When I read this week that the Carnegie Museum of Natural History had finally gone through with the removal of the 156-year-old diorama “Lion Attacking a Dromedary,” I felt like we, as a city, had lost something. The piece has captivated and intrigued visitors for nearly as long as the museum has stood, and just about anyone who’s grown up going to the Carnegie has something to say about it.
As a child, I always sought it out, and my mother still tells us each time we visit how it was her brother’s favorite piece. So naturally, I was shocked and saddened to learn that it would not be displayed again in its complete form.
How could the museum take it upon themselves to destroy this piece of great art? It may have its issues, but it still has a unique history of its own. Removing it just seemed like being woke for the sake of woke.
Historically inaccurate
But then I decided to set my emotions aside, and try to understand the museum’s point of view. In all the years that I revered the diorama, I was unaware that one of its sculptors, Jules Verreaux, was a known grave robber, notable for having dug up the remains of a Tswana warrior whose burial he had witnessed and then shipping the remains to Paris for display. The warrior’s body went on to become “El Bosquimano de Banyoles,” which has a long and complex history as well.
Although many may argue “it was a different time,” I find it difficult to admire any piece of art whose creator committed such an abhorrent act. Knowing that, “Lion Attacking a Dromedary” started to lose its luster.
But beside the human skull used for the human figure, which has been removed, what’s wrong with the rest of the piece? Why not just replace the head with a fake one and keep it as is?
I won’t speak on whether or not the lions are “a symbol of imperial power” as the museum says. But the facts remain that the depiction is a historically inaccurate amalgamation of different North African cultures, and therefore doesn’t really have a place in a natural history museum, especially without context. It’s an example of orientalism, depicting the Middle East, northern Africa and parts of Asia through stereotypes that express a colonialist point of view.
Whenever we think about changing the way we view history, be it in the form of removing statues, censoring outdated media or just adding long-buried details of a bygone era to give a more complete story, we should ask what can be learned from it all. Some may say that removing this art piece is erasing history, and others may say that there’s no history to be learned because it’s so wrong. I think that “Lion Attacking a Dromedary” is a fascinating piece and so is the conversation surrounding it.
It’s no easy task to convince people who grew up loving the diorama that its problems are significant, but I believe that it is a perfect piece to learn from because we all feel so strongly about it. This morbid hunk of orientalism is a part of Pittsburgh history, and I think it would be the wrong move to never show it again.
Instead, maybe it’s exactly what we need to convince those who stand by it that orientalism is still alive and well, and it’s long-outdated pieces like this one, that, 156 years later, still contribute to dehumanizing attitudes towards “other” cultures.
Teaching history
I do not know what the museum plans to do with the piece. I know there are many who will mourn the loss of it, and their feelings are completely valid. But I challenge them to learn a little more and see if they feel any differently afterwards.
“Lion Attacking a Dromedary” is undoubtedly a powerful piece, and therefore I believe it is the perfect tool to help destroy the very thing it represents. Museums exist to teach history, and the way we change is perhaps the most important part of that.
Sara Schmitt, a lifelong Pittsburgher, works in the local film industry.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.