Imagine an older customer in a grocery store approaches the checkout counter with a cart filled with healthy foods, and when she presents her government payment card, she’s told the store can’t accept it, even though it has the Visa or MasterCard logo. She wants to know why, and there’s no good answer.
I don’t have to imagine that scenario, because I and many other independent grocers are seeing it play out every day.
No healthy benefits
My family owns three grocery stores here in the Pittsburgh area, and I’ve known some of our customers my whole life. One of them is Marge, who’s been shopping in my stores for over 30 years.
Marge is a Medicare recipient, and her plan provides her with a Healthy Benefit Card that can be used to purchase fresh fruits, vegetables and other nutritious foods. As the old saying says, “An apple a day keeps the doctor away,” and the goal here is to help people like her avoid hospital stays and catastrophic illnesses. The cards are part of a government-created program, but the money comes from insurance, and not taxpayers.
Marge wanted to know why I couldn’t accept her card. And I want to know, too.
Unfortunately, a handful of big payment processors are standing in the way, refusing to expand the Healthy Benefit Card program beyond a handful of gigantic chains. That hurts recipients of Healthy Benefit Cards in some of America’s biggest cities and smallest rural towns, who don’t always have convenient access to these big stores, or any access at all.
Read More
Marge tells me she lives two miles from my store, and she likes to shop with us because she knows our employees and is treated like a member of the family. She doesn’t feel comfortable driving long distances, and she doesn’t want to switch to a big box store where she’ll be treated like another nameless, faceless customer just so she can use this card.
They can’t or won’t
I’ve personally been trying to solve this problem with the payment processors for about a year, and I still can’t get a straight answer why they can’t (or won’t) allow us to help our customers use these cards.
The argument seems to be that unlike the nation’s biggest chains, we don’t have common codes for items sold in our deli, bakery, meat and produce departments, making it hard to reconcile the data. I’m not sure why insurance companies like Aetna or Humana need to know how much spinach or how many artichokes we sell, but we’ve offered to work with them.
Stores big and small have successfully adopted payment systems for the government-run Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC). There’s no good reason why we couldn’t do the same with Healthy Benefit Cards.
This is yet another example of how big chains routinely use their size and influence to get lucrative advantages over independent stores like mine.
Cut the red tape
Independent grocers like me are already playing on an uneven field, and freezing us out of the Healthy Benefit Card program hands an even bigger advantage to the big chains. It also ensures that my customers will no longer have the option of shopping local and pumping money back into their own community.
The Healthy Benefit cards were designed to enrich the lives of older Americans like Marge, and she shouldn’t be forced to trade her choice as a consumer.
I’m hoping that some of the same lawmakers who helped create this worthy program can cut the red tape and help it work as it was designed.
Tom Charley is a resident of Greensburg and a fourth-generation grocer. He and his family own three Charley Family Shop N’ Save stores in the Pittsburgh area.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.