A bi­par­ti­san ef­fort is un­der­way in Har­ris­burg to ex­pand vot­ing rights for 1.2 mil­lion Penn­syl­va­nians. That’s 14% of the state’s 8.6 mil­lion reg­is­tered vot­ers.

Who are these 1.2 mil­lion? Po­lit­i­cally in­de­pen­dent Penn­syl­va­nians, peo­ple not af­fil­i­ated with a ma­jor party — who have no say in the pri­mary elec­tions that de­cide who’s on their No­vem­ber bal­lots.

Momentum is growing to open primary elections to Pennsylvania’s independents. State legislators may raise the issue in the coming days or weeks, but this measure is far from done.

Why change, why now?

Advertise with us

“No party” af­fil­i­a­tions con­tinue to out­pace Re­pub­li­can and Dem­o­crat af­fil­i­a­tions. Half of Amer­i­cans na­tion­wide are now in­de­pen­dent. As party mod­er­ates lose in­ter­est in party pol­i­tics, party die-hards gain more sway over party pri­ma­ries, and over No­vem­ber’s can­di­dates.

We know how this movie ends. Ex­treme party vot­ers are elect­ing ex­treme party can­di­dates. Leg­is­la­tures are turn­ing from houses of the peo­ple to no-holds-barred oc­ta­gons. Mod­er­ates’ voices are ex­cluded.

43 states al­low in­de­pen­dents to vote in ev­ery elec­tion, in­clud­ing pri­ma­ries. Penn­syl­va­nia is one of seven that does not. The Penn­syl­va­nia Elec­tion Code of 1937 closes pri­ma­ries to reg­is­tered party mem­bers, so only leg­is­la­tors in Har­ris­burg can change the sta­tus quo.

A re­cent poll showed that 74 per­cent of Penn­syl­va­nians, across party lines, were in fa­vor of re­peal­ing closed pri­ma­ries. Elected lead­ers are tak­ing no­tice.

In late April, two Dem­o­crats and three Re­pub­li­cans in­tro­duced three bills in the Penn­syl­va­nia House and Senate to re­peal closed pri­ma­ries. On Sep­tem­ber 18, all liv­ing, for­mer gov­er­nors — three Re­pub­li­cans and two Dem­o­crats — penned an open let­ter urg­ing the same.

Advertise with us

Legislators have debated this before, though, and unsuccessfully. A Republican senator introduced the matter in 2018 and 2019. The bill never got a vote in 2018. Senators approved it 42 to 8 in 2019, but it never moved to the House. Of the 2023 bills, none has received a vote.

Who wins and who loses?

Beyond the over­sim­pli­fied “de­moc­racy wins, party ex­trem­ists lose” ar­gu­ment above, it’s worth weigh­ing some other con­sid­er­ations be­hind open/​closed pri­ma­ries.

Inde­pen­dent vot­ers pay taxes, and $50 mil­lion of those taxes fund Penn­syl­va­nia’s pri­ma­ries. But in­de­pen­dents can­not vote in them. Some might call that tax­a­tion with­out rep­re­sen­ta­tion.

Hun­dreds of thou­sands of Penn­syl­va­nian vet­er­ans stand to ben­e­fit from open pri­ma­ries. Nearly half of vet­er­ans do not af­fil­i­ate with a ma­jor party, mean­ing this apo­lit­i­cal de­mo­graphic is dis­pro­por­tion­ately shut out of the pri­mary elec­tion pro­cess.

Advertise with us

And yes, pol­i­ti­cians will need to co­op­er­ate with mod­er­ates and cam­paign — and gov­ern — be­yond their ex­treme bases. When elected of­fi­cials are un­afraid of be­ing “pri­ma­ried” by hard­liners for col­lab­o­ra­tion and com­pro­mise, they can truly be lead­ers.

Ac­cord­ing to closed pri­mary sup­port­ers, some­one who wants to vote in pri­mary elec­tions should reg­is­ter with a party. The U.S. Con­sti­tu­tion, how­ever, does not re­quire party mem­ber­ship for par­tic­i­pa­tion in demo­cratic pro­cesses, nor does it men­tion po­lit­i­cal par­ties or pri­ma­ries. Penn­syl­va­nia wrote its Elec­tion Code, and Penn­syl­va­nia can amend it.

Power to the peo­ple

Sup­port­ers of closed pri­ma­ries also be­lieve that open pri­ma­ries vi­o­late their Con­sti­tu­tional right to as­so­ci­ate. State court af­ter state court, how­ever, has dis­missed each chal­lenge on these mer­its.

Open­ing pri­ma­ries, how­ever, does not pre­vent Dem­o­crats or Re­pub­li­cans from as­sem­bling, build­ing a plat­form, shar­ing in­for­ma­tion, fund­rais­ing, or do­ing any­thing else a party does.

Advertise with us

The in­ven­tion of party pri­ma­ries — which only dates to the early 1900s — was an in­no­va­tion that trans­ferred power from smoke-filled rooms and cor­rupt party bosses back to the peo­ple. And while the bal­ance has again shifted to par­ties, we need only an­other in­no­va­tion to right the scale: open­ing pri­ma­ries to in­de­pen­dent vot­ers — to all vot­ers.

Dave Kelm, a Connellsville native and veteran of the U.S. military and the U.S. Department of State, is a Pennsylvania state leader for Veterans for Political Innovation.