In 1779 — 245 years be­fore the cur­rent U.S. Supreme Court en­dowed the U.S. pres­i­dency with mon­arch-like im­mu­ni­ties — the ear­lier de­ci­sions of ac­tual English kings re­sulted in an enor­mous land claims mess that the newly in­de­pen­dent Amer­i­cans at­tempted to un­tan­gle.

The du­el­ing land grants made by King Char­les I and later his son, Char­les II, en­tan­gled Wil­liam Penn, the father and the son, and the Lords Calvert, bar­ons of Bal­ti­more, as well as Penn­syl­va­nia, Mary­land, Del­a­ware and West Vir­ginia (then part of Vir­ginia). The is­sue then was sto­len Na­tive Amer­i­can land.

Later the is­sue be­came slav­ery and which states were slave-hold­ing and which weren’t. The draw­ing of the geo­graphic Ma­son-Dixon Line be­tween north and south in the 1760s was seen as the un­tan­gling solu­tion.

Free and slave

Through the de­cades, it came to be that ju­ris­dic­tions south of the Line were re­garded as slave ter­ri­tory, whereas the “free’’ states were north of it. Vir­ginia came to be re­garded as the north­ern border of land where slav­ery could and did thrive.

Advertise with us

Pitts­burgh fig­ured in­fa­mously in the dis­pute. Once in­cluded in Vir­ginia’s West Au­gusta Dis­trict but lo­cated on the south­west cor­ner of Penn­syl­va­nia, Pitts­burgh, un­til the late 1700s, em­braced le­gal slav­ery. Lo­cal res­i­dents chose sides at times, while some re­spected si­mul­ta­ne­ously the laws and cus­toms of both Penn­syl­va­nia and Vir­ginia.

Then Penn­syl­va­nia passed the Act for the Grad­ual Abo­li­tion of Slav­ery on March 1, 1780. The Act ren­dered il­le­gal the en­slave­ment of those born of the en­slaved in the state af­ter that date and ended the im­por­ta­tion of slaves into the state.

People claim­ing slaves were re­quired to reg­is­ter them or lose them. Of course, wide­spread cheat­ing en­sued, thus the 1788 amend­ment that closed some 1780 loop­holes.

As for Pitts­burgh slav­ery? In 1779 Char­les Ma­son and Jere­miah Dixon’s line was drawn far­ther west to the Ohio bor­der. Pitts­burgh fell 50 miles north of the line — in Penn­syl­va­nia.

As a re­sult, slav­ery in Pitts­burgh be­gan di­min­ish­ing le­gally in 1780 and was all but gone al­to­gether by 1857. Only the loss of the Civil War in 1865 killed slav­ery in Vir­ginia, in which the cap­i­tal of the slave-hun­gry Con­fed­er­ate states was lo­cated.

Advertise with us

The slow end­ing of slav­ery

It is im­por­tant to note that no slave was freed any­where in Penn­syl­va­nia by the 1780 slav­ery-un­rav­el­ing leg­is­la­tion. Those al­ready en­slaved any­where in Penn­syl­va­nia as of March 1, 1780, could re­main so for life.

Black ba­bies born of en­slaved moth­ers (re­gard­less of who dad was; slave sta­tus was based on the sta­tus of the mother) in Penn­syl­va­nia af­ter that date could not be en­slaved in the state. Rather, they could look for­ward to be­ing in­den­tured for 28 years — term slav­ery. After­wards, the young peo­ple would be re­leased to the world with two sets of cloth­ing, “one of which shall be new,” ac­cord­ing to the 1780 Penn­syl­va­nia Grad­ual Abo­li­tion of Slav­ery Act.

Del­a­ware ended slav­ery in 1865, Mary­land in 1864. West Vir­ginia be­came a sep­a­rate state but did not end slav­ery un­til 1865. All three of those slave states re­mained in the Union, not join­ing with the trea­son­ous Con­fed­er­acy.

On my bi­en­nial Christ­mas drives from Pitts­burgh through Mary­land to be with Del­a­ware rel­a­tives, I noted the un­re­mark­able Ma­son-Dixon Line sign­age along­side the high­way in the early 2000s.

2012 was dif­fer­ent. Sad busi­ness on a dif­fer­ent side of the fam­ily in­formed my drive from Mem­phis, Ten­nes­see to New York City. On an un­fa­mil­iar road­way, I crossed the Ma­son-Dixon Line en route.

Advertise with us

The sights through the Shen­an­doah Val­ley were, frankly, bor­ing. Even the fa­mous Blue Ridge moun­tains of Vir­ginia seemed un­in­ter­est­ing. I perked up some­what when pass­ing the Staun­ton, Vir­ginia, home­town of my best friend.

But when I en­coun­tered a sign on the Penn­syl­va­nia route to the Big Ap­ple that read Ma­son and Dixon, the itin­er­ary took on an es­pe­cially en­light­en­ing mean­ing. The road into the Ma­son and Dixon un­in­cor­po­rated Frank­lin County com­mu­nity in Penn­syl­va­nia led me to jar­ring sights that are both haunt­ing and thought-pro­vok­ing.

Mark­ing sides

Large stones marked many miles of the Ma­son-Dixon Line. What are named crown­stones marked ev­ery five miles of the shame­ful bound­ary. All of the mark­ers were English im­ports. En­graved upon them, a ‘’P” es­tab­lished the Penn­syl­va­nia and Del­a­ware side; an “M” marked the Mary­land side of the de­mar­ca­tion line.

The coat of arms of the Mary­land Calverts as well as the Penn­syl­va­nia Penns ap­pear on the mark­ers.

Eer­ily, the count­less mark­ers ap­peared to me like grave­stones in a cem­e­tery — fit­ting given the death of lib­erty they rep­re­sented for Amer­ica’s en­slaved men, women and chil­dren. I drove away from Ma­son and Dixon, Penn­syl­va­nia, both stunned and ed­u­cated.

Advertise with us

Over the de­cades — in­deed the cen­tu­ries — some of the stones of the Ma­son-Dixon Line were sto­len, bur­ied or oth­er­wise miss­ing from view. Those that re­main are dis­grace­ful sym­bols of an Amer­ica that rid it­self even­tu­ally of slaves — as it had of mon­archs.

Robert Hill is an award-winning Pittsburgh writer and communications consultant, and a regular contributor to the Post-Gazette. His previous article was “The Supreme Court's latest racist decision.”