Donald Trump says that if he regains the presidency, he will veto any federal abortion ban. The man whose appointees overturned Roe v. Wade has, for now, abandoned his former hardline position against abortion.
As a person with a deeply held religious conviction that life begins at conception, I say good riddance.
The lesser evil
People opposed to abortion have hurt the movement by embracing politicians who support the death penalty, perpetual war, energy strategies that make our planet less able to support life, and economic policies that take years off the sacred lives of our least resourced neighbors.
There is no party or movement in the United States that can honestly call itself pro-life.
Pope Francis recently instructed U.S. Catholics to vote for the “lesser evil,” without naming names, but affirming that being anti-immigrant is not pro-life. The U.S. church is more conservative than the pope, and its leaders have emphasized abortion far more than other social issues. Trump’s coziness with various prominent U.S. cardinals and bishops is well documented.
During Trump’s first (and, please God, only) term, I talked with a Catholic priest working on policy for the church. He was distressed that efforts against abortion are aligned with one political party. He wanted to get gun control on the list of pro-life concerns — but he felt that was impossible to do so long as the movement had so many Republican ties.
“I’ve talked with so many Catholic women who are supporting Trump because of abortion,” my own pastor told me on the eve of the 2016 election. He shook his head. We’d met working on other issues addressed by Catholic social teaching, like access to health care and immigrant rights. We knew that our faith had a broad vision of what pro-life means. A recent Pew poll, however, shows Catholic voters favoring Trump over Kamala Harris, 52% vs. 47%.
I get aligning with a political party. That’s one way to make change. But religion is not a strategy. It should be a shining light proclaiming the truth, not just the part of the truth that supports your argument.
Trump is still making outrageous, false accusations that Democrats support the execution of newborns. I am reminded of something Dorothy Day, the founder of the Catholic Worker Movement said: “Don’t worry about being effective, just be faithful to the truth.”
Complicated truth
The truth around abortion is complicated. This is why most people don’t fall neatly into either camp, but support considerations about viability, the woman’s health, and so on. Good legislation about abortion would be difficult to craft.
We certainly don’t have it now. An investigation by ProPublica documents that abortion bans in Georgia have killed women. The rush to enact abortion bans was irresponsible. Those of us who believe life deserves protection at all stages have a special obligation to wade into this swirl of conflict and seek the advice of actual experts (e.g., doctors) on reform.
Abortion is badly suited for legislative reform. Almost all my friends are, like me, progressive. Invariably they ask if I want abortion to be illegal. I answer that I want it to be unthinkable.
Access to great health care for everyone, including contraception, is a good way to prevent abortion. I recognize that my church has been a roadblock here.
More broadly, so is the elimination of poverty, a goal that would be within this country’s reach if only our ambition extended that far. According to the pro-abortion rights Guttmacher Institute, 75% of the people seeking abortions in the U.S. are poor or low-income. Applying the word “choice” to that situation is indecent.
To steal a bit from a popular bumper sticker: Against abortion? Fight poverty.
Lives saved on both sides
Every major faith recognizes an obligation on the part of those who have much to those who have little. Many religions, including mine, go beyond the call for charity to one for justice. Let’s start there. Let’s build a society where no one feels financially pressured to abort a child.
Will that eliminate every abortion? No, but neither will abortion bans. This effort would save lives on both sides of the womb.
Such a movement would generally align more with the Democratic party than the Republican. But the Dems are still a lesser evil — sending weapons to decimate Gaza, rolling over for the fossil fuel industry, and more.
A real pro-life movement would not have a political party. It would have legitimacy.
Colleen Shaddox is co-author with Joanne Samuel Goldblum of “Broke in America: Seeing, Understanding, and Ending U.S. Poverty.” Her website is www.freecolleen.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.