Shortly after college football’s transfer portal opened — a new post-Thanksgiving ritual that rivals Black Friday in dollars spent and pandemonium — fans were treated a breaking news bulletin usually reserved for the professionals: “Sources: Kansas quarterback Jalon Daniels has agreed to a new deal to stay with the Jayhawks for 2025,” ESPN’s Pete Thamel posted on X on Dec. 6.
A new deal? For a college athlete?
That’s the wild world we live in now, where the idea of Name, Image and Likeness has evolved well past the days of Kenny Pickett getting free dinners for his Pitt offensive lineman. It’s now full-fledged free agency, without the benefit of knowing any of the contractual details. There is no obligation to report NIL revenue or expenses.
While ideas are being kicked around on Capitol Hill about regulating athletic purchasing power for universities — or, more specifically, their most ardent and wealthy alumni — for now, we’re stuck in purgatory between the hush-hush deals we always knew were going on (but were illegal) and the sort-of-public announcements we’re seeing now.
To say the game has changed would be a massive understatement. But has it been “ruined”? Not so fast.
Adolescent athletics
We are witnessing college athletes in an adolescent stage: rebelling against the parents at NCAA headquarters, earning their own living and stepping into a future both bright and loaded with landmines. And with adolescence comes awkwardness, which we feel every time a new “deal” is announced for a player.
But you can blame those in charge for that: for dragging their feet on giving players a seat at the table and then finally doing so without any guardrails or long-term planning.
As we enter the new 12-team College Football Playoff, we can see all three stages of the sport’s growth laid out in front of us.
SMU, once given the “death penalty” by the NCAA for giving football players money and gifts, will play at Penn State. Georgia, a recent powerhouse rivaled only by Alabama, has adjusted to the new world and has a first-round bye. And Indiana, the school with literally the most losses of any football program in history, masterfully played the portal and NIL game to earn a date at Notre Dame, the school possibly most associated worldwide with the words “college football.” (Full disclosure: This writer attended IU and saw many pre-portal teams get stomped.)
It’s not your father’s game (or even your older brother’s), and there’s no doubt the landscape will look even more different in a few years.
Big business
It’s hard in a capitalist society to argue that college kids getting paid for their job is a bad thing. Yes, they also receive a full scholarship and amenities the average student could never dream of — but that’s how the world works. The supremely gifted are granted special access.
I hope my daughter one day becomes good enough at anything to receive a free college ride. But if that comes as an academic scholarship, I understand people will not pay her for the right to watch her study in their school’s colors.
This past year, EA Sports released its “College Football 25” video game featuring real names and likenesses of players, and in October it was deemed the best-selling U.S. football game of all time, beating out “Madden NFL 07.” Fans are not only watching these athletes: They are pretending to be them. And, unlike in previous iterations, this year’s game comes with a paycheck for those who opted in.
College sports have always been big business. Now, they have some junior executives.
Portal to the future
If NIL money is the nail, the transfer portal has become the hammer. Not getting enough playing time? Enter the portal. Not getting enough money? Portal. Simply want attention and a cool social media graphic? Portal!
Since it first opened in 2018-19, the total number of football players in FBS (Division I) who have transferred has more than doubled from 1,561 in 2018-19 to over 3,700, according to NCAA data.
More than the money, this is the element that threatens to hurt the game. Where fans once could become attached to a group of players four years at time, now it truly is a year-to-year plan.
Pitt, for example, watched Pickett grow for four years with the program before putting on a Heisman-level showcase in his fifth year. Since he went to the NFL after the 2021 season, the Panthers have had three different quarterbacks start the year — all from the transfer portal.
Perhaps a future payroll system will lessen the incentive to find greener pastures in this wild west of shadow money. But right now, even the most diehard fan will need a few weeks each year to learn the new names.
Eventually, the dust will settle, rules will be in place and major college sports will all-but-officially be what they’ve always been in practice: a free minor league system for the professional leagues.
College sports will grow up. But for now, embrace the clumsiness and chaos. We’ll never get these years back.
Ryan Winn is the assistant managing editor for sports for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: rwinn@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.