As a professional athlete in a country that idolizes athletes, Harrison Butker has a platform to do great good. Unfortunately, he used his platform, the commencement dais at Benedictine College, to promote his myopic views on the roles of women. His misguided message ignores the economic reality of many women’s lives.
Butker addressed the “ladies present” and spoke of the “diabolical lies” told to them. He got it wrong. The diabolical lies are not what we tell women regarding careers, or whether it is possible to successfully combine work with family life.
The diabolical lie is the idea he advanced that every woman has the option to not work.
What Butker ignores
Fighting back tears, Butker spoke of his own wife abandoning her career dreams, and adopting his vision of the only acceptable female vocation: full-time homemaking. He asserted that his wife would respond, “Heck, no,” if asked whether she regretted her choice.
What he ignores is that Isabelle Butker is married to a professional athlete with a multi-million dollar yearly salary, plus endorsement deals, appearance fees, and more. She has the luxury of choice that not all women have.
In homes with one wage earner making a solid income, families often need a second income to pay for their children’s extracurricular activities (including sports), or the rising cost of college tuition. Economically disadvantaged families often struggle to keep their children fed and housed even with two incomes.
Many women never marry. Some women have partners who die, become incapacitated, or abandon them. Other women forego domestic life in favor of religious vocations. Maybe that is why the sisters of Mount St. Scholastica, whose order founded the college, said he is fostering divisions “in our church, our nation, and the world.”
Women’s contributions
Contrary to his assertions, not all women work to gain “promotions and titles.” But if these are a woman’s motives, we should not condemn her. Men who work with those goals are lauded as hard-working, ambitious, and successful. There should not be a double standard.
Where would the world be without the contributions of working women — like Butker’s own mother, medical physicist Elizabeth Keller Butker?
For many years I balanced a career with marriage and motherhood. I’m glad my children had parents who weren’t limited by gender stereotypes. They saw both parents do house chores, take care of them when they were sick, have responsibilities outside of the home, and earn a living.
My job involved public service. As they grew older, my children understood that my work helped others and were proud of that.
Ten years ago I unexpectedly lost my job due to budget cuts. A pension and guaranteed healthcare allowed me early retirement from the workforce. Now my role in our family is more traditional, as is my husband’s. I enjoyed having a career and now I enjoy being at home. Each phase has brought its own challenges and joys.
Each phase benefitted my family in different ways. Through it all my priorities have remained the same: my Catholic faith and my family.
No single path
There is no single path to living your best life, fulfilling your destiny, or following God’s will. Women are not tailor-made for one role in life. Sometimes life circumstances dictate your choices.
If women do not adapt to change and seize opportunities the same as men, they do a disservice to themselves, their families, their communities, and the world. In suggesting otherwise, Harrison Butker advanced a diabolical lie.
Butker continually spoke of the need for each of us to stay in our lane. He has never been a career woman, a working wife or mother, or a full-time homemaker. He is not even typical of male wage earners. He has been blessed with talents and opportunities that elude most men, and is extraordinarily well paid for kicking a football.
Perhaps he needs to heed his own advice and stay in his place: the football field.
Karen Sirianni Gerlach, a retired lawyer, is a wife and mother living in the Pittsburgh area.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.