When you stepped into office, Mr. President, many of us felt renewed optimism. We knew you opposed the death penalty, and we heard you supported life sentences without parole instead of capital punishment. For many, this felt like a hopeful sign that we might see a shift away from retribution and toward a more compassionate approach to justice.

This fall, I interned with a nonprofit advocating for changes to our criminal justice system. Through this work, I’ve learned just how deeply inequities run within the system, where justice isn’t equal, and how devastating the consequences can be. But my awakening to these injustices began earlier.

I attended a Witness to Innocence event last year in Manhattan, where I met death row exonerees, including Ray Krone, the 100th person in the U.S. exonerated from death row, and Sabrina Butler, the first woman on death row to be exonerated. Their stories brought the reality of capital punishment into sharp focus, underscoring the systemic failures in every corner of our country. Their freedom proves that mistakes can be corrected — but had they been executed, those mistakes would have been permanent, and our failure as a society irreversible.

Human complexity

Today, 40 people remain on federal death row. The decision to execute them is not just a legal one but a moral choice that speaks to our nation’s values.

Advertise with us

Before the Trump administration, federal executions were rare: Only three had been carried out since the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated the federal death penalty in 1988. But in the final days of President Trump’s term, this changed drastically, as 13 individuals were executed.

Among them was Brandon Bernard, who was only 18 when he committed his crime. Science shows us that the rational part of a teenager’s brain isn’t fully developed until around age 25. Knowing this, how can we ignore the role of age and human development in shaping actions? Even the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 2005 that the death penalty is unconstitutional for juveniles. Yet Bernard, though barely an adult at the time of his crime, was not afforded the same consideration. Our system didn’t deem him mature enough to order a drink, yet it deemed him mature enough to be sentenced to death.

Another case was that of Lisa Montgomery, a woman so profoundly mentally ill as a result of a lifetime of torture and sexual violence that her execution shocked even those who have long supported capital punishment.

Cases like these reveal the human complexity behind crimes. No person is inherently evil. There is always context that shapes the choices people make. While such context doesn’t excuse the act, it does compel us to seek justice rooted in mercy, not vengeance.

Compassion and hope

As a young person watching the results of the recent presidential election unfold, I’m concerned we’re entering a phase where we’re moving toward leading with an iron fist, and seeing justice as merely retribution.

Advertise with us

What we need from you now, more than ever, Mr. President, is compassionate leadership — leadership that shows we stand firm in our values, even when they are most tested. Justice must be tempered with mercy, especially in a country founded on the ideals of equality and the sanctity of human life. My generation needs to witness this from our leaders if we are to grow up believing that empathy, integrity and justice for all are not just aspirations but promises we consistently uphold.

I implore you to commute the sentences of those on federal death row. In doing so, you would set a legacy rooted in compassion and fairness, showing that even in our darkest hour, America chooses healing over retribution.

We need that kind of leadership heading into these next four years. We need that kind of hope.

Sienna Walenciak is a sophomore at the University of Pittsburgh and a fall intern with the Responsible Business Initiative for Justice. She lives in Easton, Pa.