Home prices hit an all-time high this year, and both homebuyers and renters spend more per month on housing than almost ever before. President-elect Donald Trump claims he’ll bring those prices down. Will he?

Probably not.

A problem of supply

Fundamentally, it’s a problem of insufficient supply. Government regulations play a significant role in this story.

Local zoning restrictions, like those limiting housing construction to single-family homes in large swaths of our cities and suburbs, have artificially capped housing supply. Developers simply haven’t been allowed to build enough homes in highly desirable areas rich in jobs and amenities to keep up with the demand.

Advertise with us

More people competing over fewer homes means sellers and landlords can command higher prices. The people who get homes pay more to do so, and those who lose the bidding war are forced to live farther away from jobs, grocery stores, and recreational spaces.

Some cities and states have recently taken steps to correct this, but even those places must overcome the fallout from decades of bad policy from Republicans and Democrats alike.

Donald Trump’s messaging on how he might address the problem has been mixed, to say the least. He has claimed that by homing in on this problem President Biden and Democrats were waging a “war on the suburbs” and seeking to undermine suburban Americans’ way of life rooted in single-family neighborhoods.

More recently, Trump changed tone a bit and appeared to support relaxing zoning restrictions as a general matter. But he didn’t specify what sorts of restrictions he has in mind. He also supports freeing up some federal land for housing construction — a measure that will matter little unless the land sits in areas with high housing demand, like cities or inner suburbs near well-paying jobs.

Immigration and tariffs

Other key Trump policies could affect the housing market indirectly, such as cutting immigration and raising tariffs. He has claimed that restricting immigration and deporting undocumented immigrants will help keep housing prices down.

Advertise with us

The rationale seems to be that if the problem is too many people and not enough homes, then reducing the population will tilt the scales back towards affordability. One big problem with this line of argument is that immigrants make up a key portion of the housing construction workforce.

Undercut that workforce and you could make the problem of lagging housing construction even worse. Any miniscule price reduction you might’ve otherwise achieved from reducing demand for housing would likely be offset by dampening housing supply too. Immigrants help the economy thrive.

What about tariffs? Trump’s plan to raise tariffs could exacerbate the housing crisis. Tariffs are often aimed to benefit Americans by making American producers and their goods more market-competitive. But what they typically accomplish is making everything more expensive for American consumers.

American consumers feel the squeeze because products are either pricier, scarcer, or both, and that includes materials for housing construction, like lumber and major appliances. Building costs have skyrocketed in the U.S. over the past several years partly because building materials have become pricier and scarcer already.

Throw higher tariffs into the mix and what do you get? Perhaps some American companies that produce building materials could compete a little more easily in the market, but developers, builders and ultimately homebuyers and renters will have to pay more for housing construction.

Advertise with us

The path forward

We shouldn’t expect cheaper housing if we don’t make housing easier to build. Trump could support policies that would alleviate financial strain on millions of Americans, but so far his housing-related policies represent a mixed bag at best, and could cause harm.

Perhaps the silver lining is that the government policies with the greatest effect on housing production come not from the federal government, but from local and state governments. We can’t count on the next presidential administration to navigate us out of the housing crisis, but we can press local and state leaders to loosen residential zoning restrictions and streamline permitting processes.

That was the path forward before this latest election, and it’s the path forward now.

Brian M. Miller is an assistant professor of law at Duquesne University’s Thomas R. Kline School of Law. His previous article was “Mayor Gainey's great housing plan, and its one flaw.”