It’s important to understand how our politicians talk to us to get us to support what they want to do. President Biden's Oval Office speech responding to Hamas's terrorist attacks against Israel and Russia's ongoing war against Ukraine fit into a genre of presidential speech-making called “presidential international crisis rhetoric.”

This kind of talk does three things, according to communication scholar Ted Windt: It tells the people that a dangerous new situation exists that requires that the president act decisively; that this new situation is only one more in an ongoing battle between incompatible ideologies; and that the public must realize that the enactment of his policy and support for it are moral acts.

Convincing America

First, Biden depicted the international crisis as a critical historical juncture — “an inflection point in history — one of those moments where the decisions we make today are going to determine the future for decades to come." He argued that Hamas and other terrorist groups and nations like Iran that support them, along with Putin's Russia, represent threats to international freedom and democracy.

Advertise with us

These threats are not only foreign but domestic as well. Biden warned about the political discord and the "hate" that fuels “racism, a rise in antisemitism and [Islamophobia] right here in America." The threats require decisive action on his part. Thus his appeal for the package he sent to Congress asking for military aid to Israel and Ukraine and "humanitarian assistance" for Palestinian civilians in Gaza.

Second, Biden described America's support of Israel and Ukraine as part of a larger struggle against incompatible ideologies: the forces of democracy and freedom versus the forces of terrorism and tyranny. As he put it, "Hamas and Putin represent different threats, but they share this in common: They both want to completely annihilate a neighboring democracy — completely annihilate it."

Third, the president's speech made a moral appeal. He referred to "the idea of America," and said that, during his recent visits to Ukraine and Israel, he carried with him “the promise of America to the people who are today fighting for the same things we fought for 250 years ago: freedom, independence, self-determination."

By following these three lines of argument in his speech, Biden sought to convince Americans of the extreme gravity of the international situation as it relates to the democracy and freedom of America's allies; that the threats represent truly ideological differences between the Free World and the forces of terrorism and autocracy; and that decisive action to meet these threats is absolutely preferable to costly inaction or the continued political paralysis and disorder at home.

He also sought to distinguish the good actors (US, Israeli, and Ukrainian citizens, “innocent Palestinians,” America's Middle Eastern “partners”) from the bad actors (Hamas, Putin, Iran, North Korea, anti-Semites, and Islamophobes).

Advertise with us

Creating unity

Biden's rhetoric is reminiscent of former presidents George H.W. and George W. Bush, Bill Clinton, Ronald Reagan, and John F. Kennedy. In their international crisis speeches, they tried to unite Americans by constituting them as leaders of the Free World.

Biden also endeavored to create national unity given both the size of the threats and America's moral mission abroad. Despite political differences and conflicts, he said, “We are the United States of America — the United States of America. And there is nothing — nothing beyond our capacity if we do it together.”

According to Windt, presidential international crisis speeches, with their “Caesar”-like and “aristocratic” qualities, can “squelch or discredit dissent.” However, such discourse may also spark thoughtful reflection, not only concerning clear and present dangers facing a nation and its allies but also threats to domestic political order.

Biden's speech was designed to address both perils and evoke the serious political will necessary for facing them head-on. In this, his speech hinted at how America’s current political divisions undermine America’s democratic standing.

Advertise with us

American leadership

As Biden concluded: “American leadership is what holds the world together. ... American values are what make us a partner that other nations want to work with. To put all that at risk if we walk away from Ukraine, if we turn our backs on Israel, it’s just not worth it.”

Whether the president’s speech will succeed in bringing Americans closer together to confront the crises before them may reveal how strong America’s democratic international vision of itself remains or how far it has fallen.

Kenneth Zagacki is a profession of communication at North Carolina State University. Richard Cherwitz is an emeritus professor at the University of Texas at Austin.