A bipartisan effort is underway in Harrisburg to expand voting rights for 1.2 million Pennsylvanians. That’s 14% of the state’s 8.6 million registered voters.
Who are these 1.2 million? Politically independent Pennsylvanians, people not affiliated with a major party — who have no say in the primary elections that decide who’s on their November ballots.
Momentum is growing to open primary elections to Pennsylvania’s independents. State legislators may raise the issue in the coming days or weeks, but this measure is far from done.
Why change, why now?
“No party” affiliations continue to outpace Republican and Democrat affiliations. Half of Americans nationwide are now independent. As party moderates lose interest in party politics, party die-hards gain more sway over party primaries, and over November’s candidates.
We know how this movie ends. Extreme party voters are electing extreme party candidates. Legislatures are turning from houses of the people to no-holds-barred octagons. Moderates’ voices are excluded.
Read More
43 states allow independents to vote in every election, including primaries. Pennsylvania is one of seven that does not. The Pennsylvania Election Code of 1937 closes primaries to registered party members, so only legislators in Harrisburg can change the status quo.
A recent poll showed that 74 percent of Pennsylvanians, across party lines, were in favor of repealing closed primaries. Elected leaders are taking notice.
In late April, two Democrats and three Republicans introduced three bills in the Pennsylvania House and Senate to repeal closed primaries. On September 18, all living, former governors — three Republicans and two Democrats — penned an open letter urging the same.
Legislators have debated this before, though, and unsuccessfully. A Republican senator introduced the matter in 2018 and 2019. The bill never got a vote in 2018. Senators approved it 42 to 8 in 2019, but it never moved to the House. Of the 2023 bills, none has received a vote.
Who wins and who loses?
Beyond the oversimplified “democracy wins, party extremists lose” argument above, it’s worth weighing some other considerations behind open/closed primaries.
Independent voters pay taxes, and $50 million of those taxes fund Pennsylvania’s primaries. But independents cannot vote in them. Some might call that taxation without representation.
Hundreds of thousands of Pennsylvanian veterans stand to benefit from open primaries. Nearly half of veterans do not affiliate with a major party, meaning this apolitical demographic is disproportionately shut out of the primary election process.
And yes, politicians will need to cooperate with moderates and campaign — and govern — beyond their extreme bases. When elected officials are unafraid of being “primaried” by hardliners for collaboration and compromise, they can truly be leaders.
According to closed primary supporters, someone who wants to vote in primary elections should register with a party. The U.S. Constitution, however, does not require party membership for participation in democratic processes, nor does it mention political parties or primaries. Pennsylvania wrote its Election Code, and Pennsylvania can amend it.
Power to the people
Supporters of closed primaries also believe that open primaries violate their Constitutional right to associate. State court after state court, however, has dismissed each challenge on these merits.
Opening primaries, however, does not prevent Democrats or Republicans from assembling, building a platform, sharing information, fundraising, or doing anything else a party does.
The invention of party primaries — which only dates to the early 1900s — was an innovation that transferred power from smoke-filled rooms and corrupt party bosses back to the people. And while the balance has again shifted to parties, we need only another innovation to right the scale: opening primaries to independent voters — to all voters.
Dave Kelm, a Connellsville native and veteran of the U.S. military and the U.S. Department of State, is a Pennsylvania state leader for Veterans for Political Innovation.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.