Poll after poll reveals what’s on voters’ minds: It’s the economy, stupid, as it was in 1992 when Bill Clinton’s campaign advisor James Carville invented the phrase. Voters consistently cite inflation as the most important issue affecting our country.
Economic fearmongering drives the disastrous policies both candidates propose in respone to voter concerns. And each candidate is guilty of blaming a boogeyman. For Kamala Harris, greedy corporations are gouging customers and raking in profits. For Donald Trump, foreign governments — primarily China — control the flow and pricing of consumer goods into our country.
Poorer workers
Under President Joe Biden, consumer prices have increased 19.43%. The rate of increases may be slowing (following the highest inflation in 40 years), but prices are still rising.
Wages haven’t kept up. The average weekly pay for Pennsylvania workers increased only 12.6% under Biden. This represents a 5.9% decline in real weekly earnings — a loss of more than $2,880 in annual buying power.
Workers are poorer today than three years ago.
Democrats in power — including Vice President Kamala Harris and U.S. Sen. Bob Casey — blame “greedflation” and “shrinkflation.” For them, it’s the companies that reduce product size without lowering prices that are at fault. They even promoted legislation empowering federal bureaucrats to “crack down” on evil corporations that put fewer chips in the bags.
If corporate greed is the only cause of higher prices, were these corporations benevolent for the four decades prior and keeping prices relatively low until recently? Moreover, did every corporation in every sector conspire to raise prices simultaneously? Also, did this collusion occur right when the federal government went on a spending binge?
Inflation’s root cause isn’t Big Business. It’s Big Government.
The economist Milton Friedman taught us inflation is a monetary phenomenon. When the money supply grows too fast, the dollar loses value.
This happened when the federal government injected trillions of dollars in pandemic-related stimulus spending — first under former President Donald Trump and then Biden — into an already vulnerable economy.
Government’s the problem
Unfortunately, politicians from both sides of the aisle actively pitch more government intervention to fix the problems caused by government, using vague platitudes and economic policies universally rejected by economists.
Harris and Trump both propose policies that would exacerbate prices on consumer goods and harm struggling families.
Harris proposed a federal ban on price gouging — another term for price controls. Economists broadly agree that price controls don’t work and have failed every time they’ve been imposed. Rather than driving down prices, price controls only lead to shortages. Harris has even admitted her proposal “would likely not affect the prices Americans are currently paying in the grocery aisle.”
While Harris and Democrats tilt at corporate windmills, Trump’s trade policies — specifically his call for tariffs — are equally detrimental.
Again, economists agree: Tariffs increase prices. A tariff is a tax on imported goods — paid by U.S. consumers.
Businesses trading on a global scale are less competitive because of foreign retaliation. Businesses and consumers are always collateral damage in trade wars.
From 2017 to 2020, the Trump administration imposed about $80 billion in new tariffs. The Tax Foundation called Trump’s tariffs “the largest tax increases in decades.”
Interestingly, Democrats, though they tend to revile anything remotely related to Trump, seem to like his tariffs. In 2019, Biden mocked Trump for his tariffs, tweeting, “Any freshman econ student could tell you that the American people are paying for tariffs.”
Yet, Biden not only kept the Trump-era tariffs but also added new ones. In May, his administration announced another $18 billion in tariffs on Chinese goods.
Terrifying words
In reality, government policies — government spending fueled by printing money and tariffs on goods bought by American consumers — have driven up costs for families.
Candidates should wise up and realize that federal intervention is a recipe for economic disasters.
Nathan Benefield is the Senior Vice President of the Commonwealth Foundation. His previous article was “Gov. Shapiro wants unilateral power to commit the state to climate agreements.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.