Canadian wildfires notwithstanding, Allegheny County has achieved record improvements in our air and water quality, all while protecting existing jobs, through a collaboration between the county and its manufacturing and industrial partners. But a proposal from the Environmental Protection Agency to further tighten federal air quality standards could put all of that at risk — after nearly three years of surpassing the existing benchmarks for the first time ever.
Just when we succeed, the goal posts are being moved.
What’s happening
Here’s what is happening: The EPA, a federal agency, is reviewing air quality standards that two years ago it decided needed no changes. It is also now considering tightening the standards that were shown then to protect human health and the environment just two short years ago. In the interim, our air quality has been the best on record.
Should this proposal become reality, the consequences could be immediate and dire: if Allegheny County does not comply and does not develop a plan to meet new standards, the federal government could stop federally supported infrastructure projects. These include support for transportation and highways, unless project developers can prove the construction will not increase emissions.
It is inarguable that air and water quality are of paramount importance to the quality of life in Western Pennsylvania. That is why so many in the county government have worked so hard with our industry partners to achieve the recent record results. The key to our success is a balanced approach that prioritizes environmental improvement while recognizing the economic lifeblood our industry partners provide.
Read More
One example of this partnership is U.S. Steel. The company by its actions has demonstrated its full commitment to our shared goals, investing over $100 million a year at its Mon Valley Works to lower its environmental footprint — despite wrongly being painted as the sole source of the county’s emissions by activists who fundraise by manufacturing “crises.”
Activists then turn to blame a corporate “enemy” and try to achieve either a legal or regulatory outcome that is always unbalanced, often unfair, and rarely motivated by altruism. Narrowly focused, these groups ignore the big picture of what companies like U.S. Steel bring to our community in terms of jobs, livelihoods, economic growth and donations that bring millions of dollars to our community organizations.
As the largest industrial employer in Allegheny County, U.S. Steel has proven a reliable source of good-paying jobs for generations of hard-working men and women including members of the United Steelworkers, the Building Trades and local contractors for 120 years. That is a substantial contribution to the families and fabric of our community.
U.S. Steel employs more than 3,000 people at its Mon Valley Works. The majority of of whom live in Allegheny County and Mon Valley communities and are our neighbors, sending their children to our schools, coaching little league teams, volunteering in their communities and churches, and paying taxes. They are a driving force of our local economy.
The Mon Valley Works alone generates $4.6 billion in economic output each year, according to the Allegheny Conference on Community Development. But that is just a fragment of what the steel industry generates for Pennsylvania, according to a 2023 report from The Pennsylvania Steel Alliance prepared by the Allegheny Conference.
Industry contribution
Overall, the steel industry contributes more than 123,000 jobs to the state, $55.3 billion in economic output and wages that are almost 25% higher than the industry average. Those are significant contributions and the kind of economic activity that Gov. Josh Shapiro has said he is hoping to attract more of.
That is a move in the right direction. But to make Pennsylvania more business-friendly, our county must lead and increase collaboration that makes our major employers like U.S. Steel feel as if they are welcome and that their actions as a responsible community member are not vilified.
We question what impact more stringent regulations will have when U.S. Steel is already using advanced, state-of-the-art technologies and safety protocols to protect our air quality, exceeding EPA and Pennsylvania standards. There is a huge gap between the reality of what’s possible and the demands made by a handful of activist groups.
We respectfully urge the EPA to carry out their important duties with impartiality and an eye firmly on a balanced approach.
Sam DeMarco (R) is Allegheny County councilman at large and Bob Macey (D) is the District 9 representative on the Allegheny County Council.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.