How should we define leadership? Is it innate or learned? How do we distinguish a true leader from a demagogue or a con artist?

As a journalist, citizen, and student of political philosophy, I have been pondering leadership for four decades. A homespun definition: When I was a teen, my pastor said a leader is the person who, when he sees that someone has fainted in a crowd, driven his car off the road, or is being bullied, steps up and steps in.

Firefighters are leaders. They run to trouble. Nurses are leaders. Fathers are leaders, if they listen and learn.

John F. Kennedy said that leadership and learning are indivisible. Consider the lack of leadership in most universities today.

Advertise with us

Second homespun definition: My late friend, Jerome N. Eller, ace Capitol Hill aide, teacher and journalist, once asked me if I knew why he sought to elect Eugene J. McCarthy president of the United States. “The issues,” I asked? “His prescience?”

Nah, he said. None of that. Three reasons: “He can live alone. He doesn’t lie to himself. And he can change a tire.”

What makes a leader

To me a leader must be at least three of four things:

He must be a scout. He must be willing to move out in front, perhaps into unknown territory. With experience, he may learn to “see around corners,” to use Mary McGrory’s phrase about Mr. McCarthy. Rachel Carson was a scout. So was Upton Sinclair, who exposed the abuses of the meat-packing industry and ran for governor of California.

He must be a thinker, and even a skeptic (not a cynic). He must be able to do his own thinking, and be willing to take the time to do so — re-examining not only conventional wisdom, but what he once thought was his own wisdom. George Orwell was a leader in this sense. So was Hannah Arendt.

Advertise with us

He must be a builder. Leaders build, they do not tear down. Franklin Roosevelt was the builder, par excellence. So was A. Philip Randolph. And Frances Xavier Cabrini. But, also, William F. Buckley, Jr. He built a movement he was strong enough to dissent from in later life.

He must have courage. Churchill said: “Success is not final, failure is not fatal: it is the courage to continue that counts.” When I think of courage, I think of Rosa Parks. And Alexei Navalny.

Leaders are not plaster saints (most real leaders possess a will that can be ruthless), or always right and must be followed blindly. It is that they help us to find the leader in ourselves. They help us to think, see and act.

Rivals to friends

Hence I rise today to praise two Pittsburghers who have recently left us and who led: Jim Roddey and Cyril Wecht.

They were very different men. They were one-time political rivals who became close friends. But both were all four things: Scouts. Thinkers. Builders. And men of courage.

Advertise with us

Mr. Roddey was a consensus builder. He was a Republican who succeeded in a Democratic town. That’s because he was more interested in getting things done than getting credit. When one door shut, he found another way to serve. In his tenth decade on this earth, he was doing radio commentaries on local heroes. He was a politician, yes. But, even more, a public servant.

Ditto, Dr. Wecht, a constant in Pittsburgh public life for decades. But his greatest contribution was his ability to raise questions about seemingly settled great crimes and medical science, and the intersection of the two. Talk about prescient. His critique of the Warren Commission conclusions on the Kennedy assassination, once thought far out, now appears as what it was all along — reasoned and brave. The same is true of his stand on concussions in the NFL.

True men

Cyril Wecht had a lion’s heart and, in the spirit of Churchill, kept going. He was street smart, book smart, very funny, and he cared. Like Mr. Roddey, he cared to the end. He cared about truth, his family, this sacred republic and Israel, until the day he died.

Jim Roddey could be almost as politically incorrect as Dr. Wecht. (He told me Joe Biden was too old and had muffed the Mexican border problem. But when he considered Kamala Harris and Donald Trump he prayed for Mr. Biden’s health.) Lame jokes were forgiven, because he was such a courtly Southern gentleman and such a helper. “Look for the helpers,” Fred Rogers’ mother told him.

And that raises a final point: Both of these men had a quality that is not always found in leaders. But when it is, we are ennobled: Jim Roddey was a mensch. Cyril Wecht was a mensch.

Advertise with us

Some years ago I asked a Jewish friend to help me to fully understand this word. “It means,” and he paused for what seemed like a while “... a person with soul; a true human being.”

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “What I'd say in a commencement address in a world like ours.”