“Americans,” Churchill allegedly said, “can always be trusted to do the right thing, once all other possibilities have been exhausted.” We like distraction. We may even be addicted to it.
Maybe that’s all politics and all people. But one of the things that has been true of American politics for a long time is a preference for distraction over problem solving and policy making.
We have been talking about global warming for a long time, for example, but doing very little about it. Ditto, immigration. Unfortunately, denial and distraction generally lead to more of the same, sometimes by a grand multiple.
Scapegoats and enemies
America in the 1950s had real problems, including Soviet aggression and the romance of Marxism. Race, domestic violence, and social conformity were simmering below the surface.
Instead of really dealing with any of it, we engaged in scapegoatism — the hunt for communists under every bed. The search for ”enemies within.”
We practiced “the paranoid style of American politics,” in which anyone on the left was accused of communist sympathies. Being “a little pink” could obliterate a person’s livelihood. Witch hunts are part of our national DNA, sadly.
And distraction is sometimes our life’s blood: Let’s not talk about Dad’s alcoholism. Let’s talk about Mom’s housekeeping or junior’s poor grades. And find an excuse external to ourselves for our woes: The boss. The noisy, nosy neighbors. The “lazy” teachers. The other.
Scapegoats work. Distractions rule. But these distractions cost us, because the real problems fester. And, sometimes, when they reach a boiling point, we choose the worst possible solution — another scapegoat. Or a big, broad “solution” that we know is a con.
Our country is in deep distraction and scapegoat mode right now. If immigrants aren’t scapegoats enough, how about we blame the government for our problems? A tried and true whipping boy, even for people who personally and financially benefit from government.
Until the Social Security check is late or comes no more at all. Until it is no longer safe to fly.
Two problems
I want to give two examples of issues we are currently ignoring, in our distraction inebriation. One is a small-bore issue that is emblematic of our broken health insurance system. The other is macro, and is perhaps the key to how our politics has gotten so stupid and so dishonest.
The first is the war on independent pharmacies. According to the New York Times, plan benefit managers, or PBMs, which corporations and government agencies hire to oversee prescription drug benefits, “have been systematically underpaying small pharmacies, helping to drive hundreds out of business.”
Independent pharmacies, increasingly, cannot afford to fill prescriptions for their patients. They lose money on them. Many small pharmacies will perish, resulting in pharmacy deserts and gaping holes in neighborhoods and towns — in community.
Why? Well, economic predation. Greed. Many PBMs run their own pharmacy companies.
This issue may seem relatively small. But lives will be lost. And it touches on denial of care by insurance companies; cost of drugs that many Americans need to survive; lack of students going to pharmacy school (too much debt and too little eventual income): A broken system.
Is there a simple solution? No. The system is incredibly complex.
But we are not dealing with the fissures at all. We are distracting ourselves with a dismantling of the federal government, which we will eventually have to reconstitute.
Because we need government. Complex economies require a functional government to referee and repair. Yet, we fiddle while D.C. burns (from the match we lit).
A wider and deeper problem: About 28% of adults in the United States are reading at a rudimentary level. Some 45 million Americans read on the fifth grade level or below. For the modern workplace, this is functional illiteracy. The skills of Americans in numeracy and computers are even lower.
And these trends have accelerated in the last five years. You can’t get to critical thinking or civic obligation if people cannot read, add and subtract.
Worth noting: Literacy is declining in much of the world, just as authoritarian movements and parties are on the rise. It does not take a prophet or a scholar to make the correlation.
In roughly 1440, Johannes Guttenberg invented the printing press. And for some 600 years, much of the world got smarter. Ordinary people could now read Wordsworth or St. Paul.
Distracting internet
With the invention of the Internet, and the ubiquity of the cell phone, a great many of us are getting more distracted, more illiterate, and, as night follows day, more irrational and reckless.
Democracy does die in darkness. Ignorance is fed by distraction and propaganda, and then recycled. And when social problems hit the viral point, it is all too easy to choose a new distraction.
Righting a careening polity, like righting a family, or a soul, takes brutal honesty and the courage to change.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Government is art, not performance.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.