I have con­flicted views about po­lit­i­cal de­bates. Un­less there are a se­ries of them and they are more or less di­rect con­fron­ta­tions, Lin­coln-Douglas style, I think de­bates are more of­ten dis­tract­ing than re­ve­la­tory.

This is par­tic­u­larly true of pres­i­den­tial de­bates. They are all about pre­med­i­tated got­cha mo­ments and re­hearsed sound­bites.

The re­hearsed sound­bites

Ron­ald Rea­gan’s “There you go again,” said in his de­bate with Pres­i­dent Jimmy Carter, was cute and semi-clever. But it was not a de­fense of Reag­anom­ics and the trickle-down the­ory.

The same is true of “You’re no Jack Ken­nedy,” which Dem­o­crat Lloyd Bentsen said to Re­pub­li­can Dan Quayle in the 1988 vice pres­i­den­tial de­bate. Mean­ing­less.

Advertise with us

We don’t of­ten get to the heart of an is­sue in a pres­i­den­tial or vice pres­i­den­tial de­bate. De­bates are en­ter­tain­ments; cir­cuses with­out el­e­phants and horses. And, any­way, as Sen. Eugene McCarthy said, “pres­i­dents don’t de­bate.”

Rich­ard Nixon (in 1960), Ger­ald Ford (in 1976), and George H.W. Bush (in 1992), all knew more than their op­po­nents and all were bet­ter qual­i­fied to be pres­i­dent. Yet, none de­bated well.

Still, in the Trump-Har­ris de­bate last Tues­day night, we did get some in­sight, even if we only scratched the sur­face.

On Ukraine: Don­ald Trump was not able to say he wanted Ukraine to pre­vail. He im­plau­si­bly, al­most fan­tas­ti­cally, said he would have kept the war from hap­pen­ing and that he would end it in days if elected, even be­fore be­ing in­au­gu­rated.

On abor­tion: Mr. Trump could not de­cide. He made an­other fan­tas­tic claim. He said “ev­ery­body,” for de­cades, wanted the is­sue turned back to the states. A fan­tasy. And that he and brave and smart Supreme Court ju­rists had ac­com­plished this. But he punted on sign­ing a na­tional abor­tion ban, should he be elected and should such a ban come to his desk.

Advertise with us

On ac­cept­ing the re­sults of elec­tions and the peace­ful tran­si­tion of power: Mr. Trump still in­sists that he won in 2020. (The mod­er­a­tors, who gen­er­ally did a cred­it­able job, cor­rected this but failed to fol­low up: Will Mr. Trump ac­cept the re­sults in 2024 should he lose? It seems likely that he will not.)

Mr. Trump has al­ways been a truth bender, from crowd size to Barack Obama’s place of birth. But bi­zarre, self-in­vented fa­bles have now car­ried him away. And this was the prin­ci­pal re­al­ity in his de­bate per­for­mance.

In the past, one got the feel­ing that Mr. Trump knew, on some level, that he was dis­tort­ing or fab­ri­cat­ing. But he now says things that are com­pletely crack­pot and he de­fends them pas­sion­ately. For ex­am­ple: Not only are mil­lions of im­mi­grants com­ing to Amer­ica il­le­gally, com­mit­ting crimes, tak­ing our jobs and gen­er­ally men­ac­ing us. But they are steal­ing and eat­ing our pets!

Say what?

Yes, a for­mer pres­i­dent of the United States who wants to be pres­i­dent again, and who has the con­sis­tent sup­port of 45%-47% of likely vot­ers, was scream­ing on na­tional tele­vi­sion that “they,” are eat­ing our cats and dogs.

Don­ald Trump be­gan his pub­lic life a de­cade ago in cyn­i­cism: Ex­ploit­ing the bub­bas by show­ing them his own an­ger and re­sent­ment. Make no mis­take, he holds his “base­ment dwel­l­ers,” in con­tempt at least as rich and deep as Hil­lary Clin­ton’s.

Advertise with us

But, in­creas­ingly, to make the sale, and to convince him­self, Mr. Trump must up the MAGA fairy­tale ante. So what be­gan in cyn­i­cism ends in de­lu­sion.

Ms. Har­ris is right. A pres­i­dent who can no lon­ger tell fact from fic­tion is a very trou­bling pos­si­bil­ity. If Joe Biden showed in the last de­bate that he is (though wise) de­pleted, Don­ald Trump showed clearly that he is de­luded.

He also showed his val­ues. Who does he ad­mire? Vik­tor Or­ban, dic­ta­tor of Hun­gary. And why does he ad­mire him? Be­cause he is a “strong man,” as Trump wants to be and be­cause Or­ban ad­mires Mr. Trump.

So the de­bate did show us some­thing: Trump let­ting Trump be Trump. Trump in all his un­fo­cused and un­hinged nar­cis­sism. Trump the man per­fectly qual­i­fied for re­al­ity TV and ut­terly un­fit for the pres­i­dency.

How about Ms. Har­ris? What did the de­bate show us about her? Well, she does her home­work. She is a pro­fes­sional pol­i­ti­cian, which used to bore us but now should re­as­sure us. And she is as dis­ci­plined as he is un­dis­ci­plined.

Advertise with us

None of this nec­es­sar­ily means she will be a good pres­i­dent.

No real choice

But it seems to me that the coun­try has no real choice.

Ms. Har­ris does have some good pol­icy ideas: We need to in­crease the child tax credit, es­pe­cially for new par­ents. And we need to build new, af­ford­able hous­ing. We have not done so since af­ter World War II.

If she could ac­com­plish these two things and bring dig­nity and prag­ma­tism to the pres­i­dency, that would be enough. Amer­i­cans like Kamala Har­ris the more they see her, which is un­usual in a grumpy coun­try with a lazy press.

She is tough and com­pas­sion­ate, two things a pres­i­dent needs to be. So this de­bate did also re­veal char­ac­ter. And in this job char­ac­ter is des­tiny.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “We are our values.”