I went overseas for school when I was 20 and I met a girl, and for a quarter-century lived in Rome, where Thanksgiving is just another day. I got used pretty easily to getting up and going to work on the fourth Thursday in November.

Looking back on those years, I understand two things more fully now. One is how eerie was the feeling, and why, that I ought to have been doing something else not only on the day but in the days leading up to the day.

The other is how important is community for the cultivation of gratitude, which is not so much a feeling as an attitude of the spirit and an aptitude of the soul.

Thanksgiving in Rome

There’s a sizeable American expat presence in Rome and there are a couple of big regular Thanksgiving gatherings, but I don’t recall ever going to one of them. Some other Americans, I know, would put on the whole kit ‘n’ kaboodle every year. There was no expectation that one do it, though.

Advertise with us

Some Romans — the day was well known as an American holiday — would ask whether we celebrated or would be celebrating, and I would explain the days of prep that go into Thanksgiving. They’d understand why we couldn’t or wouldn’t be doing that as a matter of course, especially when everyone else wasn’t doing the same thing.

One year, Profs. Giorgio Salzano and Elena Mannucci — Giorgio’s wife — hosted us. If memory serves, we celebrated on the third Thursday in November rather than the fourth. Elena did the cooking. The meal was exquisitely executed, and if you’ve never roasted a whole turkey before nor prepared pretty much any of the sides and desserts, that is no mean feat.

My recollection is that Elena made New York cheesecake for dessert, not exactly a Thanksgiving staple perhaps, but a taste of home for me and a favorite dessert of her husband’s, another professor, from his years in the United States.

It was an act of friendship for their American friend (my wife is Italian), recreating one of his national traditions, and doing so, except for the cheesecake, authentically and at no small effort.

That Thanksgiving in Rome was special, I’d say too special, because the circle of fellowship was tightly drawn. Thanksgiving in America is ordinary and for that reason capacious.

Advertise with us

Society’s decision

I found I had missed the days of preparation and travel planning and all the other business about the day far more than I realized when I returned with my family to the States in 2021.

There’s something about a whole society deciding — as the collective “we” that we are has decided — to stop and give thanks to heaven. I would not have seen that, had I not lived so many years abroad.

I’ve often wondered what, if anything, the fact of our official gratitude says about us. It’s not that we are especially grateful by comparison with other peoples, that’s for sure.

We recognize that gratitude is the proper disposition, and that — perhaps — says something about the kind of people we would like to think we are. That’s not quite the same as saying it is a sign of the kind of people we aspire to be, but it may remind us there is a “we” to speak of, a community that recognizes itself in an act of thanks-giving.

The thing I missed most

After our children were born, we would sometimes and somehow mark Thanksgiving Day in our house. One year, we pulled out all the stops and did the whole thing for ourselves. It was great fun, but there was less delight in being different than there is in being like everyone else.

Advertise with us

“Thanks, ladies!” I said to the receptionists in the office I was visiting the other day. “If I don’t see you, have a Happy Thanksgiving!” Then, to the fellow in the waiting room: “Happy Thanksgiving to you, Sir!” and he, a total stranger, returned the greeting with a smile.

That’s the thing I missed the most, when I was over there. I mean the knock-on effects of our common civic decision for gratitude.

Happy Thanksgiving to you all.

Christopher R. Altieri is a journalist and editor and author of “The soul of a nation: America as a tradition of inquiry and nationhood.” His previous article was “Does the Pope matter anymore?”