The people who “know,” are very often wrong. I am talking about elites, the chattering classes, and what we used to call the press, which is now the media, or pod media, and has, for years, appended itself to D.C. and New York bigwigs and hangers on.
The smart money and the conventional wisdom are almost always off by a slight to wide mark. This warning should precede every journalism seminar and be printed on every political science text that purports to explain American politics.
From Franklin Roosevelt (a “tennis anyone?” type, they thought), to Harry Truman (whom they considered a failed retailer and a shrill little man who could never fill FDR’s shoes), to Ronnie Reagan (an “amiable dunce”), they got it wrong.
Wrong about Kamala Harris
They still get it wrong and make their wrongness the take we all take home. The most recent shockingly wrong take was on Kamala Harris.
For four years we have been told that she is lighter than light; a person who does not do her homework; a person who cannot keep staff; a person who is bad at politics. We were told she cannot run a campaign and she cannot connect with people.
What say they now? The experts, the supercilious set, got it wrong again.
Read More
And why is that? Well, they are obsessed with the horse race. They are closer to gossip than to tradition, culture or ideas. They over-value cleverness and facility with words. And they live in echo chambers.
It is still early. And politics can change fast. Especially in 2024. But, so far, Ms. Harris has run a flawless campaign. This includes picking Tim Walz as her running mate.
The people who know said it had to be Josh Shapiro. Clearly, she picked the right guy. Mr. Walz is a star. He is so good, and so credible, for the same reason Ronald Reagan was compelling: Mr. Walz knows what he thinks and he can articulate it in a simple, clear, non-threatening way. It helps to be likable.
Ms. Harris has also done three things that are Smart Politics 101: She combats propaganda and lies head on, often with humor; she makes the campaign about us, not her. (“What kind of country do you want?”); she is optimistic, not pessimistic. (Another Reagan lesson.)
That is, the country is not doomed. America has not failed. The country is capable, great, even happy.
And it turns out that, duh, Americans kind of like that, and therefore kind of like her. Almost as brilliant as the Tim Walz line about the Trump Tribe (“these guys are weird”) is Ms. Harris’ line about the Harris/Walz ticket (“we are joyful warriors”).
A campaign turned on its head
Ms. Harris has turned the campaign on its head in a matter of days, something I have not seen in 50 years of watching presidential politics. And now the people who know are asking: How did this happen? And: Is this a sugar high or the new 2024 campaign?
I suspect that it is the second and for reasons that are deeper than Ms. Harris’ considerable skills.
One is relief. The country did not want the 2020 choice again. It did not want to choose between Joe Biden and Donald Trump again. The party that found a way out of the cul-de-sac was apt to get a boost.
The second is that the country is also exhausted and more likely to be grateful for Ms. Harris than to closely scrutinize her. She is wise to stick to broad themes rather than specifics in most speeches.
Finally, Harris/Walz confronts Trumpist Populism with Progressive Populism. What is that? It is not just policies, like Social Security, or Obamacare, though it is partly that. At heart it is about values. Ms. Harris and Mr. Walz talk about freedom, mutual respect, and mutual obligation. This allows them to cast progressivism in terms of common sense when Trump and company want to label it “left.”
Trump’s populism is a varied shade of strong man autocracy — up from the folk, rather than imposed from above. It is built on resentment and the belief that common social goods — like wealth and health care – are always zero sum commodities. Someone must always lose (and be angry).
Sharing and compromise
Progressive populism asserts that social goods can not only multiply but be shared. And when limits are reached, proportions can be determined by compromise. Burdens can also be shared.
Collective good will makes all this possible. In short: The greatest good to the greatest number. And: Better is still better.
Politics is a sport. But it is also history — tragedy, perseverance and hope.
The ultimate social good in democracy is power. This is true populism and true patriotism: When power is dispersed. When there is faith that every ordinary leader has the capacity for greatness (Truman; Walz) and that every citizen has the capacity to lead.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Tim Walz says: Don’t be weird, don’t be afraid, build.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.