When pressed by White House reporters to explain what he thought caused the recent deadly midair collision between a military helicopter and a commercial airline, President Trump blamed the incident on DEI.
When asked to supply evidence for his claim, he replied, “I have common sense.” His assessment reveals how easily “common sense” can be commandeered as a rhetorical trope to justify one claim while dismissing others.
As the philosopher S.A. Grave once pointed out, common sense distinguishes, or claims to, what makes sense from what doesn’t. It “produces the feeling” that any argument posed against it is “precarious,” if not “manifestly absurd.”
Traditional common sense
Common sense appeals are deeply rooted in Western political and intellectual traditions. Thomas Paine’s famous “Common Sense” pamphlet advocated for American independence from Great Britain as if it were obviously right.
What is called Common Sense philosophy marshaled common sense to quarrel with philosophers who were skeptical about what human beings can know about the world. As one philosopher put it, in understanding the world, “the learned and the unlearned, the philosopher and the day-labourer, are upon a level.”
Certainly, reasonable people can find many knowledge claims about the world commonsensical. However, common sense appeals in political discourse are not always as “commonsensical” as they appear.
For one thing, one person or group’s common sense may contrast sharply with the common sense of others whose intuitions lead to different common sense interpretations. What Trump sees as the obvious explanation for an accident because he opposes DEI initiatives will not be obvious to those who support them.
Problematic, as well, is that speakers can blithely ignore the validity of an opponent’s arguments given what they believe is their own unassailable and overriding common sense. Trump is not accepting any alternative explanation, though they are as plausible as his.
And commonsensical understandings that everyone holds (e.g., the earth is flat) often prove wrong later, when better knowledge reveals more about the world.
Oversimplifying complications
Worrisome, too, is how common sense oversimplifies complicated issues. For example, some people’s common sense convinces them that a single, obvious cause leads to a particular effect, even though many effects have multiple and confounding causes. Like air accidents.
Moreover, common sense allows speakers to overgeneralize about things and people they consider nonsensical. Speakers might dismantle a policy deemed nonsensical when only a revision is necessary.
Ideally, in democracies, political speakers should provide rational proof for their commonsensical intuitions. Otherwise, their explanations risk circularity: I know policy x to be nonsensical because my common sense is right, and my common sense is right because it tells me policy x is nonsensical.
In other words, to be commonsensical — to show “common sense, or practical knowledge and judgment,“ as dictionaries define it, means that common sense must be shared by people who have had similar experiences. So, in some ways, there is no ”common sense” unless it is validated by widely shared evidence.
Still, it’s a testament to the resiliency of American democracy that political speakers representing different political views have frequently achieved agreement on complex issues despite rival commonsensical interpretations. However, speakers with self-proclaimed common sense can conveniently bypass public deliberation and consensus-building, because these democratic norms don’t accept their idea of common sense.
Dogmatic speech
Framing difficult and controversial public concerns as simple common sense can enhance a speaker’s credibility and appear to refute dissenters, while seeming to cut through the confusing, nettlesome intricacies of public debate.
Speakers who establish only themselves and their loyal followers as possessing an authoritative grasp of reality because of their superior common sense can deploy common sense as a rhetorical cudgel against anything and anyone they dislike.
Such dogmatic speech, which doesn’t engage other points of view and other evidence, tell us to beware of common sense.
Kenneth Zagacki is a professor of communication at North Carolina State University. Richard Cherwitz is professor emeritus at the Moddy College of Communication at the University of Texas at Austin. Their previous article was “Why 'weird' isn't a weird tactic for the Harris campaign.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.