By this point, Pennsylvania voters could confidently assume that they have read about every major political issue and know everything there is to know about both major party candidates.
But New Jerseyans have something to share with our neighbors that may not be well known in the Keystone state. The issue concerns Donald Trump’s Bedminster golf course and resort.
The Trump Organization has paid much less than the normal property taxes for several years, leaving a tax burden that his poorer neighbors had to shoulder as a result.
A glaring injustice
The issue is an ethical more than a legal one, and it extends well beyond Trump to the larger question of how politicians in high-responsibility roles should conduct their private businesses.
As Business Insider reported in 2021, he paid a mere $700 in property taxes in 2020 for the 119-acre part of the estate that he claims is a farm because a dozen or so goats are kept there. In 2024, he also claimed to grow hay on 113 acres and counted another 70 acres as woodland and wetland, saving him at least $257,000 dollars.
A single member of Trump’s Bedminster club pays a $350,000 membership fee.
Of course, businesses have every right to seek legal ways of reducing their taxes owed. And New Jersey needs to reform its Farmland Assessment Act, which was enacted in 1964 to help poor farmers stay in business, and to reduce the loss of green spaces to housing developments and business parks.
Pennsylvania largely avoids our state’s problem of ultra-wealthy owners paying almost zero property tax by requiring at least ten contiguous acres engaged in farm production (in contrast to NJ’s five acres), or $2000 in farm produce sales (NJ only requires $1000).
And crucially, Pennsylvania requires that the farm owner live on the property to get the tax break. Trump could definitely not meet this requirement at the Bedminster club, which has never been his permanent residence.
But aside from shining light on a glaring injustice in New Jersey law, Trump’s farm tax write off raises two larger issues.
Trump’s tax avoidance
First, it is part of a larger pattern of tax avoidance by the former president.
He has found ways to pay almost no federal income tax by reporting business losses during four of the six years between 2015 and 2020. He made questionable loans to his children that auditors might count as gifts (with gift tax implications).
In January of 2023, Trump’s business was convicted of criminal fraud for off-books payments and benefits to its executives. In September 2023, the NY state supreme court also ruled against Trump in a civil cases, finding that his organization had persistently in engaged in “fraud” by inflating business valuations to potential lenders while submitting much lower valuations to tax authorities.
And this May, Trump was convicted of falsifying business records for recording as a business expense his October 2016 hush-money payment to porn star/actress Stormy Daniels.
Then there is the question of whether Trump violated the constitution’s ban on “emoluments,” which was intended to prevent corrupting monetary influence, by making millions at his hotel in Washington D.C. and his Mar-a-Lago resort in Florida from foreign leaders and business chiefs looking to benefit from connections with a Trump administration.
Courts have repeatedly dodged this issue, and Congress needs to pass a detailed statute about foreign emoluments.
However, even if Trump did nothing illegal by accepting these business benefits and registering part of his Bedminster club as a “farm” for tax purposes, the pattern raises serious questions about his ethics as a businessman.
Trump does not merely exploit every loophole within the “letter of the law.” He stretches that letter contrary to the spirit again and again.
Should a billionaire pay 2% of the normal property tax by claiming to have sold $1000 of hay, goat milk, honey, or wood on a giant resort for the super-wealthy, while knowing that this raises everyone else’s tax burden in the township? Should he use a law clearly meant for other people for public purposes?
What does this say about his sense of responsibility to his neighbors and community? About his character? Nothing good.
Hold to higher standards
Second, there is the broader point that leading politicians and civic leaders should hold themselves to higher standards. At a time when more Americans across the political spectrum fear that many politicians are corrupt, they should try to remain above suspicion and set an example by doing what’s ethically right.
In the long run, Congress needs to set stricter guidelines concerning how political leaders run their businesses. It may even be necessary to alter the constitution to require politicians to hold businesses in blind trusts during their terms in office, or longer.
John J. Davenport is professor of philosophy and peace and justice studies at Fordham University and author of “The Democracy Amendments.” Jack Curtis, a former high school principle, is an expert on the farm tax issue.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.