I have conflicted views about political debates. Unless there are a series of them and they are more or less direct confrontations, Lincoln-Douglas style, I think debates are more often distracting than revelatory.
This is particularly true of presidential debates. They are all about premeditated gotcha moments and rehearsed soundbites.
The rehearsed soundbites
Ronald Reagan’s “There you go again,” said in his debate with President Jimmy Carter, was cute and semi-clever. But it was not a defense of Reaganomics and the trickle-down theory.
The same is true of “You’re no Jack Kennedy,” which Democrat Lloyd Bentsen said to Republican Dan Quayle in the 1988 vice presidential debate. Meaningless.
We don’t often get to the heart of an issue in a presidential or vice presidential debate. Debates are entertainments; circuses without elephants and horses. And, anyway, as Sen. Eugene McCarthy said, “presidents don’t debate.”
Richard Nixon (in 1960), Gerald Ford (in 1976), and George H.W. Bush (in 1992), all knew more than their opponents and all were better qualified to be president. Yet, none debated well.
Still, in the Trump-Harris debate last Tuesday night, we did get some insight, even if we only scratched the surface.
On Ukraine: Donald Trump was not able to say he wanted Ukraine to prevail. He implausibly, almost fantastically, said he would have kept the war from happening and that he would end it in days if elected, even before being inaugurated.
On abortion: Mr. Trump could not decide. He made another fantastic claim. He said “everybody,” for decades, wanted the issue turned back to the states. A fantasy. And that he and brave and smart Supreme Court jurists had accomplished this. But he punted on signing a national abortion ban, should he be elected and should such a ban come to his desk.
On accepting the results of elections and the peaceful transition of power: Mr. Trump still insists that he won in 2020. (The moderators, who generally did a creditable job, corrected this but failed to follow up: Will Mr. Trump accept the results in 2024 should he lose? It seems likely that he will not.)
Mr. Trump has always been a truth bender, from crowd size to Barack Obama’s place of birth. But bizarre, self-invented fables have now carried him away. And this was the principal reality in his debate performance.
In the past, one got the feeling that Mr. Trump knew, on some level, that he was distorting or fabricating. But he now says things that are completely crackpot and he defends them passionately. For example: Not only are millions of immigrants coming to America illegally, committing crimes, taking our jobs and generally menacing us. But they are stealing and eating our pets!
Say what?
Yes, a former president of the United States who wants to be president again, and who has the consistent support of 45%-47% of likely voters, was screaming on national television that “they,” are eating our cats and dogs.
Donald Trump began his public life a decade ago in cynicism: Exploiting the bubbas by showing them his own anger and resentment. Make no mistake, he holds his “basement dwellers,” in contempt at least as rich and deep as Hillary Clinton’s.
But, increasingly, to make the sale, and to convince himself, Mr. Trump must up the MAGA fairytale ante. So what began in cynicism ends in delusion.
Ms. Harris is right. A president who can no longer tell fact from fiction is a very troubling possibility. If Joe Biden showed in the last debate that he is (though wise) depleted, Donald Trump showed clearly that he is deluded.
He also showed his values. Who does he admire? Viktor Orban, dictator of Hungary. And why does he admire him? Because he is a “strong man,” as Trump wants to be and because Orban admires Mr. Trump.
So the debate did show us something: Trump letting Trump be Trump. Trump in all his unfocused and unhinged narcissism. Trump the man perfectly qualified for reality TV and utterly unfit for the presidency.
How about Ms. Harris? What did the debate show us about her? Well, she does her homework. She is a professional politician, which used to bore us but now should reassure us. And she is as disciplined as he is undisciplined.
None of this necessarily means she will be a good president.
No real choice
But it seems to me that the country has no real choice.
Ms. Harris does have some good policy ideas: We need to increase the child tax credit, especially for new parents. And we need to build new, affordable housing. We have not done so since after World War II.
If she could accomplish these two things and bring dignity and pragmatism to the presidency, that would be enough. Americans like Kamala Harris the more they see her, which is unusual in a grumpy country with a lazy press.
She is tough and compassionate, two things a president needs to be. So this debate did also reveal character. And in this job character is destiny.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “We are our values.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.