Many people, when first hearing Donald Trump speak extemporaneously — myself included — hear the glib generalities, repetitiveness, bombast, 3rd grade level name-calling, along with the hint of an inability to explain anything substantive, and think the man a fool, with a slightly above-average IQ at best. Adjectives like boorish, buffoonish, immature, insecure, etc., spring to mind.

I certainly felt that way from at least 2015 through 2018 or so. But I gradually began to ask myself how such an intellect could almost always end up making what I viewed as smart decisions, such as with his cuts to various taxes and heavy-handed regulations, his stances on trade deals such as NAFTA and the TPP, the NATO alliance, Iran and the Middle East, North Korea, China, etc.

Speaking and doing

I’m no psychologist, and have read only one of his (co-written) books, “The Art of the Comeback.” I’ve no special insight into his mind, but I do think I have an insight into one aspect of his public performance that explains the gap between the way he speaks and what he does.

My main hypothesis is that, like me, Donald has a below-average recall memory, but excellent recognition memory and way above-average analytical skills. Those latter two mental qualities allow him, when all the pro and con arguments are set before him — either in writing or speech from his team of advisors — to see in his mind’s eye how the dynamics will play out, generating good decisions on his part.

Advertise with us

On the other hand, people with excellent recall memory usually make very good story-tellers, able to bring in all the small details that enrich a telling. Such people are able, without much preparation, to give detailed, professorial-type lectures. If they lack analytical skills, however, they are likely to be relatively unsuccessful in life.

Donald, conversely, has been very successful in life. But if he, weeks after making a decision on a difficult topic, decides to speak impromptu on that topic, such as during one of his rambling, 2-hour rally speeches, he’s unable to recall the specifics that went into making his decision.

He’s not at all like a well-prepared college professor giving a lecture, listing all the pros and cons and providing astute analysis. Instead, he resorts to generalities and superlatives (“the greatest/biggest,” “most incredible/unbelievable/phenomenal,” “the likes of which the world has never seen,” etc.), and denigrates those who disagree with his decision as stupid, low IQ, etc.

To attain a more comprehensive view of Trump’s aptitude for making favorable deals for the U.S., one must consider also his long experience negotiating one-on-one with bank and real estate executives, involving personal assessments of both their intentions and capabilities.

Thus, his penchant for establishing cordial, productive working relationships with the leaders of adversarial countries: North Korea, China, Russia, and the Taliban of Afghanistan. Throw in his long history of being rewarded for his showmanship in the worlds of professional wrestling and mixed martial arts, and his long stint in reality TV, and Trump as both Dealmaker and Entertainer comes more into focus.

Advertise with us

Entertainer and showman

This last part, about his entertainer/showman persona, may lead one to question whether he actually has a sub-par recall memory, or simply chooses not to give many details in his speeches, thinking those details will bore his audience and slow down the flow of his “carnival pitchman”-type performance. I reject that view, as I’m sure that somewhere during his two-hour rally speeches all of those details would spill out if he actually had them in mind, within easy reach.

In short, I think that Donald the Speaker is not the intellectual lightweight he seems, while Donald the Decider is top-notch.

Harold Kyriazi, who holds a Ph.D. in Biochemistry from the University of Pittsburgh, is the author of “Libertarian Party at Sea on Land.” His previous article was “How to understand Donald Trump and avoid TDS.”