Vladimir Putin can­not be haunted. He be­longs to the dark and re­morse­less school of kill­ers whose ranks in­clude Hitler, Sta­lin, Mao, Pol Pot and Idi Amin. The scale of their crimes may vary but not the in­tent, and not the ap­ti­tude for cru­elty and vi­o­lence.

But his even­tual suc­ces­sors in Rus­sia will be haunted. And to­tal­i­tar­ian copy­cats of Putin, both pres­ent and fu­ture, will be haunted.

Alexei Navalny is the mar­tyr to lib­erty and de­moc­racy of our time. And he will haunt all en­e­mies of free­dom. But, in a dif­fer­ent sense, he should haunt the West.

A haunted West

In two ways. First, did we do enough to keep him alive? I don’t think we did. The United States got Brit­tney Gri­ner, the fe­male bas­ket­ball star, out of Rus­sia. (Marc Fo­gel, of Pitts­burgh, is for­got­ten and re­mains).

Advertise with us

If not get­ting him re­leased, might the West, col­lec­tively, have made Mr. Putin at least think twice about kill­ing Navalny?

Prob­a­bly not. This is what re­morse­less means. Putin cer­tainly has not thought twice about his war on Ukraine and its in­no­cents — war crimes as war strat­egy. Maybe this is just who Putin is. The ex­pla­na­tion is not geo­po­lit­i­cal but meta-eth­i­cal — evil or­ga­nized.

Navalny him­self once ob­served that war has al­ways worked for Rus­sian dic­ta­tors. So don’t ex­pect Pu­tinism to die with Putin.

We might have failed to save Navalny if we’d tried harder. But why didn’t we try harder? We did not pay much at­ten­tion when they hauled him off to the Arc­tic Cir­cle, though it was pretty clear what would hap­pen.

The sec­ond way Navalny should haunt us is this: A to­tal com­mit­ment to an ideal can cost a per­son his life in this world.

Advertise with us

That ought to so­ber us. His ideal was a demo­cratic Rus­sia — a Rus­sia of law, free speech and free as­so­ci­a­tion.

In the days since his death, hun­dreds of Rus­sians have been ar­rested for pay­ing trib­ute to him in the streets. An aw­fully small start, you may say. Ah, but mil­lions have read his writ­ing and watched his in­ter­views and vid­eos and know how, and where, and by whose ul­ti­mate hand, he died.

He was not a per­fect man. No man is. But what kind of a man, hav­ing been poi­soned twice, goes back to Rus­sia to face prison, tor­ture, and death?

Tell me the right word.

We are not Navalny

Solz­hen­it­syn, the pre-em­i­nent Rus­sian dis­senter of two gen­er­a­tions ago, got out. But he had help. He had been poi­soned and would have been re-im­pris­oned and killed. But Willy Brandt, of West Ger­many, of­fered shel­ter in his coun­try. So the KGB ex­pelled the dis­si­dent. And Stan­ford Univer­sity, in the United States, soon there­af­ter of­fered to host him.

Advertise with us

Those were the days of de­tente, when we thought we had to en­gage evil, not just name it, to de­feat it.

And of the di­plo­macy of hu­man rights — when ev­ery small fight for hu­man dig­nity mat­tered and was our cause.

What is our cause to­day? What be­came of hu­man rights?

Do we even be­gin to un­der­stand Navalny’s brav­ery? Where was the West when he was taken and tor­tured? Where is it now? Where were the pro­tests? Where is our out­rage?

And how many of us would die for our coun­try? A coun­try is land, lan­guage, tra­di­tion, but, also, ideas. This coun­try, more than any in the world, is based upon ideas. Few of us are in­dig­e­nous.

Advertise with us

We are bound by con­cepts: Due pro­cess of law; free speech and thought; the right to dis­sent; es­sen­tial hu­man equal­ity with all its ram­i­fi­ca­tions.

How many would risk even their po­lit­i­cal lives for these rights?

There have only been a few “pro­files in cour­age” in re­cent years. Mike Pence and Rusty Bow­ers stood up to elec­tion theft, and paid. Some years back, Bob Ca­sey Sr. dared to in­sist that pro-life Dem­o­crats had a place in his party.

This kind of cour­age pales in com­par­i­son with Navalny’s, but there is pre­cious lit­tle even of it. Indeed, I am not sure that there is much sense of the coun­try, or of cit­i­zen­ship, in the U.S. to­day.

The young think in terms of group iden­ti­ties. But it is not only the young. If wok­ism is a civil re­li­gion, the fake na­tion­al­ism of the right (ev­ery­where) is both a re­li­gion sub­sti­tute and an iden­tity. And both ya­hoo na­tion­al­ism and wok­ism are cheap: Put a “let’s go Bran­don” or a “re­sist” sticker on your car, and you are good to go.

Advertise with us

The fake and the real

Fake con­vic­tion and fake pa­tri­o­tism are alike in this: No ser­vice or sac­ri­fice is re­quired.

Navalny had to go back. He was not a writer like Solz­hen­it­syn. He was a cit­i­zen. He needed to be in a pub­lic space, even if it was as small as a cell.

His life should un­nerve bully boys and ty­rants and shame lib­eral dem­o­crats, but then teach us and give us cour­age.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “We know enough about Trump to know we don't want him.”