Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro invoked William Penn’s name this past weekend in protest against the rise of antisemitism around the world, including in Pennsylvania. The governor thundered at a jam-packed rally at Rodeph Shalom Synagogue in Philadelphia: “Hate in whatever form — whether antisemitism, Islamophobia, racism, homophobia — has no place here in Pennsylvania, in a place founded on the promise of William Penn.”
Earlier last week Mr. Shapiro had denounced the president of the University of Pennsylvania’s failure in her testimony to Congress to acknowledge that it is never acceptable for anyone on Penn’s campus to call for the eradication of Israel. “Frankly,” the governor said, “I thought her comments were absolutely shameful. It should not be hard to condemn genocide.” Liz Magill resigned on Saturday (she remains a tenured professor at the university’s law school).
Pennsylvania’s commitment
The governor is correct. Lost in all the legalisms about freedom of speech at the University of Pennsylvania is the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania’s historic commitment to freedom of religion — the commitment that Mr. Shapiro invoked. Of the five British American colonies planted for religious reasons — Massachusetts, Maryland, Connecticut, Rhode Island, and Pennsylvania — Pennsylvania’s dedication to religious tolerance was the strongest, thanks to William Penn.
William Penn (1644–1718), the Quaker founder and proprietor of Pennsylvania, endeavored to conduct a “holy experiment” in Pennsylvania. He wished to establish a society that was godly and virtuous, and an example for all humanity. While he was particularly concerned about creating a haven for the much-persecuted Quakers, he also was committed to religious tolerance in general.
Penn’s commitment to religious tolerance in Pennsylvania was a product of his personal experience with religious intolerance in his native land. He was imprisoned in Ireland and England on at least four occasions for his religious activities during his initial years as a Quaker. The Quaker desire for religious tolerance and an end to persecution rested upon the belief that the seat of religion was the conscience, and the religious leaders of England’s established church felt that idea of religion to be seditious.
Read More
As one historian aptly noted, “imprisonment made the costs of religious dissent painfully clear ... [and it] also allowed [Penn] to begin working out the ideas that he would later attempt to put into practice, both in England and in Pennsylvania.” Penn’s writings about religious freedom predated, and were more inclusive than, the English philosopher John Locke’s celebrated “Letter Concerning Toleration,” published in 1689.
Penn helped draft or approved six different constitutions for Pennsylvania during his lifetime, and all except two memorialized a staunch commitment to religious freedom. The two that did not echoed that commitment in a statute that came to be known as the “Great Law” that was declared “fundamental.”
Pennsylvania's animating principle
Scores of statutes — ranging from those relieving Quakers of the obligation to swear oaths to those approving lotteries so that the members of non-Quaker denominations could raise funds to construct and repair their own church buildings — were likewise ratified to effectuate Pennsylvania’s animating principle.
Despite Penn’s personal misgivings about what he regarded as the corruption of Catholicism, he nevertheless refused to punish Catholics by law. He trumpeted in a 1678 speech to England’s Parliament that “we must give the liberty we ask, and cannot be false to our principles ... for we ... would have none suffer for a truly sober and conscientious dissent on any hand.”
When Penn died in 1718 the proprietorship of Pennsylvania and Delaware — Pennsylvania’s “lower counties” at the time — passed to his three sons. They remained dedicated to their father’s vision of religious liberty, including through law.
Significantly, the Delaware Constitution of 1776, mirroring the Pennsylvania constitution of that same year — in 1776 Delaware declared independence from both Great Britain and Pennsylvania — continued to constitutionalize the animating principle of religious tolerance. Article 2 of the Delaware Declaration of Rights borrowed directly from the Pennsylvania Constitution of 1776 in proclaiming “That all men have a natural and unalienable right to worship Almighty God according to the dictates of their own consciences and understandings.”
The great man Penn
“Great man” theories of history are unfashionable on America’s college and university campuses at the moment, especially if the great man was a white male. But there can be no credible doubt that the commitment to religious tolerance that characterized colonial Pennsylvania traces directly to William Penn’s vision, example and determination.
Indeed, Thomas Jefferson — the author of one of the most celebrated religious liberty laws in American history, the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom of 1786 — described Penn as “the greatest lawgiver the world has produced, the first in either ancient or modern times who has laid the foundation of govmt in the pure and unadulterated principles of peace of reason and right.”
The leaders of America’s colleges and universities, including but not limited to the new leaders of the University of Pennsylvania, would be wise to remember William Penn’s timeless teachings.
Scott Douglas Gerber is the author of “Law and Religion in Colonial America: The Dissenting Colonies.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.