As a pro­fes­sional ath­lete in a coun­try that idol­izes ath­letes, Har­ri­son But­ker has a plat­form to do great good. Un­for­tu­nately, he used his plat­form, the com­mence­ment dais at Ben­e­dic­tine Col­lege, to pro­mote his my­o­pic views on the roles of women. His mis­guided mes­sage ig­nores the eco­nomic re­al­ity of many women’s lives.

But­ker ad­dressed the “la­dies pres­ent” and spoke of the “di­a­bol­i­cal lies” told to them. He got it wrong. The di­a­bol­i­cal lies are not what we tell women re­gard­ing ca­reers, or whether it is pos­si­ble to suc­cess­fully com­bine work with fam­ily life.

The di­a­bol­i­cal lie is the idea he ad­vanced that ev­ery woman has the op­tion to not work.

What But­ker ig­nores

Fight­ing back tears, But­ker spoke of his own wife aban­don­ing her ca­reer dreams, and adopt­ing his vi­sion of the only ac­cept­able fe­male vo­ca­tion: full-time home­making. He as­serted that his wife would re­spond, “Heck, no,” if asked whether she re­gret­ted her choice.

Advertise with us

What he ig­nores is that Isa­belle But­ker is mar­ried to a pro­fes­sional ath­lete with a multi-mil­lion dol­lar yearly sal­ary, plus en­dorse­ment deals, ap­pear­ance fees, and more. She has the lux­ury of choice that not all women have.

In homes with one wage earner mak­ing a solid in­come, fam­i­lies of­ten need a sec­ond in­come to pay for their chil­dren’s ex­tra­cur­ric­u­lar ac­tiv­i­ties (in­clud­ing sports), or the ris­ing cost of col­lege tu­i­tion. Eco­nom­i­cally dis­ad­van­taged fam­i­lies of­ten strug­gle to keep their chil­dren fed and housed even with two in­comes.

Many women never marry. Some women have part­ners who die, be­come in­ca­pac­i­tated, or aban­don them. Other women forego do­mes­tic life in fa­vor of re­li­gious vo­ca­tions. Maybe that is why the sis­ters of Mount St. Scho­las­tica, whose or­der founded the col­lege, said he is fos­ter­ing di­vi­sions “in our church, our na­tion, and the world.”

Women’s con­tri­bu­tions

Con­trary to his as­ser­tions, not all women work to gain “pro­mo­tions and ti­tles.” But if these are a woman’s mo­tives, we should not con­demn her. Men who work with those goals are lauded as hard-work­ing, am­bi­tious, and suc­cess­ful. There should not be a dou­ble stan­dard.

Where would the world be with­out the con­tri­bu­tions of working women — like But­ker’s own mother, med­i­cal phys­i­cist Eliz­a­beth Keller But­ker?

Advertise with us

For many years I bal­anced a ca­reer with mar­riage and moth­er­hood. I’m glad my chil­dren had par­ents who weren’t lim­ited by gen­der ste­reo­types. They saw both par­ents do house chores, take care of them when they were sick, have re­spon­si­bil­i­ties out­side of the home, and earn a liv­ing.

My job in­volved pub­lic ser­vice. As they grew older, my chil­dren un­der­stood that my work helped oth­ers and were proud of that.

Ten years ago I un­ex­pect­edly lost my job due to bud­get cuts. A pen­sion and guar­an­teed health­care al­lowed me early re­tire­ment from the work­force. Now my role in our fam­ily is more tra­di­tional, as is my hus­band’s. I en­joyed hav­ing a ca­reer and now I en­joy be­ing at home. Each phase has brought its own chal­lenges and joys.

Each phase ben­e­fit­ted my fam­ily in dif­fer­ent ways. Through it all my pri­or­i­ties have re­mained the same: my Cath­o­lic faith and my fam­ily.

No sin­gle path

There is no sin­gle path to liv­ing your best life, ful­fill­ing your des­tiny, or fol­low­ing God’s will. Women are not tai­lor-made for one role in life. Some­times life cir­cum­stances dic­tate your choices.

Advertise with us

If women do not adapt to change and seize op­por­tu­ni­ties the same as men, they do a dis­ser­vice to them­selves, their fam­i­lies, their com­mu­ni­ties, and the world. In sug­gest­ing oth­er­wise, Har­ri­son But­ker ad­vanced a di­a­bol­i­cal lie.

But­ker con­tin­u­ally spoke of the need for each of us to stay in our lane. He has never been a ca­reer woman, a work­ing wife or mother, or a full-time home­maker. He is not even typ­i­cal of male wage earners. He has been blessed with tal­ents and op­por­tu­ni­ties that elude most men, and is ex­tra­or­di­nar­ily well paid for kick­ing a foot­ball.

Per­haps he needs to heed his own ad­vice and stay in his place: the foot­ball field.

Karen Sirianni Gerlach, a retired lawyer, is a wife and mother living in the Pittsburgh area.