The Supreme Court's decision in Trump v. United States has been widely and severely criticized across the spectrum of commentators, including several retired and senior judges characterized as liberal, conservative, Republican or Democrat, from the Court of Appeals on down. But all is not lost.
Let us review the history. Following the August 2023 four-count indictment in Federal District Court for D.C., Donald Trump filed a Notice of Appeal. Special Counsel Jack Smith filed a request to fast-track the case to the Supreme Court on Dec. 11, which was denied.
The Supreme Court decides
Subsequently the case was heard before the U.S. Court of Appeals for D.C., which ruled in favor of the prosecution. Predictably, Trump requested a hearing before the Supreme Court on the question of “Whether and if so to what extent does a President enjoy presidential immunity from criminal prosecution for conduct alleged to involve official acts during his tenure in office.” Oral argument was heard in April and the decision was rendered on July 1.
Briefly, the Court declared that a former president has absolute immunity from criminal prosecution for “official acts,” presumptive immunity for “acts within the outer perimeter of his official responsibilities,” and no immunity for “private acts,” while he is in office.
The Court also ruled that inquiry into the defendant's motives is impermissible, but rejected Trump’s argument that a president must be impeached and convicted by the Senate before being prosecuted for any acts performed while in office.
I believe the Court made several missteps that ultimately led to a decision that has received more criticism from a wide swath of the legal community than any other in recent memory. Why is that so?
First, the oral argument before the Court focused largely on vague references to the doctrine of separation of powers, and a case where civil suit had been brought against ex-president Nixon, and much speculation about imaginary scenarios that might occur in the future.
But does too much
Justice Neil Gorsuch explicitly stated that they were “writing a rule for the ages,” and both he and Justice Brett Kavanaugh stated that they were not so concerned about the present case as they were about the future — seemingly a sideways attempt to preemptively defend themselves from accusations that they might be partial to Trump. That approach seems to exceed the Court's power granted under Article III of the Constitution to decide cases and controversies.
It is also at odds with what Chief Justice John Roberts said at his confirmation hearing in 2005, calling the Dred Scott case one of “the most egregious examples of judicial activism in our history,” because “the Court went far beyond what was necessary to decide the case, and ... tried to put itself in the position of resolving the dispute about the extension of slavery, and resolving it in a particular way that it thought was best for the Nation.” In 2013, that same Chief Justice said: “If it's not necessary to decide more to dispose of a case, in my view it is necessary not to decide more.”
Here, the result was, in effect, the enactment of an amendment to the Constitution, bypassing the cumbersome requirements for amendment as prescribed in Article V. Indeed, many have claimed that only a Constitutional Amendment could overrule it and that legislation (such as the subsequently introduced No Kings Act ) would be insufficient.
Second, the Court’s December refusal to hear the case effected a delay of several months, virtually eliminating any possibility that a trial would occur before Election Day. In the end, perhaps the most damaging result of that decision may be that it deprived voters of a chance to vote for a Republican candidate who is reasonable, honest, articulate, and committed to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution.
The trial court’s turn
There is a ray of sunshine, though. In response to the Court's remanding the case to District Court to determine what are “official acts,” etc., Special Counsel Jack Smith, in filing a 165-page brief has been able to make public evidence that most of the indictment did not involve “official acts.”
Additionally, because inquiry into the defendant's motives is now impermissible, any claim by Trump himself that he sincerely believed there was election fraud to justify any of his actions is irrelevant and therefore probably inadmissible.
Now the trial court, notwithstanding the results of the Nov. 5 election, and especially in light of the now public evidence that Trump induced others to commit crimes, can and must eventually examine whether “official acts” include an abuse of presidential power in violation of his sworn oath to “preserve, protect and defend the Constitution,” or a violation of his "core" Constitutional duty to “take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed.”
Bruce Wilder is a former long-time resident of Oakland and a graduate of the University of Pittsburgh School of Law.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.