I have long thought that the late historian Barbara Tuchman had dibs on the greatest book title ever: “The March of Folly.” The theme of the book is just as good: The ironic tendency of governments to choose courses contrary to their own interests.

But it’s more than governments. This is something men in power do quite often: They choose paths and policies contrary to their own interests, to say nothing of their avowed ideals.

Then — and this is the long march — they stick to the mistake, stubbornly, not only to their own detriment but sometimes to the point of their own undoing.

Men in power

This was Lyndon Johnson in Vietnam. And George W. Bush in Afghanistan and Iraq. This is what the men in power in Israel are doing now. What they are doing is disproportionate and, in some instances, war crime. But, also, they hurt the cause of Israel.

Advertise with us

Why do men in power act in this way so often? Is it really the march of pride? The triumph of emotion over reason? The victory of delusion and magical thinking over evidence-based thinking and the willingness to change one’s mind? All of the above.

Of course this curious bent toward self-sabotage, and even self-destruction, is not limited to politics and power. It is at work in all of us, daily. Calling Dr. Freud and St. Augustine.

Why is folly in politics so hard to rein in? This is my question after the Iowa caucuses.

The Republican Party marches on toward folly, though most of its leaders know the result will be disaster. They know that Donald Trump’s legal troubles will not go away. They know his demons will not abate. They know a second Trump presidency will be terrible for the country and, in the long run, for their party.

Yet onward toward folly they march. Much of the Trump base is rage embodied — people who are mad as hell. And all they want to know or feel is anger. They do not know much about the Constitution or the institutions or norms of our system.

Advertise with us

And no one has taught or challenged them. No one has said: Think of the country. And stop whining like 1960s baby radicals. Most of your lives are pretty good.

Republican elites

And that brings us to Republican elites — the “leaders.” They don’t teach or challenge because they are cowards. Once again, they are failing to block Mr. Trump from nomination. Once again, they are hapless and lame beyond lame. They are the same people who cannot pass a budget, mold legislation, or do oversight.

The GOP mass, base, and elites are all different and differently deluded, but the leaders are the worst, because they are so visionless and such gutless wonders. They cannot stand up to a mob, or Mr. Trump.

American populism need not be fascistic. And Mr. Trump did not start out a fascist. Both evolved toward darkness because they were allowed to do so.

Iowa is not the nation. And yet the nomination process is essentially over before it has begun, and most of the Republican candidates, from Mike Pence, to Chris Christie, to Tim Scott, are dead before the first primary. Lame beyond lame.

Advertise with us

Democrats’ folly

So what now? Will the courts defeat Trump? I have bad news for the left: Not in time.

Will Joe Biden, at 81? With Kamala Harris at his side? Not according to the polls, or the evidence of one’s own eyes.

The Democrats, too, are marching toward folly. Their party retains some of its Rooseveltian ideal of fair play and the efficacy of government. But if the Republicans grovel, the Democrats fear the people in a different way: They fear to engage them, for what they might find. What if most Americans are “deplorables”?

Since Truman, Democrats have had trouble connecting. When they listen (Bill Clinton; Barack Obama), they win. But, often, they cover their ears and chant, “We know best; we know best; we know best.”

Democratic dialectic

Look, Joe Biden is the finest Democratic president since Truman, but pretending his age does not matter, that the country hasn’t noticed, or that it has confidence in Ms. Harris is folly — a corner the Democrats put themselves in. It reminds me of the party in 1968: The country didn’t want more of the same. LBJ, Mayor Daley and the party apparat said: You get it anyway.

Advertise with us

Edmund Burke is often credited with the notion that the statesman stands for what he knows is right, not what the people want. Actually, democratic representation is a dialectic — both teaching and listening. Never to lead is an abdication, a republican sin. Never to hear or adapt is political suicide.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “The virtue that makes Pittsburgh a 'most livable' city.”