President Trump, acting within his authority, has made it clear that he sees value in significantly increasing tariffs in order to achieve multiple policy objectives. These objective include:
Increasing government revenues; stopping the illegal movement of immigrants and drugs across our borders; equalizing reciprocal tariffs so that foreign companies do not have an unfair advantage in their home countries; bringing back employment opportunities for American workers, especially in the manufacturing sector; and protecting certain industries, such as steel and aluminum, from overseas competition.
One objective that is noticeably missing is the historical use of tariff policy to encourage other countries to politically align themselves with the United States. Trump is an isolationist and encouraging closer relations with other countries, including those on his own continent, does not appear to interest him.
A costly reduction
Even if President Trump has some success in achieving one or more of these objectives, the overall reduction in international trade will cost us dearly.
Having a low tariff policy, even if we run large trade deficits with our largest trading partners, allows us to import those goods and services that can satisfy our wants and needs.
As explained by Nobel Prize winning economist Milton Friedman: “The gain from foreign trade,” our automobiles, computers, pharmaceuticals, cell phones, etc., “is what we import. What we export is the cost of getting those imports.”
This understanding leads Friedman to the understanding of what our nation’s objective should be when it comes to international trade. “The proper objective for a nation, as Adam Smith put it, is to arrange things so we get as large a volume of imports as possible for as small a volume of exports as possible.”
Tariffs, by increasing the cost of imports, interferes with the objective of “getting as large a volume of imports as possible for as small a volume of exports.”
Having multiple objectives that require higher tariffs run counter to Mr. Friedman’s sole objective. Moreover, trying to achieve one or more of the other objectives at the same time will have unintended consequences.
Unintended consequences
For example, raising tariffs in order to bring back manufacturers jobs home will have a negative impact on our supply chains and therefore constrain domestic employment.
This is because supply chain inputs such as capital goods (approximately $1 trillion worth, excluding automobiles) account for approximately 75% of U.S. imports. If tariffs raise the prices of those imports, the production of many final products may no longer be economically viable, and the industries that import and produce them will lose work and therefore jobs.
Higher tariffs as a means to raise revenues may also invite a trade war where the sale of our exports will be blocked by retaliatory tariffs and quotas. This will also have a negative impact on U.S. employment levels.
The first thing Mr. Trump must do is to determine the primary objective of his tariff policy. That objective should be “getting as large a volume of imports as possible for as small a volume of exports.” Without always having his eye on this objective, the President may inadvertently kill the golden goose that international trade provides.
He should then think of his other objectives as constraints on this primary objective. For each constraint he can then ask himself how much in imports he believes Americans should forego and other costs Americans will endure in order to meet that constraint. This process will help him visualize the trade-offs he is making.
Reducing risks
To minimize the risk of harmful results, the President should reduce the number of objectives he is trying to achieve through his tariff policy. This will reduce the risk of unintended consequences.
He can also choose objectives that support each other. For example, threatening retaliatory tariffs if other countries do not reduce their tariffs to match ours. Successful negotiations may eventually lead to the lowering of reciprocal tariff rates that not only match but go below our current tariffs.
If President Trump is not able to properly manage his tariff policy, a significant reduction in the economic benefits we receive through international trade will be the result. We can only hope for the best.
Bernard S. Sharfman is a research fellow with the Law & Economics Center at George Mason University’s Antonin Scalia Law School. The opinions expressed here do not represent the official positions of the Law & Economics Center. His previous article was “Can Congress tell the president what to do?”.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.