The problem with many Americans is that they assume that nationality is synonymous with ethnicity or lineage or simply birthplace. This is not citizenship as understood and defined in the Constitution. Whether one is a citizen by birth or naturalization, the central requirement, regardless of race, creed, gender or country of origin, is allegiance to the Constitution.

Even for those born here, true citizenship is rooted in choice. It is an intellectual act to live under and by the Constitution as the bedrock of governance in public life. That includes affirming freedom of speech, debate, respect for the rights of the minority and the legitimacy of the elected — all under threat today — and working to make our nation a better nation for all.

The office of the citizen

The office of citizen does not mean just living your life and going along. It is not just something you are because you are born here or even went through the naturalization ceremony. It is an office you hold: a position with responsibilities and duties.

The citizen has a public responsibility. If he sees something wrong, a citizen has the responsibility and even the duty to make what he sees known, and to protest if necessary. Nothing may come of it. He may be criticized or harassed for making it known. But the office of citizen does not absolve him of making the effort.

Advertise with us

For example, the exclusion of women from political life. Although championed by some for years, what became the 19th amendment giving women the right to vote did not become law until 1920. The Jim Crow laws in the South and racist laws in the North would be another example. They were not eliminated in law (though not in fact) until the 1960s.

Both of these only happened because enough citizens saw something wrong, took their responsibilities seriously and fought for change. Now, anyone who does not see a woman’s right to vote or freedom from discriminatory laws as a fundamental human right can rightly be called a bad citizen, even un-American. Serious citizens changed the way we think.

The protest against the Vietnam War is a third example of citizens challenging and changing an injustice. The war drew more and more protests as it progressed. Before he was elected, John F. Kennedy reported wanted to withdraw so-called support forces of Americans from Vietnam, but he didn’t.

After he was killed, President Lyndon B. Johnson used an incident in the Bay of Tonkin that never happened to justify sending combat troops to Vietnam. Unwilling to be known as the first president to lose a war, he kept sending troops (“cannon fodder” in the language of protesters). President Richard Nixon later expanded the war into Cambodia.

Spreading protests

Meanwhile, protests spread across the country, supported by Robert F. Kennedy, Martin Luther King and numerous others, though for many years most of the country supported the war and opposed the protesters. The protests climaxed in the killing of four protesting students at Kent State University by the National Guard. (It is a prophecy of what could happen if Trump is elected and uses the military for similar purposes.)

Advertise with us

The protesters, serious citizens, forced the government to negotiate an end to the war. American losses were 55,000 killed plus hundreds of thousands wounded. The South Vietnamese lost over a million and a half while the North Vietnamese put their losses at two million. The numbers would have been even higher without citizens protesting.

Today, we face similar a challenge in foreign policy requiring a similar response from citizens. However lethal the Hamas attack of Oct. 7, 2023 was, there can be no justice in the Israeli reprisal of launching a war of extermination and starvation on the two million people of Gaza, which has already taken the lives of a reported 40,000 Gazans, including 15,000 children.

This ongoing destruction of Gaza is being facilitated by American funds, weaponry and American diplomatic cover in the United Nations, where almost every nation opposes the war and calls for a ceasefire. Jewish thinkers like Gideon Levy, Richard Falk. Noam Chomsky, Ilan Pappe, Norman Finkelstein as well as the brave spokesmen for the Jewish Voice for Peace have written persuasively about the damage this has done and continues to do to Israel’s moral standing, but to no avail with the Biden and Netanyahu governments.

Biden seems to be so intimidated and dominated by Netanyahu that American foreign policy seems subject to his veto. In his most recent appearance before a joint session of Congress, Netanyahu, under an arrest warrant from the International Criminal Court, was cheered by his AIPAC-owned supporters, while more than a hundred others refused to attend or actually walked out. The event was probably the most servile example of arse osculation in Congressional history.

The citizen’s duty

Those who are not serious about their citizenship could not care less about the challenges American faces and their responsibility to the Constitution. But those who are serious citizens will always be troubled in conscience if they did or said nothing when a single action or word of theirs could have changed America for the better.

Samuel Hazo, Pennsylvania’s first poet laureate, was a professor of English at Duquesne University and the founder of the International Poetry Forum. His previous article was “What the university should be, it increasingly isn't.”