I was a difficult kid: Defiant, angry and, too often, delinquent. I skipped school, spent a lot of time in the principal’s office and was expelled more than once.

Eventually I stepped too far over the line and got arrested. I was sent to a detention center in Westmoreland County, but the organization that ran the facility didn’t provide much in the way of rehabilitative services. As soon as I got out, I was right back in trouble. A lot of people gave up on me. It’s fair to say I even gave up on myself.

And then, when I was 16, I moved into a group home operated by Adelphoi, the non-profit organization that’s set to operate Shuman Juvenile Detention Center when it opens. The home wasn’t perfect, by any means. but it helped me benefit from the wide range of services that Adelphoi provides, including family, group and individual therapy, and treatment for PTSD.

It’s fair to say I would not have been able to pull myself out of the trouble I was in at the time or to create the life I now enjoy had it not been for the time I spent there.

Advertise with us

Unnecessary violence

I understand from experience the essential role that services for at-risk youths, and particularly detention, play in protecting these youths and their families and in keeping our communities safe, and I’ve watched the ongoing debate over a contract signed to re-open Shuman with great concern.

The lack of detention services in Allegheny County since Shuman closed almost three years ago has already led to tragic consequences, and we simply cannot afford to let a jurisdictional dispute upend plans to re-open Shuman later this year.

According to a May 2023 analysis by the Pennsylvania Juvenile Court Judges’ Commission, since Shuman closed in September 2021, at least 234 Allegheny County young people have met the criteria for detention or have been court-ordered to detention, but were not detained because of a lack of detention beds.

Of those 234 kids, five were subsequently and tragically shot and killed. One died of an overdose. And at least one was critically injured in a shooting. Since that study is now almost a year old, I’m sure these devastating statistics have only gotten worse. I shudder when I think that I easily could have been one of those statistics.

Clear and present danger

Detention serves as short-term intervention designed to offer immediate protection for a child, his or her family, and the community in situations in which sending that child back home is unsafe. Detention also provides an opportunity for a child to participate in assessments that identify the most appropriate services to meet his or her long-term needs — the kind of personal, individualized attention that changed my life.

Advertise with us

To best serve the people of Allegheny County, our juvenile justice system needs as many arrows in its proverbial quiver as possible. While detention services should always be a last resort, the option should be there when we need it.

The dispute over the contract to re-open Shuman is a political and legal dispute over who has the authority to sign the contract. I get that issues involving legal authority are important. But as a beneficiary of services for at-risk youth and a resident of Allegheny County, I also recognize the clear and present danger that a lack of detention services represents.

I urge our county leaders to get together, settle their differences and get Shuman back up and running as soon as possible. The people of Allegheny County deserve nothing less.

Zach Williams works as a regional manager for a food services company and coaches football for disadvantaged youth.