I interviewed Mike Pence once. It was during the 2016 presidential campaign. We met at Tony Packo’s, in Toledo, made famous by Jamie Farr (aka Klinger on “Mash”).
Mr. Pence grew up Catholic and became an Evangelical Christian, but he did not preach. He spoke quietly and thoughtfully. He struck me as an eminently decent man. (When I said this to a liberal friend, she literally covered her ears and ran from the room.)
The schedule must have been soft that day. Maybe few were interested. Trump-Pence was supposed to lose, after all.
A home visit
There was no urgency. No hovering aides. No cameras. Mr. Pence’s daughter was traveling with him and she alone sat drinking coffee with the two of us. It felt like a home visit in a race for state representative.
A little boy of perhaps 5, in shorts and no shirt, came tottering up to the table and asked Mr. Pence for an autograph. Mr. Pence obliged and was exceedingly gentle with the lad.
Read More
It seemed to me that Mr. Pence was on board with libertarian populism (abortion excepted) but less comfortable with Donald Trump. Mr. Pence wanted to talk about his hero, Ronald Reagan, and Indiana. “I love Indiana,” he said, and it sounded real.
I thought: I should take a road trip to Pence Land. Check it out.
Indiana is also Mitch Daniels Land. Mr. Daniels is a former governor, like Mr. Pence, and former president of Purdue, as well as former head of the federal budget office. He is brilliant, grounded and capable. But when Mr. Daniels considered a U.S. Senate race earlier this year, the right and far right chased him back into the realm of golf games and early bird specials.
Mr. Daniels is exactly the sort of person we need in the Senate. Just as Mr. Pence is exactly the sort of person who should be running for president as a Republican.
If you watched Mr. Pence’s Town Hall on CNN a few months back you saw what I saw the day I met him: Clear values (albeit right and somewhat rigid), but values, reason and balance.
Moreover, the man has been a congressman, a governor and a vice president. He’s qualified. And he has courage.
But Mike Pence never had a real shot at the 2024 Republican presidential nomination. For his party has literally lost its mind — its values and traditions. Its “leaders” fear its followers. And its thugs.
I doubt Mike Pence thinks too long about single moms trying to work their way out of poverty and what the Jesus ethic says about them. Or America’s addiction to imprisonment, especially of young Black men. Or how to stop industrial farming from permanently destroying Lake Erie.
But in normal times he would make a very respectable “Mr. Republican.”
Alienated from both parties
And, to be honest, I don’t think many Democratic leaders actually think much about those things, either.
Most Americans feel alienated from both parties.
Mike Pence is a man of limits and restraint. In a party still in touch with the temper of Dwight David Eisenhower, Mr. Pence would be the nominee, or at least a finalist. He may yet find a useful postlude, as Walter Mondale, who got his clock cleaned as a presidential candidate, did.
But the end of Mr. Pence’s presidential campaign is a last bit of evidence, if any is needed, that the Republican Party we once knew is gone. The culprit is not just Trumpism, but also Reaganism.
The core tenet of Reaganism is that government is the problem. Mr. Pence’s hero built this early public career on it and never abandoned the trope.
Taken to its logical extreme, this notion inevitably brings us to repeated attempts to cripple and dismantle the government. Hating government and sabotaging it eventually leads us to the present House Republican Caucus and zero capacity to do government. (And a Speaker who, in the days of Sam Rayburn, would be parking the car.)
Saying that government is always the problem is as mindless as saying it is always the solution. Of course, Reagan, in practice, was never a prisoner of his own rhetoric. He ran governor of California, and president of the United States, and did so as a pragmatist. And he knew how to be president of all the people.
Impossible Reaganism
But Reaganism has made another Reagan, even lite, impossible. Another Ike, or even Jerry Ford or Al Smith, is not possible either. At least not soon. Not until we get the posturing and rage and willful ignorance out of our system.
Contempt for government gave us Jim Jordan and eliminated Mike Pence.
“Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall.” You don’t get politicians who speak like that by demeaning and diminishing politics.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Where is the human race going?”.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.