Republicans have long identified themselves as the party of law and order, at least since the 1960s, contrasting their party with the permissive “soft on crime” Democrats. Yet now we see the Republican party leadership and a majority of rank-and-file members supporting Donald Trump even though he’s plausibly accused of breaking the law, with 91 felony counts from four different jurisdictions.
How on earth did we get here? A powerful celebrity-driven personality cult is obviously one reason, but a survey of the nation’s history suggests Americans’ commitment to law and order has never been absolute.
Since at least the days of the American Revolution, what we now call “libertarianism” has played a central role in American life. The “Don’t Tread on Me” flag so popular among the January 6 insurrectionists was first used by patriots during the Revolution to target the British government.
Libertarianism rises
Since the late nineteenth-century, American conservatives have increasingly embraced an individualistic and anti-statist philosophy, which differs from traditional conservatism, which valued existing institutions, including government. The modern conservative movement that emerged after World War Two was an unstable alliance of anti-communists, social conservatives, and libertarians.
Though Barry Goldwater’s presidential hopes were buried in the LBJ landslide in 1964, his libertarian views gradually gained acceptance within the party. They were ratified with the election of Ronald Reagan in 1980. As Reagan famously concluded in his first inaugural address, “Government is not the solution to our problem. Government is the problem.”
Read More
Indeed, some White House staff in his administration may have introduced the disturbing phrase “starve the beast.” This referred to the strategy of sharply cutting taxes to reduce the size of government. Predictably, the approach didn’t work, because even Republican politicians wouldn’t sharply reduce spending. It instead increased deficits.
Such language reflected a view of government as the enemy, a perspective that had once been on the fringes of the Republican party and often identified with extremists. Republican president Teddy Roosevelt governed as a “progressive.” Presidents Herbert Hoover at the end of the 20s and Dwight D. Eisenhower in the 50s didn’t treat government as a problem.
But a co-founder of the now influential libertarian Cato Institute did. Murray Rothbard quipped that “just as no one is morally required to answer a robber truthfully when he asks if there are any valuables in one’s house, so no one can be morally required to answer truthfully similar questions asked by the state, e.g., when filling out income tax returns.”
One influential Republican critic of government spending, Grover Norquist, declared: “I don’t want to abolish government. I simply want to reduce it to the size where I can drag it into the bathroom and drown it in the bathtub.”
The evil state
As the libertarian attitude to government increasingly came to dominate the Republican party after Reagan, Republicans began to see the state as not just big and intrusive but evil and illegitimate.
Such beliefs were cemented within the Republican party with the coming of the Tea Party movement, in the wake of the election of Barack Obama. Obama was denounced as a “socialist” for supporting uses of government Teddy Roosevelt and even George W. Bush would have approved.
Of course, many Americans have long celebrated individualism and long challenged big, activist government — that’s a reasonable conservative position. But today’s hyper-individualism that views government as an illicit pariah eats away at ethical and legal norms. Many Republicans now seem to view our democratically elected, constitutional system as though it were the regime of France’s Louis XIV.
Treating government as, at best, a necessary evil undermines popular respect for institutions like courts or the Department of Justice. When people believe that the individual’s unrestricted freedom overrides considerations of the common good, they’re not going to respect legal standards or trust legal institutions. We shouldn’t be surprised when they start to call for defunding the FBI.
Nor has the ideological Right alone cornered the market on this sort of caustic individualism. The counterculture of the late sixties celebrated individual self-indulgence against traditional institutions and legal guardrails. Many ridiculed marriage and the family as stifling individual growth.
Advocates of liberalized abortion laws chanted “My body, my choice!” as if the broader community should have no say in the matter. Many conservative opponents of vaccination and mask mandates during the recent pandemic adopted the same line. The libertarian impulse is clearly deeply ingrained on both sides of the aisle.
Republican corruption
Donald Trump — while certainly not a consistent libertarian — personifies the self-absorbed amoral pragmatism that characterizes the now dominant variety of libertarianism. When he became the nominee in 2016, leading Republicans thought they could make good use of him — and his large number of energized followers — to achieve their policy goals.
They convinced themselves that striking a deal with such a deeply flawed person wouldn’t corrupt them. Their negative view of government and their amoral transactional approach to politics — in short, their libertarianism — clouded their vision and made them more susceptible to Trump’s appeal.
Gillis Harp is professor of history at Grove City College.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.