Why has the U.S. had no recession since 2020? When covid shocked the world economy in March 2020, it caused a global recession. In the U.S., the unemployment rate shot up from 3.5% in February to 14.4% in April.

With remarkable speed the U.S. Congress passed a $2 trillion spending package for 2020 called the CARES act with bipartisan support. The $2 trillion fiscal stimulus boosted the economy in the second half of 2020 cutting the unemployment rate to 6.7% in December. The federal government spent all the CARES money by the end of 2020.

Biden’s budget

In December 2020 Congress enacted a much smaller fiscal stimulus for 2021, $0.7 trillion, just a third of CARES’ $2 trillion. When Biden took office in January, fiscal stimulus in 2021 was therefore about to plunge by two-thirds — a plunge of $1.3 trillion from $2 trillion in 2020 to $0.7 trillion in 2021.

Did the economy still need $2 trillion of fiscal stimulus in 2021? Opponents of the bill believed covid would fade by spring 2021 and that $2 trillion would cause high inflation. Supporters believed covid might stay virulent all of 2021 and that $2 trillion was needed to prevent recession.

Advertise with us

Biden promptly proposed a new fiscal stimulus package called the American Rescue Plan (ARP) that would spend $1.3 trillion in 2021 (and $0.6 trillion in 2022) so fiscal stimulus would be $2 trillion in 2021, the same as in 2020. Former President Trump urged Congress to reject it.

No recession

In the Senate, all 48 Democrats and 2 Independents voted yes, all 50 Republicans voted no, and Vice President Harris broke the tie by voting yes so it passed 51-50. In the House, the Democrats had a slight majority. Virtually all Democrats voted yes, and virtually all Republicans voted no, so ARP passed barely. It became law in March and was spent in 2021 and 2022.

Covid stayed virulent in 2021. But with ARP there was no recession in 2021 or 2022. In 2021 unemployment fell from 6.1% in April to 3.9% in December. What would have happened without ARP?

In February 2022, Moody’s Analytics Macro-Econometric Model developed by Mark Zandi simulated what would have happened. According to Moody’s Analytics report “Global Fiscal Policy in the Pandemic,” the unemployment rate would have stayed above 7% for all of 2021 instead of falling to 3.9% in December.

That’s what happened in the Eurozone. The report showed that U.S. total fiscal stimulus was 25% of its annual GDP during the pandemic, while the Eurozone’s total fiscal stimulus was only 10% of its annual GDP. Unemployment in the Eurozone did not go below 7% for the rest of 2021. Unemployment in December was 7.0% compared to 3.9% in the U.S.

Advertise with us

Stimulus and inflation

But didn’t the $2 trillion in 2021 cause the high U.S. inflation that occurred in 2021 and 2022? No. As I explained here in February, inflation rose 8% in the U.S., but also rose 8% in Europe and most countries, which did not spend nearly so much on stimulus policies.

The reason for inflation was the large worldwide cost increases from severe covid supply chain disruptions and a huge rise in the world price of oil. Hence, the American Rescue Plan prevented a U.S. recession while causing very little of the 8% rise in U.S. inflation.

Laurence Seidman is professor of economics at the University of Delaware. His previous article was “Joe Biden was not at fault for inflation.”