When school budgets tighten, music is often the first subject cut from the curriculum. Many school administrators, policy makers and even parents think music is a frill, and certainly not as important as “academic” subjects such as math, science, English, and social studies.
What does music instruction do? It can improve the mental processes involved with verbal memory, spatial relationships, geometric skills, reading fluency, learning a second language, motor-sequence skills, and auditory skills.
Musical rewards
Music does all that simultaneously. No other subject or learning activity can make that claim.
Several important studies connect music participation with improved learning capabilities. One, by Michael Posner of the University of Oregon, found that sustained motivation while practicing music strengthens the brain’s attention networks and improves ability to concentrate.
In three different studies by Elizabeth Spelke of Harvard University, elementary, middle, and high school students participating in music outscored non-music participants in mathematical and geometric tasks. Her results were not caused by differences in IQ, academic achievement, or socioeconomic level. Those factors were controlled for in her studies.
Using new brain imaging technology, Brian Wendell of Stanford University pinpointed areas of the brain involved in reading. He found that simultaneously reading rhythms and pitches on a music staff contributes to reading fluency.
Gottfried Schlaug and Ellen Winner, both of Harvard, compared children ages five to seven who were starting violin and piano lessons with children of the same age who were not learning an instrument. Almost immediately, the beginning musicians outperformed the non-musicians on motor-sequencing tasks and rhythmic and melodic discrimination.
They noted a relationship between these abilities and structural changes in the parts of the brain responsible for motor and auditory skills. They also found improvement in the attention networks of the brain, which corroborated Posner’s findings.
Why cut music?
When reading music, instrumentalists must respond kinesthetically by using correct fingering and adjusting their embouchure. Pianists must read in two clefs. Singers modify vowel shapes and pronounce foreign languages.
Research tests by the University of Toronto’s Kevin Dunbar showed that music students learn a second language faster and more proficiently than non-musicians. Learning a second language is beneficial because it develops attention networks: the brain must concentrate on one language while blocking out the other language.
Considering all this evidence demonstrating the many benefits of music study, why have so many schools across the country either entirely eliminated or cut back their music programs? I believe there are two reasons.
The first is lack of money. At the Basic Education Funding Commission hearing in September, Matthew G. Kelly, who teaches in Penn State’s education department, testified that 86% of Pennsylvania public school students are underfunded by more than $6.2 billion annually. It is easy to understand why public schools would cut what they unfortunately consider a non-essential program.
The second reason is that today’s society prioritizes obtaining a higher paying job as the primary purpose of public schools, rather than receiving a well-rounded education. It is easy to understand why public schools would cut music when they don’t realize the extent to which music contributes to a well-rounded education and that its benefits can ultimately translate into graduates getting higher paid jobs.
Achieving the mission through music
Our local schools, both public and private, have mission statements that include phrases such as “achieve academic excellence” and “maximize student potential.” However, the evidence clearly indicates that the only way school systems can do that is by offering a comprehensive music program — not just a choir and a band — taught by a qualified music educator.
John Weiss, a retired choral director and professor of voice at Mississippi Valley State University, was a Metropolitan Opera Regional Finalist and has performed with several regional opera companies around the country. He resides in Ross Township.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.