Has Kamala Harris done all she can to win? Has Donald Trump? What do the last-minute polls say? Who will come out to vote and who will stay home on the couch? Which campaign has the better ground game?

These are the questions the press is asking, and will be asking, until election night. They are all interesting and entertaining. But there are other questions that deserve consideration.

The other questions

Is Donald Trump truly an aberration as a presidential candidate? Is either candidate ready to handle the situation in the Middle East? Is the politics of 2024 — the horse race, the obsession with Mr. Trump’s antics, all the posturing and gotcha-ing — the best politics available to us?

The answers cannot possibly be yes, and the thought of Trump as a war president in light of his Covid performance is a head hurricane. We need to, in Hannah Arendt’s words “think what we are doing.”

Advertise with us

Marine Gen. John Kelly, who was Mr. Trump’s chief of staff, as well as Homeland Security chief, has come forward to say that Mr. Trump is not fit to return to the Oval Office. Not because of his business practices or his personal flaws. But because of his failure to understand the presidency, our constitutional system, and our country as a whole.

Mr. Trump thinks, says the general, that the president should have, and exercise, dictatorial powers. He does not comprehend basic civil rights or the right to dissent. He does not respect the service men and women who are willing to die to protect those rights. He calls them “losers.”

Gen. Kelly’s own son died for those rights. For this country.

A big, scary word

As repugnant as such attitudes are on a human level, their true relevance is what they mean to the function of our government and the health of our republic. Gen. Kelly has said that it is accurate to call Mr. Trump a fascist.

That is an astonishing statement for someone like Kelly to make about a former president.

Advertise with us

It’s a big, scary word, fascist. If we had a more mature citizenry, and press, we could talk about that word. For it goes to the heart of why Mr. Trump is different — different, perhaps, even from himself in 2016.

The fascist rejects the complexity and messiness of democracy. The fascist says the strong man is the answer to the messiness. He alone can fix it.

He is a chauvinist and a nationalist. He defines for us the right and the wrong people. The people who should be here versus those who “corrupt our blood,” and should be expelled or expunged.

He thrives on conspiracies and propaganda and on redefining what we thought we saw and what we thought we knew. He targets public enemies — his enemies. He demands total loyalty and returns none.

He claims to have the answers, a complete catechism of solutions, definitions and meaning, the best of which he promises to reveal only in the fullness of time. He is supported by true believers, which can easily become a mob fueled by resentment, false nostalgia, and fake bravado. This mob believes in the leader absolutely.

Advertise with us

One can see why historians, Gen. Kelly and others who are not partisan but persons of some personal and intellectual heft, like Gen. Mark Milley, former chair of the Joint Chiefs, think we are sleepwalking into fascism.

The deeper issue

The deeper issue, the one the press seems unable to engage in 2024, is democracy. If elected, Ms. Harris will need a first-rate, nonpartisan national security team to deal with a world aflame.

Arendt, George Orwell and Eric Hoffer all say that fear of responsibility is why fascist movements appeal — the personal desire to vanish into the cause and escape from the burdens of individual thought and obligation.

Hoffer calls this person “the true believer.” The complexity of politics, of society and culture, of life, of truth, terrifies the true believer.

This person is also the opposite of the citizen, the person who cares as much about American duties as American rights.

Advertise with us

More troubling than the true believer is the sneering cynic. He sees politics as bully boys and circuses and his ideal government is a wrecking ball. He thinks it’s all a game. He has forgotten his duty, and his country, entirely.

A citizen, while not indifferent to his own interests, is capable of thinking about the common good of the country.

He puts on the mantle of citizenship, and learns the role, as a juror puts on a mantle of detachment, rather than prejudice. No matter what happens in this election, we must recover the citizen.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Donald Trump is a bad American.”