Don­ald Trump says that if he re­gains the pres­i­dency, he will veto any fed­eral abor­tion ban. The man whose ap­poin­tees over­turned Roe v. Wade has, for now, aban­doned his for­mer hard­line po­si­tion against abor­tion.

As a per­son with a deeply held re­li­gious con­vic­tion that life be­gins at con­cep­tion, I say good rid­dance.

The lesser evil

People op­posed to abor­tion have hurt the move­ment by em­brac­ing pol­i­ti­cians who sup­port the death pen­alty, per­pet­ual war, en­ergy strat­e­gies that make our planet less able to sup­port life, and eco­nomic pol­i­cies that take years off the sa­cred lives of our least re­sourced neigh­bors.

There is no party or move­ment in the United States that can honestly call it­self pro-life.

Advertise with us

Pope Francis re­cently in­structed U.S. Cath­o­lics to vote for the “lesser evil,” with­out nam­ing names, but af­firm­ing that be­ing anti-im­mi­grant is not pro-life. The U.S. church is more con­ser­va­tive than the pope, and its lead­ers have em­pha­sized abor­tion far more than other so­cial is­sues. Trump’s co­zi­ness with var­i­ous prom­i­nent U.S. car­di­nals and bish­ops is well doc­u­mented.

Dur­ing Trump’s first (and, please God, only) term, I talked with a Cath­o­lic priest work­ing on pol­icy for the church. He was dis­tressed that ef­forts against abor­tion are aligned with one po­lit­i­cal party. He wanted to get gun con­trol on the list of pro-life con­cerns — but he felt that was im­pos­sible to do so long as the move­ment had so many Re­pub­li­can ties.

“I’ve talked with so many Cath­o­lic women who are sup­port­ing Trump be­cause of abor­tion,” my own pas­tor told me on the eve of the 2016 elec­tion. He shook his head. We’d met work­ing on other is­sues ad­dressed by Cath­o­lic so­cial teach­ing, like ac­cess to health care and im­mi­grant rights. We knew that our faith had a broad vi­sion of what pro-life means. A re­cent Pew poll, how­ever, shows Cath­o­lic vot­ers fa­vor­ing Trump over Kamala Har­ris, 52% vs. 47%.

I get align­ing with a po­lit­i­cal party. That’s one way to make change. But re­li­gion is not a strat­egy. It should be a shin­ing light pro­claim­ing the truth, not just the part of the truth that sup­ports your ar­gu­ment.

Trump is still mak­ing out­ra­geous, false ac­cu­sa­tions that Dem­o­crats sup­port the ex­e­cu­tion of new­borns. I am re­minded of some­thing Doro­thy Day, the founder of the Cath­o­lic Worker Move­ment said: “Don’t worry about be­ing ef­fec­tive, just be faith­ful to the truth.”

Advertise with us

Com­pli­cated truth

The truth around abor­tion is com­pli­cated. This is why most peo­ple don’t fall neatly into ei­ther camp, but sup­port con­sid­er­ations about vi­a­bil­ity, the woman’s health, and so on. Good leg­is­la­tion about abor­tion would be dif­fi­cult to craft.

We cer­tainly don’t have it now. An in­ves­ti­ga­tion by ProPub­lica doc­u­ments that abor­tion bans in Geor­gia have killed women. The rush to en­act abor­tion bans was ir­re­spon­si­ble. Those of us who be­lieve life de­serves pro­tec­tion at all stages have a spe­cial ob­li­ga­tion to wade into this swirl of con­flict and seek the ad­vice of ac­tual ex­perts (e.g., doc­tors) on re­form.

Abor­tion is badly suited for leg­is­la­tive re­form. Al­most all my friends are, like me, pro­gres­sive. In­vari­ably they ask if I want abor­tion to be il­le­gal. I an­swer that I want it to be un­think­able.

Ac­cess to great health care for ev­ery­one, in­clud­ing con­tra­cep­tion, is a good way to pre­vent abor­tion. I rec­og­nize that my church has been a road­block here.

More broadly, so is the elim­i­na­tion of pov­erty, a goal that would be within this coun­try’s reach if only our am­bi­tion ex­tended that far. Ac­cord­ing to the pro-abor­tion rights Gutt­macher In­sti­tute, 75% of the peo­ple seek­ing abor­tions in the U.S. are poor or low-in­come. Ap­ply­ing the word “choice” to that sit­u­a­tion is in­de­cent.

Advertise with us

To steal a bit from a pop­u­lar bumper sticker: Against abor­tion? Fight pov­erty.

Lives saved on both sides

Every ma­jor faith rec­og­nizes an ob­li­ga­tion on the part of those who have much to those who have lit­tle. Many re­li­gions, in­clud­ing mine, go be­yond the call for char­ity to one for justice. Let’s start there. Let’s build a so­ci­ety where no one feels fi­nan­cially pres­sured to abort a child.

Will that elim­i­nate ev­ery abor­tion? No, but nei­ther will abor­tion bans. This ef­fort would save lives on both sides of the womb.

Such a move­ment would gen­er­ally align more with the Demo­cratic party than the Re­pub­li­can. But the Dems are still a lesser evil — send­ing weap­ons to dec­i­mate Gaza, roll­ing over for the fos­sil fuel in­dus­try, and more.

A real pro-life move­ment would not have a po­lit­i­cal party. It would have le­git­i­macy.

Col­leen Shad­dox is co-au­thor with Joanne Samuel Gold­blum of “Broke in Amer­ica: See­ing, Under­stand­ing, and End­ing U.S. Poverty.” Her web­site is www.freecol­leen.com.