Right now, for every $100 you spend, your retailer pays a percentage of that $100 to the credit card company for processing the sale, plus 2% of the $6 sales tax. That sales tax, of course, goes straight to the Commonwealth. The retailer doesn’t get to keep any of it and the 2% they are charged comes out of their pocket.

My family owns three grocery stores here in the Pittsburgh area. This affects me directly, but affects consumers because stores like mine that operate on narrow profit margins have to raise our prices to cover the charges. It’s a small charge, but it adds up.

It’s also a good example of the kind of challenges small businesses face, which affect their customers as well.

Profitable status quo

The credit card industry and the big banks and airlines they work with like the status quo because it makes them a lot of money.

Advertise with us

Look up the profit margins of publicly traded companies like Visa and Mastercard. Compare them to retailers in the food sector. Last year, Visa’s profit margin — the amount they kept in profit after tax — was around 50%. The average grocer’s is around 1.6%.

With Visa and Mastercard controlling nearly 90% of the credit card industry, and credit cards now making up most grocery store transactions, they have found themselves with a pretty sweet deal. And to be clear: I value the convenience and utility of credit cards and recognize processing fees as a cost of doing business. But getting charged a fee on sales tax that I am simply passing on to the state isn’t right.

But back to profit margins. You might ask what do the credit card companies do with all that money? Well, apart from getting Jennifer Garner to star in their commercials, they can do a lot of public outreach and pay for bombastic marketing on issues that would disrupt their monopolistic behavior, like House Bill 2394.

The bill passed state House Finance Committee on June 12. It would prohibit swipe fees from being charged on the sales tax portion of electronic transactions.

Over the top reaction

Since that committee vote, big banks and their partners have flooded the zone with claims bordering on the hysterical. Quite frankly, the industry’s reaction is over the top. The claims are misleading at best, and wholly out of proportion with the change being proposed.

Advertise with us

Apart from anything else is the suggestion that only “the largest convenience store chains and corporate megastores” would benefit from the bill. That’s nonsense.

Every single business that takes credit cards and collects sales tax would benefit. Businesses would save around 2% of the amount of the sales tax they collect and remit to the Department of Revenue.

It’s not rocket science or even particularly difficult arithmetic. And customers would benefit, too, because competition works and as costs go down in a competitive marketplace, so do prices. It’s basic economics, and basic logic. You see it right now as the prices of all sorts of goods are coming down in stores across Pennsylvania.

On points and rewards, too, the claims don’t hold up. In jurisdictions where swipe fees have seen actual, substantial limits placed on them, like in Australia, banks still offer significant credit card rewards as they compete for customers. Why would they stop doing everything they can to earn your business?

Businesses in food retail, with its considerably lower margins, manage to offer all sorts of points and rewards programs to loyal customers. Again, this line of argument just doesn’t stand up.

Advertise with us

Table pounding

There is an adage in the legal profession you may have heard: “If you have the facts on your side, pound the facts. If you have the law on your side, pound the law. If you have neither the facts nor the law, pound the table.”

When it comes to swipe fees and HB 2394, the credit card companies are most definitely pounding the table.

Tom Charley is co-owner of Charley Family Shop ‘N Save, which operates three Shop ‘N Save grocery stores in Westmoreland County. He also is on the board of directors for the Pennsylvania Food Merchants Association. His previous article was “Payment processors are keeping senior citizens from getting healthy food.”