In a recent statement, Tennessee Republican Rep. Tim Burchett referred to Vice President Kamala Harris as a "DEI hire," a term that expresses a fundamental misunderstanding of what the field of diversity, equity, and inclusion represents.
DEI is a practice, not a person. There is no such thing as a "DEI hire" or a "diversity hire." Such terminology implies that individuals from non-white, non-male backgrounds are somehow inherently less qualified, a notion as baseless as it is outdated.
Historically overlooked
Calling someone a “DEI hire” is tantamount to saying "a non-white male hire," as if white men are intrinsically more competent than anyone else. The reality is that white men are neither better nor worse than any other identity group. Talent and potential are distributed equally across all demographics, with each group having its superstars and its underperformers.
The essence of DEI lies in uncovering talent that has been historically overlooked and excluded. It seeks to level a playing field that has never been fair from the outset. When implemented effectively, DEI initiatives do not marginalize white men; rather, they create an environment where top performers from all identity groups have the opportunity to contribute and shine.
The goal of DEI is to dismantle systemic barriers that have historically marginalized certain groups, not to create new ones against others. As a white woman, I find it ironic when people say DEI is “anti-white.” Why would I work within a field that discriminated against myself?
The argument that DEI is anti-white also fails to recognize the historical context. For centuries, systemic barriers have disproportionately affected non-white individuals. Addressing these injustices is not about punishing white people; it's about rectifying a long-standing imbalance. It's about ensuring that everyone has a fair shot at success, regardless of their background.
Read More
We need DEI
As a white woman, I hold certain privileges that my DEI practitioners of color do not. Research shows that pro-DEI messaging is less favorable when coming from an individual perceived to benefit from it. In other words, women and ethnic minorities are penalized for talking about DEI, whereas white men are not.
So, allow me to flex my white privilege and make the case for why we — especially businesses, schools and government agencies — need DEI. Diverse teams outperform non-diverse teams. Diverse, equitable, and inclusive companies see greater financial gains compared to homogeneous ones. And I think we can all agree that fairer systems — what equity is all about — lead to better outcomes for everyone.
We need more white men standing up for DEI, too. Right now, the anti-DEI rhetoric is much louder than the pro-DEI side. And we’re already beginning to see the fallout: DEI leaders are getting the ax, DEI teams and budgets are being slashed, even industry leaders like Microsoft are de-funding their DEI function, a move that will inevitably be replicated by others.
It is time we move away from the zero-sum game mentality that portrays DEI as a threat. DEI is about people — all people — and when done right, everyone benefits. A diverse and inclusive workplace fosters innovation, enhances problem-solving, and leads to better decision-making, which all impact the bottom line. DEI is good for business, and therefore good for society.
Forward progress
Our likely Democratic presidential nominee was not selected because she is a Black woman, just as our mayor wasn’t elected because of the color of his skin. Both made it where they are today because of the experience and credentials they bring, despite being the first … although they surely won’t be the last.
In the spirit of Pittsburgh's recent strides towards diversity and inclusion, let us embrace the true meaning of DEI. Let us ensure that every talented individual, regardless of their background, has a seat at the table. Only then can we harness the full potential of our collective capabilities and drive forward progress for all.
Victoria Mattingly is CEO of Mattingly Solutions, a DEI consulting firm. She grew up in Swissvale and currently resides in Stanton Heights.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.