“Bel­lis­sima!” ex­claimed yet an­other per­son upon see­ing our baby in a stroller, fol­lowed by some en­thu­si­as­tic re­marks in Ital­ian whose mean­ing our seven-month-old un­der­stood bet­ter than we did. We en­coun­tered this sit­u­a­tion count­less times in a re­cent trip to Italy.

Italy was so child-friendly that it was jar­ring. We didn’t ex­pect to be wel­comed into fine restau­rants and other pub­lic spaces so read­ily or gen­u­inely. We didn’t an­tic­i­pate the ac­com­mo­da­tion of a sep­a­rate “fam­ily line” to get through Ital­ian air­port se­cu­rity.

We didn’t ex­pect Ital­ians ev­ery­where to be so over­joyed to see Amer­i­can tour­ists with a baby in tow.

In Italy, not in the States

In the States, one of­ten has to think about whether it’s ap­pro­pri­ate to bring a baby some­where. Is this too nice of a restau­rant for a kid? Will this place care if we bring in a stroller? Will peo­ple get mad if she starts cry­ing? In Italy, we never had to worry about these things.

Advertise with us

We sam­pled fine wine in Montepul­ci­ano while Mag­gie blew the lon­gest and loud­est rasp­ber­ries she could mus­ter. We dined on Tus­can tar­tar with a baby bab­bling (some­times fuss­ing) in our laps. We pil­grimed to some of the most mag­nif­i­cent ba­sil­i­cas and churches on earth while our kid made crazy noises just to hear them echo.

And no one cared. They were more than happy to have a baby there.

It’s hard to imag­ine do­ing these things in the United States with­out get­ting side­ways stares of dis­ap­proval. That’s sad, but per­haps not sur­pris­ing. Our mo­res on chil­dren and fam­ily are chang­ing.

Not only are peo­ple hav­ing fewer chil­dren, but in­creas­ingly young peo­ple don’t see mar­riage as a pre­req­ui­site for hav­ing kids. They say that mar­riage is an out­dated and su­per­flu­ous in­sti­tu­tion fraught with re­li­gious and moral con­cerns that don’t mat­ter any­more.

Two peo­ple can be just as com­mit­ted to each other with­out be­ing mar­ried as they can be mar­ried, so why bother? Too many peo­ple end up di­vorced any­way.

Advertise with us

The prob­lem with this per­spec­tive is that it’s not rooted in re­al­ity. Mar­riage in­volves a level of com­mit­ment and vul­ner­a­bil­ity that can’t be rep­li­cated out­side of mar­riage.

Com­mit­ment and vul­ner­a­bil­ity

When two peo­ple get mar­ried, they make a very pub­lic and very per­ma­nent com­mit­ment to each other that un­mar­ried cou­ples have never made. A mar­ried cou­ple has taken vows. An un­mar­ried cou­ple has not.

A mar­ried cou­ple has placed their hu­man frailty on pub­lic dis­play and prom­ised that their love will en­dure. An un­mar­ried cou­ple has never taken this risk. A mar­ried cou­ple has asked for the sup­port of their loved ones as they live out their com­mit­ment. An un­mar­ried cou­ple has never asked for this sup­port be­cause they do not make this com­mit­ment.

The re­al­ity of mar­riage, quite frankly, is dif­fer­ent be­cause of the vowed life that mar­ried cou­ples strive to live.

And it’s in striv­ing to live out this com­mit­ment that the foun­da­tion for chil­drear­ing is laid. This isn’t to say that sin­gle par­ents or other fam­ily struc­tures can’t raise good kids, but stud­ies re­peat­edly show that two-par­ent house­holds yield bet­ter out­comes for chil­dren so­cially, ed­u­ca­tion­ally and eco­nom­i­cally.

Advertise with us

This striv­ing is never per­fect, nor is it al­ways easy. But that makes it all the more im­por­tant to sup­port those who are so striv­ing. The sup­port from strang­ers that our fam­ily re­ceived abroad made all the dif­fer­ence as we de­toured into Parme­san al­leys for di­a­per changes and or­ches­trated feed­ings at Roman ca­fes.

Their hos­pi­tal­ity helped us to be bet­ter par­ents and by ex­ten­sion bet­ter spouses — and that’s no small mat­ter. In fact, that’s the whole point of tak­ing vows. Liv­ing them out is sup­posed to make us bet­ter, which is why they’re so im­por­tant.

Wel­com­ing chil­dren

This is also why it’s im­por­tant to sup­port each other as we carry out these com­mit­ments. If we sup­ported our fam­i­lies bet­ter — by be­ing more wel­com­ing to chil­dren and hav­ing man­da­tory pa­ren­tal leave and child­care sup­port like other de­vel­oped na­tions — we’d all be bet­ter.

If we don’t sup­port our fam­i­lies, it will be for the worse. A so­ci­ety that doesn’t make space for its chil­dren is in­her­ently dis­or­dered. It will col­lapse in on it­self.

It is true that mar­riages can fail, and some­times ac­knowl­edg­ing that fail­ure is in ev­ery­one’s best in­ter­est. It is also true that our fam­i­lies are hope­lessly im­per­fect be­cause we are im­per­fect. But if we con­tinue to make the per­fect the en­emy of the good, we will lose what­ever ca­pac­ity we have for the good in the first place.

Ryan Hrobak serves as assistant general counsel to Saint Vincent College and Archabbey, where he also teaches in the theology department. He lives in Bloomfield with his family. His previous article was “The key to happiness isn't work: It's enjoying the worthless world.”