My friends from college, George and Arnav, had been considering voting for Donald Trump because they feel so dissatisfied with the Biden-Harris Administration. They decided that it was important to really experience a Trump rally to make their final decision.
Though a life-long Democrat appalled by Trump, on a whim, I drove with them through the night all the way from New York City to Butler, Pennsylvania.
Not a lovable meme
A lot of people we ran into while being squashed in a crowd of 20,000 people were some of the kindest people I’ve ever met. They were school bus drivers, teachers, military families, industrial workers, and community leaders whom every American can look up to.
We all chummed it up while George and Arnav cracked jokes about Biden, laughing at the lovable meme they expected Trump to be.
But then the speeches started. Over five excruciating hours, we heard speech after speech, each slowly chipping away at George and Arnav’s confidence in their vote. The Trump campaign’s mastery of mental gymnastics and manipulation was on full display.
At one point, Eric Trump claimed that the United States “has given $120 billion to Iran,” while Elon Musk declared that if the Democrats win, “this will be the last election you ever vote in.” The Democrats wanted to kill the former president.
Nearly every fact or accusation leveled by a speaker, no matter how ludicrous or demonstrably false, was gobbled up by the crowd with scattered mutterings of “amen” and “damn right.”
Various surrogates called for “unity” across America while attacking their opponents. Chants of “Fight! Fight! Fight!” broke out during these calls for reconciliation.
Lara Trump strode confidently out to the podium, announcing to the crowd that this election was not politics, but “a fight between good and evil.” Eric Trump declared that we were not a part of a political movement, but a “family.” The speakers often mentioned Jesus and Trump in the same breath.
A low-energy speech
At one point, a lone sheriff spoke about the need for civility and respecting differing opinions. Not a single clap was heard. Total silence.
A little later, I turned to my friends. They had fallen silent, their sense of fun gone.
Then Trump’s private jet appeared on the horizon. The crowd erupted in applause and adulation. Trump arrived on stage to thunderous applause, with one woman near me shedding tears of joy at his sight.
His speech, given under a for whatever reason unmistakably stained American flag, was low-energy and rambling. Gone was the sprightly, “fun” Donald Trump of 2016.
A mere half an hour into his speech, the crowd started to slowly disperse, turning into a mass exodus later-on.
Walking back to our car, George lamented how sad it was that these rally-goers, many of whom have legitimate economic and social grievances about being “left behind” in rural Pennsylvania, are being duped by a conman and his extended family into channeling their time, money and emotions into this cult-like campaign. These hard-working Americans are so much more than mere pawns in his political game.
What my friends and I found worst about the rally was the disconnect between the voters and the party leaders. These leaders, despite all their bluster, know exactly what they are doing.
They are deliberately misleading and manipulating their followers into a hateful cult, focused on a mountain of lies involving Haitian immigrants and murderous Democrats.
Watch him
The hate Americans have towards each other over this election is so unfortunate and dangerous. No one should be vilified for supporting either party.
However, if you are considering voting for Trump, like my friends, I would ask that you go online and watch one of his rallies and see firsthand the man and the movement you would be supporting.
Noah Mihan is a MSc student at the University of Oxford, specializing in energy policy, and can be reached at noah.mihan@seh.ox.ac.uk.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.