In the shocked sputtering, bitter outbursts and just plain mourning in some quarters over the second election of President Donald Trump, the one-word explanation for the outcome is “misogyny.”
Talking heads from Sunny Hostin to Al Sharpton to Joe Scarborough allege that the misogyny of Trump voters is the main reason for Kamala Harris’s loss.
The dominant trope
Even in the more reflective realm of digital and print media, misogyny is the dominant trope. A New York Times piece titled “Men? Maybe Not,” reports that while some women feel “numb resignation,” others are channeling their disappointment into anger toward men as a whole.” They are experiencing “heteropessimism.”
“It turns out the United States is pretty damn sexist,” states an article titled “Men got exactly what they wanted” on slate.com. “Gender was a major driver of Trump’s victory in 2016,” the writer, Jill Filipovic, continues. “Eight years later, pundits and analysts will be hunting for a newer, fresher explanation. But sometimes the truth simply asserts itself on repeat.”
Is that “the truth”? Is contempt for women the reason why Kamala Harris and Hillary Clinton both lost bids to become the first female American president?
The only “newer, fresher explanation” anyone has hunted down is the not-so-new one, “racism.” To be sure, there are some ugly woman-haters out there, but as election analysis, misogyny just doesn’t hold water.
Read More
The candidate who won is infamous for sexist utterances and brutish actions, but we all know good people who held their noses and voted for him despite this, not because of it.
What if American voters would actually like to elect a woman, just as a majority elected Barack Obama twice?
What if the kinder and truer explanation for America not having done so is that neither party has yet found a strong enough candidate — particularly not in the fraught Trump era?
Think about the Black candidates who came before President Obama. In 1984 Jesse Jackson finished third in the Democratic primaries. Republican Alan Keyes won a handful of convention votes in 2000, and Democrat Al Sharpton won 26 delegates in 2004. None of these men had any experience in office. All three had substantial baggage.
It wasn’t until Mr. Obama’s meteoric rise from Illinois legislature to U.S. Senate that American voters found a Black candidate with both experience and wide appeal.
Why would a woman candidate face any less rigorous a vetting?
A rigorous vetting
Hillary Clinton practiced law and served as First Lady of Arkansas before her husband Bill won the White House. Despite her lack of first-hand governing experience, her husband gave her the lead role in health care reform. It did not go well. She returned to more traditional endeavors.
At the end of her husband’s presidency, Mrs. Clinton stepped right into the U.S. Senate and, after just one term, ran for the Democratic presidential nomination. She lost to Mr. Obama. He made her Secretary of State.
By 2016, the Clintons (now multi-millionaires) had been on the national stage for a quarter century. In retrospect it isn’t quite as shocking that a brash real-estate mogul would defeat a woman many voters were tired of and perceived as largely riding on her husband’s coattails.
Kamala Harris rose from San Francisco District Attorney to California Attorney General to U.S. Senator in just 13 years. But having launched a presidential bid in 2019, a scant two years into her Senate term, she withdrew 11 months later — before the primaries began — due to fundraising failure.
Despite this underwhelming effort, Joe Biden tapped her as his running mate, and voters got four years to evaluate her. Biden appointed her “immigration czar,” and the immigration crisis was one of the top problems on Americans’ minds this year, behind an inflation-distorted economy.
A New York Times reporter wrote, “The compounding rejection of first Hillary Clinton then Ms. Harris has exposed an uncomfortable but steady undercurrent of American society: Women do not necessarily agree on what counts as progress or a setback.”
Why is this an “uncomfortable” truth? Why should all women think alike? Men don’t.
It is sexist to demand a woman vote for a woman just because she’s a woman.
Black women voted overwhelmingly for Ms. Harris, but 20% of Black men — a modern record — voted for Mr. Trump. Perhaps this is because during his presidency their employment opportunities reached an all-time high.
A majority of white women with college degrees voted for Harris; those without opted for Trump.
America’s great divide
The deeper you dig into voter demographics, the more likely it seems that our great divide is class. More people voted not by racial and gender identity but for the candidate whose vision and experience brought more hope and opportunity into their lives.
Despite my longstanding, public assessment of Donald Trump as unworthy of the presidency, I reject the claim of widespread, pervasive misogyny.
There are already so many things that divide us. We don’t need another festering wound — especially if it’s bogus.
Ruth Ann Dailey was a columnist for the Post-Gazette from 2000 to August 2024. She still creates the newspaper’s crossword puzzles. She can be reached at ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.