Recently, a young entrepreneur from Guatemala came to see me. He wanted to turn a shuttered Pittsburgh bank into a supermarket, but he was struggling to secure a loan.

Although he already owned two businesses as a contractor and a property manager, he’d opened both with savings. This is a fairly typical entrepreneurial approach outside the United States, but here, the bank simply wouldn’t see past my client’s lack of credit.

Immigrant problem

Many would-be entrepreneurs have trouble securing a small business loan, but the problem is especially prevalent among immigrants who aren’t well-versed in American debt culture, have language barriers or face stigmas about their legal status.

Advertise with us

As a bilingual small business consultant with a majority immigrant client base, I see these challenges firsthand. But I also see solutions — practical steps our city and financial services sector can take to help motivated entrepreneurs of all backgrounds realize their dreams.

The tremendous risks required to pick up and move to a new country aren’t unlike the risks of entrepreneurship. I suspect it’s why immigrants are 80 percent more likely to start a business than native-born Americans. Today, 3.2 million immigrants in the United States run their own businesses, and 62,000 of them live in Pennsylvania.

Business barriers

But many face barriers. Most immigrants can’t transfer credit scores from their home countries to America.

Organizations like the Community Development Financial Institutions Fund cater to hard-to-lend clients, but more options by traditional banks would be beneficial.Instead of a credit score, for example, an individual’s prior business success, cash purchases, and civic ties could be used to bolster their reliability.

Advertise with us

Microlenders and alternative lenders have shown this to be effective. They often use unique models that consider community engagement like church membership and nonprofit work, or allow community members to contribute to the loan.

Some entrepreneurs damage their credit simply because they didn’t know that they needed to pay the minimum every month, they opened and closed too many credit cards, or exceeded their credit limit. A few credit cards offer deposit-based cards to build credit, but the options are limited.

I see some entrepreneurs damage their credit simply because they didn’t know that they needed to pay the minimum every month, they opened and closed too many credit cards, or exceeded their credit limit. A few credit cards offer deposit-based cards to build credit, but the options are limited.

Undocumented entrepreneurs

Many credit cards require a social security number, which undocumented entrepreneurs don’t have — even though there is absolutely no restriction against them starting a business. More than 820,000 undocumented business owners make approximately $15 billion in business income, but many banks don’t work with them.

Advertise with us

The alternative is high-interest, private sector loans that deplete the entrepreneur’s savings. Banks and permitting offices need more experimental programs and to think outside of the box in order to assist them.

More education and training about what these folks can legally do could be a good step. I’ve seen cleaning, construction, daycare and translation businesses be denied loans because the entrepreneur was undocumented, despite the fact that these businesses would require the same permitting and pay the same taxes as any other company.

Lastly, most legal documents, permits and government paperwork are in English. Offering translations to Pittsburgh’s large Hispanic, Arab and Asian communities, for instance, is the first step to expanding commercial outreach. The other strategy is to hire multilingual workers at financial institutions who can interact and explain the options offered by the bank.

Successful support

Over my 27 years assisting foreign-born business owners, I’ve seen how far a little early support can go. These clients have made important economic and cultural contributions to our city. They’ve launched software companies, including one acquired by IBM, and numerous food trucks and restaurants, including the Venezuelan Cilantro and Ajo in the South Side neighborhood.

Advertise with us

I appreciate the struggle that goes into this success. When I first came here from Peru in 1988, I had a degree in agriculture engineering. But with my limited English, I could only find work cleaning warehouse floors. A friend encouraged me to think bigger. But even as I applied for a data entry job at the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, I worried I wouldn’t make the cut.

To my surprise, I was hired. I stayed with the state for five years before returning to school to study a graduate degree in international affairs and public administration.

Immigrant entrepreneurs often experience similar doubts about their goals, but with the right guidance and encouragement, they thrive. They are optimists and not easily deterred. It doesn't matter if interest rates or inflation are high — they move forward.

This is exactly what happened with my Guatemalan client. When the bank turned him away, he embarked on a lengthy, stressful process to come up with the money himself. Then, on August 18, 2023, he opened a beautiful supermarket.

Brent G. Rondon is the senior management consultant for the Institute for Entrepreneurial Excellence’s Small Business Development Center at the University of Pittsburgh.