As I look at the reaction to Nippon Steel Corporation’s purchase of U.S. Steel, I cannot help but wonder if the right questions are being asked. While I can understand there is some initial hesitation when a U.S. industrial brand is bought by a foreign company, some of the reactions have been surprising.

The contours of the deal between U.S. Steel and Nippon Steel seem quite good for Pennsylvania. U.S. Steel keeps its brand and Pittsburgh headquarters intact. That means plenty of good jobs are staying in and around Pittsburgh that would have left in a different scenario.

Taking a broader view

The reaction to the sale from Pennsylvania politicians was swift and hostile.

Advertise with us
  • Senator John Fetterman: “Steel is always about security — both our national security and the economic security of our steel communities. I am committed to doing anything I can do, using my platform and my position, to block this foreign sale.”
  • U.S. Sen. Bob Casey: “This deal appears to be a bad deal for Pennsylvania and for Pennsylvania workers.”
  • U.S. Rep. Chris Deluzio: “This deal sounds an awful lot like a betrayal: of my community, of Steelworker jobs, and of American industrial leadership.”

It’s certainly understandable that these representatives would be shocked and dismayed, given their emphasis on preserving manufacturing in the U.S., and especially in western Pennsylvania. But what they need to consider is whether the Nippon deal might actually strengthen our industrial base — and whether the main alternative on the table was any better.

That alternative was a merger with Cleveland-Cliffs, proposed earlier this year. But Cleveland is only 135 miles from Pittsburgh. Two headquarters that close together would make no sense, so the deal would likely have sucked thousands more workers out of Pittsburgh’s already struggling central business district. Further, that deal would likely have come with mass layoffs due to eliminating “redundancies” and finding “efficiencies.”

And while shareholder value shouldn’t be the most important public consideration, it’s a fact that the offer from Nippon Steel was nearly double the previous offer, so the board was obligated to take it given its benefit to shareholders. More importantly, though, the high price demonstrates the financial stability of the buyer, a great signal for Pennsylvania workers that are currently employed there and will be in the future.

Real security

I agree with Mr. Fetterman that steel is about security, which why I am surprised to see so many voices opposing a deal with a company from one of our closest allies — and most important partners in containing a rising, aggressive China that is a threat both to American and Japanese national security and interests. As for steel communities, then workers and their families should take heart that Nippon Steel is honoring the current United Steelworkers (USW) contract, and has pledged to invest in employees.

Advertise with us

The president of a union local in Clairton shares my optimism, telling the Wall Street Journal that he is hopeful the new owners will add jobs to the Mon Valley Works.

Meanwhile, Japanese companies are well versed in labor relations. Strikes in Japan are rare in part because most labor negotiations are conducted amicably. In fact, Nippon’s existing American operations are unionized. Its Wheeling-Nisshin steel plant in Follansbee, W.Va., has been a union shop since 1989 — with USW. Its plant in Burnham, Pa., has been unionized since 2002, and when Nippon purchased Standard Steel in 2011, it continued to be a union shop.

Enhancing American manufacturing

This deal comes at a time when increasing steel production has become a major focus for the Biden administration and Congress with the passage of the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, which is expected to boost U.S. steel demand through investment in bridges, railways and other projects due to "Buy American" provisions in the legislation.

An enhanced, competitive steel industry with American workers is critical for implementation of IIJA and an investment like this from one of our strongest global allies will help achieve these goals.

Advertise with us

Instinctively objecting to this transaction ignores the intent of IIJA’s ambitious attempt to rebuild U.S. infrastructure with American-sourced workers. The workers will still be in Pittsburgh, and the financial stability of the industry will be reinforced.

Jobs are staying in Pennsylvania instead of leaving. The iconic U.S. Steel brand will continue instead of fading away. The United Steelworkers will continue to represent the hardworking men and women in a combined U.S. Steel – Nippon Steel. Our allied supply chain will be strengthened and Chinese grip on the international steel market will be weakened.

What’s not to like? Pennsylvania politicians should get off their soapboxes and roll up their sleeves to make sure the deal reaches its full potential for Pittsburgh, and for America.

Ryan Costello represented Pennsylvania’s 6th congressional district as a Republican from 2015 to 2019.