A re­porter once asked Pope Francis if he was a “left­ist.” The Pope re­plied, ”My friend, you are con­fused.” That’s a re­ally in­ter­est­ing re­sponse.

Espe­cially since this seems to be the Amer­i­can po­lit­i­cal and re­li­gious right’s rap on Francis: He’s a lef­tie. What did the Holy Father mean?

I think sev­eral things that are all one thing: He, Francis, is not in the left/​right busi­ness. The mes­sage of Je­sus tran­scends, is both higher and deeper, than right and left. The church should not be re­duced to, or di­vided by, what the Holy Father calls ide­ol­o­gies. Do not con­fuse ul­ti­mate truth with con­tem­po­rary cul­ture wars

But, there is ul­ti­mate truth. And it has con­se­quences.

Advertise with us

Love and justice

Rein­hold Nie­buhr said: “Love is the mo­tive. But justice is the in­stru­ment.”

Love, here, is not the love of Hall­mark or “Love Story,” but char­ity. “If I have not char­ity, I am noth­ing.”

Char­ity means good will to­ward men. Char­ity means, in Abra­ham Lin­coln’s words, “the bonds of af­fec­tion.” It means, the civic salve of mu­tual re­spect and re­gard. Or, neigh­bor­li­ness, in the old-fash­ioned, Fred Rogers, way. It means a kind of so­cio­log­i­cal “I and Thou” — I am unique and so are you.

So, the first as­sump­tion I make about my neigh­bor is that he is, if not good, de­cent. And if not just, fair.

Char­ity is the goal, the mo­tive. De­cency is the in­stru­ment. Next, fair­ness. Some­thing like justice, is the fi­nal and fin­est in­stru­ment, for per­sons and civ­i­li­za­tions.

Advertise with us

Few hu­mans are saints. Few so­ci­et­ies are just. But a real hu­man be­ing seeks to be fair. And a hu­mane so­ci­ety seeks to be ever more just.

This is the Amer­i­can ideal and story: Seek­ing a more per­fect, more just, union.

Some peo­ple who watched the Demo­cratic con­ven­tion said that Kamala Har­ris should talk more about pol­icy and plans. A few Dem­o­crats have wished she was more he­roic, like Barack Obama. (“Why am I not as ex­cited as I was about Barack?” one per­son asked me.)

But pol­icy and plans have lit­tle to do with the pres­i­dency. The job is deal­ing with what comes up — mostly po­lit­i­cal and cul­tural melo­drama and for­eign and mil­i­tary cri­ses.

Val­ues and char­ac­ter

Noth­ing pre­pares you for the pres­i­dency, though the vice pres­i­dency cer­tainly helps. No job is com­pa­ra­ble, though mayor of New York City is pretty tough. And Supreme Al­lied Com­mander of al­lied forces in Europe was surely a prep­a­ra­tion for Dwight Ei­sen­hower.

Advertise with us

But po­si­tion pa­pers and pol­icy don’t de­ter­mine a pres­i­dency. They point to di­rec­tion, and val­ues, which do de­ter­mine a pres­i­dency. Val­ues and char­ac­ter rule.

So I think Kamala Har­ris has been right to em­pha­size her val­ues. Right in small ball po­lit­i­cal terms. (She doesn’t get trapped.) But also right, in­tel­lec­tu­ally, and as an Amer­i­can leader.

She wants to lead us back to de­cency, fair­ness and some mea­sure of justice. Call this op­por­tu­nity eco­nom­ics, in­formed by com­pas­sion. As Joe Biden says: Ev­ery­one de­serves a shot.

Ms. Har­ris wants to com­plete the tran­si­tion to nor­mal­ity — re­spect for law and for in­sti­tu­tional and po­lit­i­cal norms. And then get us back on the glide path to­ward char­ity.

Only to­ward. But for­ward.

Advertise with us

I am glad she is not (so far) a mes­siah, a pres­i­dent who will al­leg­edly change ev­ery­thing and make all things new, in­clud­ing all of us.

Amer­ica is not bro­ken. It never was. And it will not cease to ex­ist if the “wrong per­son” is elected pres­i­dent. But the coun­try is stuck in di­vi­sion and grid­lock. It is bogged down in a kind of cul­tural civil war.

An au­to­bi­og­ra­phy of val­ues is what Wal­ter Lip­p­mann called a “pub­lic phi­los­o­phy.” This should pre­cede and il­lu­mi­nate any plan (like the 2025 plan).

Frank­lin Roosevelt, The­odore Roosevelt, and Abra­ham Lin­coln all ad­vo­cated pol­i­cies. But they first had a pub­lic phi­los­o­phy — a val­ues sys­tem. So did Jef­fer­son. So did Mar­tin Luther King Jr., who stud­ied Nie­buhr closely and in­voked Jef­fer­son.

John F. Ken­nedy, Barack Obama, and Don­ald Trump were char­is­matic sav­ior fig­ures, pro­pelled by the cult of per­son­al­ity.

Advertise with us

Ms. Har­ris has be­gun to sketch out for us her au­to­bi­og­ra­phy of val­ues. This, and not her thoughts on the tax code, is what we need to hear.

All we have and are

My Dad had a pub­lic phi­los­o­phy. He used to say: “I am a union man, a Dem­o­crat and a Cath­o­lic.” (In as­cend­ing or­der.)

My mother was Ir­ish Cath­o­lic. She had two pre­cepts: Up with those who are down. And: Be hum­ble. There is far more that you do not know than you know.

This re­minds me: There is also a need for a con­ser­va­tive pub­lic phi­los­o­phy: Hold­ing the Con­sti­tu­tion and Bill of Rights in sa­cred re­gard; pre­fer­ring pres­ent hap­pi­ness to fu­ture uto­pia and ade­quacy to am­bi­tion; pay­ing our debts; lim­its. But there is no true con­ser­va­tism in our pol­i­tics to­day.

Our val­ues are, fi­nally, all we have and all that we are.

Advertise with us

Nie­buhr sum­ma­rized his val­ues as “Chris­tian re­al­ism”: Char­ity our end and justice our means — in short, fal­ter­ing steps.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Of conventions and conventional wisdom.”