In 1779 — 245 years before the current U.S. Supreme Court endowed the U.S. presidency with monarch-like immunities — the earlier decisions of actual English kings resulted in an enormous land claims mess that the newly independent Americans attempted to untangle.
The dueling land grants made by King Charles I and later his son, Charles II, entangled William Penn, the father and the son, and the Lords Calvert, barons of Baltimore, as well as Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware and West Virginia (then part of Virginia). The issue then was stolen Native American land.
Later the issue became slavery and which states were slave-holding and which weren’t. The drawing of the geographic Mason-Dixon Line between north and south in the 1760s was seen as the untangling solution.
Free and slave
Through the decades, it came to be that jurisdictions south of the Line were regarded as slave territory, whereas the “free’’ states were north of it. Virginia came to be regarded as the northern border of land where slavery could and did thrive.
Pittsburgh figured infamously in the dispute. Once included in Virginia’s West Augusta District but located on the southwest corner of Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh, until the late 1700s, embraced legal slavery. Local residents chose sides at times, while some respected simultaneously the laws and customs of both Pennsylvania and Virginia.
Then Pennsylvania passed the Act for the Gradual Abolition of Slavery on March 1, 1780. The Act rendered illegal the enslavement of those born of the enslaved in the state after that date and ended the importation of slaves into the state.
People claiming slaves were required to register them or lose them. Of course, widespread cheating ensued, thus the 1788 amendment that closed some 1780 loopholes.
As for Pittsburgh slavery? In 1779 Charles Mason and Jeremiah Dixon’s line was drawn farther west to the Ohio border. Pittsburgh fell 50 miles north of the line — in Pennsylvania.
As a result, slavery in Pittsburgh began diminishing legally in 1780 and was all but gone altogether by 1857. Only the loss of the Civil War in 1865 killed slavery in Virginia, in which the capital of the slave-hungry Confederate states was located.
The slow ending of slavery
It is important to note that no slave was freed anywhere in Pennsylvania by the 1780 slavery-unraveling legislation. Those already enslaved anywhere in Pennsylvania as of March 1, 1780, could remain so for life.
Black babies born of enslaved mothers (regardless of who dad was; slave status was based on the status of the mother) in Pennsylvania after that date could not be enslaved in the state. Rather, they could look forward to being indentured for 28 years — term slavery. Afterwards, the young people would be released to the world with two sets of clothing, “one of which shall be new,” according to the 1780 Pennsylvania Gradual Abolition of Slavery Act.
Delaware ended slavery in 1865, Maryland in 1864. West Virginia became a separate state but did not end slavery until 1865. All three of those slave states remained in the Union, not joining with the treasonous Confederacy.
On my biennial Christmas drives from Pittsburgh through Maryland to be with Delaware relatives, I noted the unremarkable Mason-Dixon Line signage alongside the highway in the early 2000s.
2012 was different. Sad business on a different side of the family informed my drive from Memphis, Tennessee to New York City. On an unfamiliar roadway, I crossed the Mason-Dixon Line en route.
The sights through the Shenandoah Valley were, frankly, boring. Even the famous Blue Ridge mountains of Virginia seemed uninteresting. I perked up somewhat when passing the Staunton, Virginia, hometown of my best friend.
But when I encountered a sign on the Pennsylvania route to the Big Apple that read Mason and Dixon, the itinerary took on an especially enlightening meaning. The road into the Mason and Dixon unincorporated Franklin County community in Pennsylvania led me to jarring sights that are both haunting and thought-provoking.
Marking sides
Large stones marked many miles of the Mason-Dixon Line. What are named crownstones marked every five miles of the shameful boundary. All of the markers were English imports. Engraved upon them, a ‘’P” established the Pennsylvania and Delaware side; an “M” marked the Maryland side of the demarcation line.
The coat of arms of the Maryland Calverts as well as the Pennsylvania Penns appear on the markers.
Eerily, the countless markers appeared to me like gravestones in a cemetery — fitting given the death of liberty they represented for America’s enslaved men, women and children. I drove away from Mason and Dixon, Pennsylvania, both stunned and educated.
Over the decades — indeed the centuries — some of the stones of the Mason-Dixon Line were stolen, buried or otherwise missing from view. Those that remain are disgraceful symbols of an America that rid itself eventually of slaves — as it had of monarchs.
Robert Hill is an award-winning Pittsburgh writer and communications consultant, and a regular contributor to the Post-Gazette. His previous article was “The Supreme Court's latest racist decision.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.