“Bellissima!” exclaimed yet another person upon seeing our baby in a stroller, followed by some enthusiastic remarks in Italian whose meaning our seven-month-old understood better than we did. We encountered this situation countless times in a recent trip to Italy.
Italy was so child-friendly that it was jarring. We didn’t expect to be welcomed into fine restaurants and other public spaces so readily or genuinely. We didn’t anticipate the accommodation of a separate “family line” to get through Italian airport security.
We didn’t expect Italians everywhere to be so overjoyed to see American tourists with a baby in tow.
In Italy, not in the States
In the States, one often has to think about whether it’s appropriate to bring a baby somewhere. Is this too nice of a restaurant for a kid? Will this place care if we bring in a stroller? Will people get mad if she starts crying? In Italy, we never had to worry about these things.
We sampled fine wine in Montepulciano while Maggie blew the longest and loudest raspberries she could muster. We dined on Tuscan tartar with a baby babbling (sometimes fussing) in our laps. We pilgrimed to some of the most magnificent basilicas and churches on earth while our kid made crazy noises just to hear them echo.
And no one cared. They were more than happy to have a baby there.
Read More
It’s hard to imagine doing these things in the United States without getting sideways stares of disapproval. That’s sad, but perhaps not surprising. Our mores on children and family are changing.
Not only are people having fewer children, but increasingly young people don’t see marriage as a prerequisite for having kids. They say that marriage is an outdated and superfluous institution fraught with religious and moral concerns that don’t matter anymore.
Two people can be just as committed to each other without being married as they can be married, so why bother? Too many people end up divorced anyway.
The problem with this perspective is that it’s not rooted in reality. Marriage involves a level of commitment and vulnerability that can’t be replicated outside of marriage.
Commitment and vulnerability
When two people get married, they make a very public and very permanent commitment to each other that unmarried couples have never made. A married couple has taken vows. An unmarried couple has not.
A married couple has placed their human frailty on public display and promised that their love will endure. An unmarried couple has never taken this risk. A married couple has asked for the support of their loved ones as they live out their commitment. An unmarried couple has never asked for this support because they do not make this commitment.
The reality of marriage, quite frankly, is different because of the vowed life that married couples strive to live.
And it’s in striving to live out this commitment that the foundation for childrearing is laid. This isn’t to say that single parents or other family structures can’t raise good kids, but studies repeatedly show that two-parent households yield better outcomes for children socially, educationally and economically.
This striving is never perfect, nor is it always easy. But that makes it all the more important to support those who are so striving. The support from strangers that our family received abroad made all the difference as we detoured into Parmesan alleys for diaper changes and orchestrated feedings at Roman cafes.
Their hospitality helped us to be better parents and by extension better spouses — and that’s no small matter. In fact, that’s the whole point of taking vows. Living them out is supposed to make us better, which is why they’re so important.
Welcoming children
This is also why it’s important to support each other as we carry out these commitments. If we supported our families better — by being more welcoming to children and having mandatory parental leave and childcare support like other developed nations — we’d all be better.
If we don’t support our families, it will be for the worse. A society that doesn’t make space for its children is inherently disordered. It will collapse in on itself.
It is true that marriages can fail, and sometimes acknowledging that failure is in everyone’s best interest. It is also true that our families are hopelessly imperfect because we are imperfect. But if we continue to make the perfect the enemy of the good, we will lose whatever capacity we have for the good in the first place.
Ryan Hrobak serves as assistant general counsel to Saint Vincent College and Archabbey, where he also teaches in the theology department. He lives in Bloomfield with his family. His previous article was “The key to happiness isn't work: It's enjoying the worthless world.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.