In December 2023, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky announced a strategy to deploy one million drones into the battlefield against Russia. Since then, other world leaders, including North Korea’s Kim Jong Un, have ordered the mass production of suicide drones.
Drones are a new and very dangerous class of weaponry — cheap, easily deployed and highly lethal. They’re almost perfect weapons for bad actors, whether states or terrorists.
Civilian threats
This all-in commitment from many nations a marks a seismic shift in the civilian threat landscape, not only for Central Europe but also for major cities worldwide. Those cities include Pittsburgh, and other cities crucial to the American economy whose infrastructure is vulnerable.
Unlike New York and Washington D.C., cities like Pittsburgh aren’t generally seen as high-profile targets. Suicide drones make attacking these smaller but important cities easier and more attractive.
In early December of last year, New Jersey residents demanded to know what was going on with the strange lights hovering in the night sky over their homes and businesses. But perhaps more concerning than the sightings themselves, to them and to us, was the chaotic government response.
No one, before or since, has confirmed what the drones were or where they came from. State and federal officials did not even have a count of how many drones actually flew over the state, instead accusing residents of “over-reporting,” and of mistaking other celestial objects, like helicopters and meteors, for drones.
Despite apparently having zero information about them, the FBI and New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy nevertheless agreed that they “don’t pose a national security or public safety threat.” How could they know this, if they didn’t know what they were?
We have seen this movie before, most recently in the early days of the Covid-19 crisis, when government obfuscation and lack of coordination between its various levels (local, state and federal) generated confusion and chaos, and the outrage some people still feel.
We’re unprepared
After the New Jersey drone debacle, we should all be sounding alarm bells about our complacency in the face of this new threat.
Complacency comes in a variety of forms — misplaced hope, denial, fatalism — but the results are always the same. It leaves you flat-footed in the face of imminent threats. It prevents us from doing what needs to be done to avoid a worst-case outcome. The antidote to complacency is vigilance, that is, having a plan for what we will do when the suicide drone attacks start.
Such a plan would start by breaking down the walls between the various silos (the Department of Homeland Security, DoD, Federal Aviation Administration, FBI, etc.) within the federal government itself. It would re-establish the broken connections with law enforcement at the state and local level.
It would establish accountability: who is going to keep the watch around the clock, assess the threat in real time and notify everyone with a need to know? New technology will be required, whether it be to create an impenetrable dome, new jamming technology or high-tech weaponry to shoot drones out of the sky.
Only business and certain parts of the military have this kind of know-how. This new plan would build the public-private ventures we will need to get this done.
A new nightmare
My new 9/11 nightmare is that, on a crisp autumn morning in some not-too-distant September, Pittsburgh awakens to the menacing hum of dozens or hundreds, of unmanned aerial vehicles hovering in a clear blue sky.
Each drone, remotely controlled with its own set of eyes, carries a devastating payload intended for a range of soft targets, to disrupt in the region’s life and economy, and cause terror when people realize how vulnerable they are: targets like the international airport terminal, PPG Place, Acrisure Stadium, the Tepper Quad at CMU and UPMC Presbyterian Shadyside and the other major hospitals.
The drones might also be intended — odds are they would be — for harder targets, to cause even greater damage and disruption, like the region’s power plants, especially the nuclear power plant in Shippingport, sewage treatment facilities, and all the region’s crucial bridges and rail lines.
Just a handful of well-aimed drones would change the life of every resident of Southwestern Pennsylvania. Imagine the region losing power during the current cold. Many people would die just from that damage.
City and state governments are responsible to safeguard their people and both play an important role in preparing for this new and fearsome threat. But it is the responsibility of the federal government to prepare us for the worst case scenario.
I am confident that it will eventually do this. The only question is whether it does it the easy way, by figuring it out beforehand, or the hard way, in the chaotic aftermath of a 9/11 redux.
Kelly McKinney is the Vice President of Emergency Management at NYU Langone Health in New York City and a former deputy commissioner at the New York City Office of Emergency Management. His previous article was “The urgent need to ready America for a nuclear crisis.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.