“Can we talk?” the great comedic monologist Joan Rivers used to ask. This was her invitation to engage in what Hannah Arendt called “thought exercises.” The animating idea for both women was to step back and look at things afresh — “without banisters” or illusion.
We have now held minor elections and are headed for a big election. Our choices were again less than optimal; our mood is surly and reactive.
Creating public spaces
And I am wondering: Can we talk? Can we begin to unravel questions that are highly complex? Can we create public spaces in which we let down our defenses, bridge the gaps between the tribes of certitude, and perhaps even laugh at ourselves?
For Arendt, the space was the classroom. For Rivers, the preferred agora was the nightclub.
Might we create “safe,” but also robust spaces, both in real time and place and online? Spaces in which a person can speak his mind, take a risk, and not be defamed or destroyed?
Read More
Imagine a place where Dave Chappelle’s critics go to read him. The head of Chick-fil-A defends himself. A trangender kid can ask us to listen without feeling this must be done anonymously. And the opponents of Lia Thomas swimming on a women’s team can make their case without being called homophobic.
All on the same platform.
Imagine.
Speaking about Israel
Right now, American Jews fear to speak out against the Israeli government. And members of the Israeli peace movement, not to mention the Palestinian peace movement, fear for their lives.
And yet, is it not obvious, is it not simply true, that what Hamas did does not justify Israeli armed forces killing civilian Palestinians? And that to say this is not pro-Hamas, but honest? Bernie Sanders can say it. But almost no other American politician can or will.
This is not the worst time to say we need a two-state solution, but the best. And when American politicians say they favor a two-state solution but give Israel “unconditional” support in this war, they negate their own position. Sen. Sanders says conditions are precisely what we need.
Honesty and bravery
We also need honesty and bravery if we are to progress — on race, poverty, inequality. Name your conundrum.
And for that we need public spaces in which free speech and free thought are the preeminent values. And the thinking person – like Joan, like Hannah – can roam.
We cannot begin to unravel complex issues without this free space and license. We cannot unravel complex matters if we insist on tribes and absolutes.
I know people who will bend over backward to justify Israeli military action. I know people who want to somehow justify Hamas — a very different thing from trying to understand the rise of Hamas.
They are in the grip of ideology or tribe. Often both. Ideology and tribe insist on a side, and a good guy.
Consider abortion
Consider abortion: We are stuck with “pro-choice” and “pro-life.” The woman’s absolute right to control her body trumps all or the fetus trumps all.
We know it’s more complicated than that.
The fetus is a life. And all human life has an inherent human right to exist. And we know that abortion will always exist, that it sometimes will be the lesser evil, and that culture wars and sending women back to alleys and coathangers, will not prevent abortions and will result only in more death.
How about a discussion of a feminist culture of life? How about a Catholic culture of help and prevention — one that embraces contraception? How about a guaranteed minimum income so poor women can support their children? We aren’t allowed to talk about such ideas, though we know, inherently, there is sense in them.
There are too many things we are not allowed to discuss — like supporting Mr. Netanyahu when what we actually want to do is stop the killing of all innocents, Israeli and Palestinian.
And there are too many people afraid to talk, because they will be called stupid, insensitive, or evil. We cannot converse in fear.
We need free speech. At the moment, free speech is not safe, even in the classroom or nightclub.
The open society
We have forgotten (temporarily I hope) the ideal of the open society, in which many flowers bloom — the city of Jane Jacobs, the music of Mozart and Coltrane, the bravery of Lenny Bruce.
We need open, public spaces. No absolutes. And no fear.
In “The Open Society and Its Enemies,” the philosopher Karl Popper writes: “The open society is one in which men have learned to be to some extent critical of taboos, and to base decisions on the authority of their own intelligence.”
And: “Reason, like science, grows by way of mutual criticism; the only possible way of planning its growth is to develop those institutions that safeguard the freedom of thought.”
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Mike Pence dropped out because no one can be Ronald Reagan anymore.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.