Re­pub­li­cans have long iden­ti­fied them­selves as the party of law and or­der, at least since the 1960s, con­trast­ing their party with the per­mis­sive “soft on crime” Dem­o­crats. Yet now we see the Re­pub­li­can party lead­er­ship and a ma­jor­ity of rank-and-file mem­bers sup­port­ing Don­ald Trump even though he’s plau­si­bly ac­cused of break­ing the law, with 91 fel­ony counts from four dif­fer­ent ju­ris­dic­tions.

How on earth did we get here? A pow­er­ful ce­leb­rity-driven per­son­al­ity cult is ob­vi­ously one rea­son, but a sur­vey of the na­tion’s his­tory sug­gests Amer­i­cans’ com­mit­ment to law and or­der has never been ab­so­lute.

Since at least the days of the Amer­i­can Revo­lu­tion, what we now call “lib­er­tar­i­an­ism” has played a cen­tral role in Amer­i­can life. The “Don’t Tread on Me” flag so pop­u­lar among the Jan­u­ary 6 in­sur­rec­tion­ists was first used by pa­tri­ots dur­ing the Revo­lu­tion to tar­get the Brit­ish gov­ern­ment.

Lib­er­tar­i­an­ism rises

Advertise with us

Since the late nine­teenth-cen­tury, Amer­i­can con­ser­va­tives have in­creas­ingly em­braced an in­di­vid­u­al­is­tic and anti-stat­ist phi­los­o­phy, which dif­fers from tra­di­tional con­ser­va­tism, which val­ued ex­ist­ing in­sti­tu­tions, in­clud­ing gov­ern­ment. The mod­ern con­ser­va­tive move­ment that emerged af­ter World War Two was an un­sta­ble al­li­ance of anti-com­mu­nists, so­cial con­ser­va­tives, and lib­er­tar­i­ans.

Though Barry Gold­wa­ter’s pres­i­den­tial hopes were bur­ied in the LBJ land­slide in 1964, his lib­er­tar­ian views grad­u­ally gained ac­cep­tance within the party. They were rat­i­fied with the elec­tion of Ron­ald Rea­gan in 1980. As Rea­gan fa­mously con­cluded in his first in­au­gu­ral ad­dress, “Govern­ment is not the solu­tion to our prob­lem. Govern­ment is the prob­lem.”

Indeed, some White House staff in his ad­min­is­tra­tion may have in­tro­duced the dis­turb­ing phrase “starve the beast.” This re­ferred to the strat­egy of sharply cut­ting taxes to re­duce the size of gov­ern­ment. Pre­dict­ably, the ap­proach didn’t work, be­cause even Re­pub­li­can pol­i­ti­cians wouldn’t sharply re­duce spend­ing. It in­stead in­creased def­i­cits.

Such lan­guage re­flected a view of gov­ern­ment as the en­emy, a per­spec­tive that had once been on the fringes of the Re­pub­li­can party and of­ten iden­ti­fied with ex­trem­ists. Re­pub­li­can pres­i­dent Teddy Roosevelt gov­erned as a “pro­gres­sive.” Pres­i­dents Her­bert Hoover at the end of the 20s and Dwight D. Ei­sen­hower in the 50s didn’t treat gov­ern­ment as a prob­lem.

But a co-founder of the now in­flu­en­tial lib­er­tar­ian Cato In­sti­tute did. Mur­ray Roth­bard quipped that “just as no one is mor­ally re­quired to an­swer a rob­ber truth­fully when he asks if there are any valu­ables in one’s house, so no one can be mor­ally re­quired to an­swer truth­fully sim­i­lar ques­tions asked by the state, e.g., when fill­ing out in­come tax re­turns.”

Advertise with us

One in­flu­en­tial Re­pub­li­can critic of gov­ern­ment spend­ing, Grover Norquist, de­clared: “I don’t want to abol­ish gov­ern­ment. I sim­ply want to re­duce it to the size where I can drag it into the bath­room and drown it in the bath­tub.”

The evil state

As the lib­er­tar­ian at­ti­tude to gov­ern­ment in­creas­ingly came to dom­i­nate the Re­pub­li­can party af­ter Rea­gan, Re­pub­li­cans be­gan to see the state as not just big and in­tru­sive but evil and il­le­git­i­mate.

Such be­liefs were ce­mented within the Re­pub­li­can party with the com­ing of the Tea Party move­ment, in the wake of the elec­tion of Barack Obama. Obama was de­nounced as a “so­cial­ist” for sup­port­ing uses of gov­ern­ment Teddy Roosevelt and even George W. Bush would have ap­proved.

Of course, many Amer­i­cans have long cel­e­brated in­di­vid­u­al­ism and long chal­lenged big, ac­tiv­ist gov­ern­ment — that’s a rea­son­able con­ser­va­tive po­si­tion. But to­day’s hy­per-in­di­vid­u­al­ism that views gov­ern­ment as an il­licit pa­riah eats away at eth­i­cal and le­gal norms. Many Re­pub­li­cans now seem to view our dem­o­crat­i­cally elected, con­sti­tu­tional sys­tem as though it were the re­gime of France’s Louis XIV.

Advertise with us

Treat­ing gov­ern­ment as, at best, a nec­es­sary evil un­der­mines pop­u­lar re­spect for in­sti­tu­tions like courts or the Depart­ment of Justice. When peo­ple be­lieve that the in­di­vid­ual’s un­re­stricted free­dom over­rides con­sid­er­ations of the com­mon good, they’re not go­ing to re­spect le­gal stan­dards or trust le­gal in­sti­tu­tions. We shouldn’t be sur­prised when they start to call for de­fund­ing the FBI.

Nor has the ide­o­log­i­cal Right alone cor­nered the mar­ket on this sort of caus­tic in­di­vid­u­al­ism. The coun­ter­cul­ture of the late six­ties cel­e­brated in­di­vid­ual self-in­dul­gence against tra­di­tional in­sti­tu­tions and le­gal guard­rails. Many rid­i­culed mar­riage and the fam­ily as sti­fling in­di­vid­ual growth.

Ad­vo­cates of lib­er­al­ized abor­tion laws chanted “My body, my choice!” as if the broader com­mu­nity should have no say in the mat­ter. Many con­ser­va­tive op­po­nents of vac­ci­na­tion and mask man­dates dur­ing the re­cent pan­demic adopted the same line. The lib­er­tar­ian im­pulse is clearly deeply in­grained on both sides of the aisle.

Re­pub­li­can cor­rup­tion

Don­ald Trump — while cer­tainly not a con­sis­tent lib­er­tar­ian — per­son­i­fies the self-ab­sorbed amoral prag­ma­tism that char­ac­ter­izes the now dom­i­nant va­ri­ety of lib­er­tar­i­an­ism. When he be­came the nom­i­nee in 2016, lead­ing Re­pub­li­cans thought they could make good use of him — and his large num­ber of en­er­gized fol­low­ers — to achieve their pol­icy goals.

Advertise with us

They convinced them­selves that strik­ing a deal with such a deeply flawed per­son wouldn’t cor­rupt them. Their neg­a­tive view of gov­ern­ment and their amoral trans­ac­tional ap­proach to pol­i­tics — in short, their lib­er­tar­i­an­ism — clouded their vi­sion and made them more sus­cep­ti­ble to Trump’s ap­peal.

Gillis Harp is pro­fes­sor of his­tory at Grove City Col­lege.