It used to be said that politics is the art of the possible. These days the art, or craft, seems increasingly impossible. Indeed, many of our politicians are not even trying. The Republican majority in the Senate and House have zero legislative agenda. And they may not be able to produce a budget.
This is not new. When the Democrats were last in control of the Senate, and during the Obama years, the Republican minority seldom responded to Democratic proposals with counter proposals. They just said “no.”
It was new then.
Unwilling to govern
A different example: In many of our major cities, Democratic mayors seem utterly unwilling to govern.
Our cities have very specific problems that need nuanced and targeted responses. I’ll name three: Police forces that feel disempowered but also are ill-prepared for their modern roles. The homeless-mental health problem. And the lack of housing for young people and the working poor, exacerbated by the predatory practices of corporations that are now swallowing up free standing homes as well as apartment buildings. Young people are being gouged for rents.
In addition, most cities have major infrastructure problems that have been ignored for years — crumbling bridges, aging sewer and water systems, and poorly patched streets full of dangerous potholes.
Even though Democratic voter registration heavily favors Democrats in most cities, at some point Democratic mayors and councils are going to have to own their failure to grapple.
The police problem is hard. The homeless problem is harder. The housing shortage has no easy answer. I don’t think we want the federal government building more “projects,” like those in Chicago, Brooklyn, and Philly.
But, there are housing authorities in all of our cities and there is a federal housing department. What about low interest loans to both builders and buyers to incentivize home building? I am talking about homes, not apartments, in both the suburbs and in cities.
It’s not a simple problem. No urban problem is. But cities need proximate solutions, partial remedies, governing.
One-party rule has not been healthy. And the hold that wokeness and political correctness has on politics in our cities has sometimes paralyzed urban governance. Politics became performative.
And if politics is the craft of the possible, government is the craft of the partial fix — of ameliorating, improving and partially restoring.
The craft of government is not unlike dentistry. The purpose of a dentist is not primarily cosmetic. His purpose is to help people by addressing their problems.
Performing government
This is the purpose of government, and the only justification of high taxes and a large government apparatus on the local, state and federal levels.
But our governors are not governing. They are performing.
The Trump presidency is purely performative. There are no policy goals. The president has passing thoughts and whims. He throws them at the media wall. Some stick for a moment or two.
And the adopted purpose of the GOP congressional majorities is not to legislate, or to do oversight, but to dance to the music of Donald.
Governing, actual governing, looks like this: a) Identify an area where citizens need help; b) Debate the possible remedies; c) Via compromise and the legislative process, pass legislation that addresses the problem. This is policy making.
The president, mayor, or governor is charged with implementing policy. And if that person is good at the job, he or she was an integral part of shaping the new policy.
All that said, “the crooked timber of humanity,” can never be “fixed.” Some problems are unsolvable. But we can help. Better is still better. We can give everyone a shot.
The New Deal made life better. Social Security continues to make life better. Clean air and water; safe food; safe air travel — all are reasons for government.
Failing to govern because it is hard discredits government. Attacking and dismantling government is malpractice. People get hurt.
I mentioned oversight. Many years ago I interviewed a young freshman senator named Joe Biden. He was impressed by another freshman: Hubert Humphrey had come back to the Senate after losing the 1968 presidential race. Senator Humphrey would regularly call mid-level bureaucrats to check up on the implementation of a bill he’d worked on. And he listened to their feedback.
This is government. This is the constitutional means of accountability.
Simmering crises
While the president and his minions perform, and create new government dysfunction, at least three systemic failures are simmering: One is the housing crisis I noted.
One is the health insurance system: A guy’s $50 inhaler goes to $600 and he winds up dying. (We need Medicare for all.)
And the third is our transportation system. We can no longer afford our cars, personally or socially. Our air travel system is broken. Our bus and train systems are anemic.
We need public policy. Legislators who legislate. Governors who serve and protect.
Government is a craft. Like fixing teeth. It’s not entertainment.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Immigration is a wedge to divide Americans.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.