Parents shopping for summer drinks for their children will see a lot of colorful fruit drinks with cartoon characters and eye-catching images designed to catch their children’s attention — and boasts about added vitamins and minerals to catch theirs. But the reality is, these drinks are packed with added sugars their children don’t need.
Children in the U.S. are averaging 80 grams of added sugars per day (the amount in eight Krispy Kreme glazed donuts!) which is more than triple the recommended amount, and fruit drinks are the top sugar-sweetened beverage consumed among children younger than four. Sugary drinks are associated with health issues such as cavities, weight gain, and type 2 diabetes.
One in five children live with obesity. Youth-onset type 2 diabetes was basically nonexistent 30 years ago, but between 2001 and 2017, the prevalence of this disease increased by 95.3% among youth between the ages of 10 and 19. Prevention in the form of limiting sugary beverages is important because excess weight gain and type 2 diabetes are very difficult to reverse.
Vitamins and sugar
In a study published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, of which I was an author, we looked at 510 fruit drinks and found that companies had added vitamin C to many of them. What’s so bad about adding healthy nutrients to these drinks? Isn’t vitamin C good for us?
The truth is, kids in the U.S. aren’t deficient in vitamin C. In fact, vitamin C is no longer required on the Nutrition Facts Label on packaged foods precisely because the vast majority of Americans already have sufficient intake of this nutrient.
But pumping sugary fruit drinks with vitamin C allows companies to present as a healthy snack what is essentially sugar water. Beverage companies know how to capture a busy parent’s attention and wallet, preying on parents who rely on quick facts located on the front of the package to determine if a drink is healthy and appropriate for their child.
Research shows that marketing claims like “100% Vitamin C” on sugary fruit drinks can mislead consumers into thinking that these products are healthy. What these claims don’t reveal are the teaspoons of added sugar that come with the vitamin C. Parents are gatekeepers to their children, and these misleading claims are a sneaky way to fool them into buying something they wouldn’t necessarily buy if they knew all the facts.
The jelly bean rule
So why are companies allowed to fortify sugar water to make them more appealing to parents? Under what’s known as the “jelly bean rule,” the FDA does not permit companies to add micronutrients like vitamins and minerals to snack foods and carbonated beverages.
The FDA’s own guidance makes it clear that they are concerned that, “fortification of these types of snack foods could mislead consumers to believe that substitution of naturally nutrient dense foods with fortified snack foods would ensure a nutritionally adequate diet.”
That means that there is a simple solution to the problem of adding nutrients to sugary drinks: the FDA should update their regulation so that no sugar-sweetened beverages, not just ones that are carbonated, can be fortified with vitamins and minerals. This small change will make it easier for busy parents who are out school shopping to not be misled into thinking their children need these sugary fruit drinks to meet vitamin requirements they likely have already met.
Sophia Hua is an assistant professor of health policy in the Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy at the University of Pennsylvania. She was the lead author of Child-Directed Marketing, Health Claims, and Nutrients in Popular Beverages.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.