Too many working families in southwestern Pennsylvania end up in eviction proceedings because they’re struggling to make ends meet.
Those proceedings make much harder their finding the safe, secure, affordable housing that is the first step to achieving long-term economic security. We all need a stable place to live before we can be expected to succeed at finding a job, budgeting, or getting a good education.
Devastating records
As general counsel for ACTION-Housing and Chief Executive Officer for Brandywine Communities — or, as we are more familiarly known, landlords — we regularly engage with the eviction system. We strive to provide respectable, stable housing for thousands of residents that is truly affordable and meets livability standards.
But we also file eviction cases every year. Eviction is often the only leverage landlords have to ensure we can continue providing affordable housing to all tenants.
Though we often have no better option, we know that eviction filing records can devastate tenants, shutting them out of decent housing, because they made one financial misstep from years ago or even had a case filed against them through no fault of their own.
An eviction case can be filed against tenants for many reasons. That filing remains on record even if the tenant wins the case (for example, if the tenant withheld rent while a landlord failed to address significant livability problems). Under current rules, the hatchet is never buried. Report of an eviction filing stays on record into perpetuity, always available for viewing.
But knowing a tenant has been involved in eviction proceedings in the past does very little — if anything — to help landlords identify or warn against problem renters. We can both think of many instances in which current or former tenants have been turned down repeatedly for apartment rentals, despite excellent credit and stable employment.
And we all incur the extra human services costs when individuals and families lose their homes.
Needed changes
As people who navigate the system every day, it is clear to us that changes are needed. That’s why we are supporting legislation, House Bill 1769, that would place a common-sense, four-year time-limit on eviction-case records being available for public view.
Pennsylvania has a 10-year limit on access to criminal records involving felonies and seven years for misdemeanors. In the financial world, bankruptcy filings and missed payments are removed from credit reports after seven years.
The internet and automated screening practices have made record searching easier as landlords sort through rental applicants to find the best tenants. More landlords are using data reporting agencies, even though studies have shown that background checks are poor predictors of successful tenancy.
These reports will prove to be more useful and efficient if irrelevant information, like old eviction filings (many of which were actually won by the tenant or settled before verdict), saving landlords like us time and money.
The proposed legislation would resolve instances of records being inaccurate, incomplete, or lacking context by automatically denying access except for cases in which the landlord has prevailed.
Second chance principle
The law is based on a second-chance principle that is already the basis of reforms in Pennsylvania’s criminal record-keeping rules, allowing more than 1 million Pennsylvanians a fresh start and access to family-sustaining jobs. The same can happen with eviction records.
This bill as an opportunity for Pennsylvania lawmakers to eliminate unfairness in the current eviction record system, provide housing security to struggling families, and reduce homelessness and hopelessness across the state, providing a second chance to people struggling to recover from a past setback.
Kyle Webster is general counsel for ACTION-Housing. John Katz is CEO of Brandywine Communities. House Bill 1769 was introduced by State Rep. Ismail Smith-Wade-El (D., Lancaster) and Senate minority leader Jay Costa, (D., Allegheny County).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.