The university has traditionally been defined as a place where truth can be pursued for its own sake. The goal is primarily intellectual in lecture-classes or in seminars. Dialectic and discussion are the expected and demanded form of discourse where divergent views can be clearly defined and debated in an atmosphere of leisure. Authoritarianism is regarded as a threat to intellectual freedom and has no place in the university.
That is the very basis of campus culture and that has changed.
A truly liberal education
Because so many universities have fallen short of the idea of what a university should be, public trust in universities has fallen. In 2015, according to the Gallup Poll, 58% had a great deal of confidence in higher education, a percentage that’s dropped to 36% today. Then, 10% felt very little or no confidence, while 32% feel that way today.
The idea of a university also has been compromised and weakened considerably and even replaced by what can only be called marketable substitutes. As a result of the education I described, students often find a vocation or way of life that enables them to seek and do what they love to do above all else — not merely as employment but as an outlet for their capabilities and talent.
Such an education is identified as liberal in the sense that it frees or liberates the mind to be satisfied only by the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. The subjects of study that open the mind to such freedom are literary, historical, philosophical, linguistic and the cultural dimensions of the social sciences.
That is no longer so true as the liberal arts have been replaced. At my alma mater Notre Dame in 2011, the major programs were political science, English, finance, science, accountancy, history, marketing, biological science and anthropology. Of these 10 majors, five could qualify as being liberal arts subjects. (Even in 2011 the diminishing presence of the liberal arts was obvious compared to what it was in 1950.)
Read More
By 2021, the 10 leading majors were finance, economics, political science, computer science, business analysis, mechanical engineering, psychology, neuro-science and behavior, biological science, and applied and computational mathematics. Liberal education is evident in this list by its absence.
The loss of the liberal arts
What caused this distance from the liberal arts, which should be the core of undergraduate study? I believe that as society became more mechanized and computer driven, many universities saw themselves as the suppliers of personnel — I use this word deliberately rather than “graduates” — to meet employee demand. By definition, this is not education but training.
Regardless, such training was instantly more attractive to students as the cost of undergraduate education skyrocketed. Facing the debt incurred by four years of college made the need for immediate and lucrative employment both urgent and unavoidable.
I believe also that America’s obsession with chosen wars and the militarizing of government has had a lot to do with it. Starting with Vietnam, America’s wars have been “chosen” — Iran-Contra, Panama, Lebanon, Afghanistan, Iraq and what passed the test anywhere as a “war on terror,” and now America’s support for Israel against Gaza. Any moral justification for American involvement in international disputes was less and less common.
The response on college campuses was more and more resistance and turmoil, and there is no sign that these would lessen. Universities paid the price by appearing to be the enemy of justifiable dissent on campuses. The need to support these wars helped push universities to create “personnel” rather than liberally-educated human beings.
Too few on campus after campus insisted that there was a stronger option than violence and brute force to expose and defeat villainy, and that was and is and will always be the bravery of the free mind confronting controversy. The university is one of the last — if not the last — bastion to ensure the primacy of intellectual freedom and moral values. It is one of the most important places where responses to the ongoing chosen wars and other national problems can be explored.
The last bastion
If the university permits itself to be transformed into a training center to guarantee profitable employment, it has abandoned its mission in society. There is no substitute. It will then be only a matter of time before degree-baited students will be transformed into personnel, manpower, figures on a list of voters, payers, prayers, sums of population tamed with forms.
The ideal of intellectual freedom will seem like a relic of the past, and trained mentalities will be what universities are paid exorbitant sums to graduate.
Samuel Hazo, Pennsylvania’s first poet laureate, was a professor of English at Duquesne University and the founder of the International Poetry Forum. His previous article was “The United States is complicit in genocide.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.