Young women fleeing abusive relationships or trying to escape from sex trafficking often have few safe places to turn. They may be estranged from their family or even separated by thousands of miles. Broke, scared and traumatized, these women often find sanctuary in the caring embrace of women’s shelters.
These safe havens provide women more than just a secure place to sleep; they provide trauma counseling, career training and guidance on how to start a new life.
Given the vital role such shelters provide to women in their communities, you might think that lawmakers would make supporting these shelters — and the women they serve — a priority during the legislative season.
Instead, the Pennsylvania General Assembly is currently considering HB 300, a proposal that would enshrine both sexual orientation and gender identity into state non-discrimination law — and that would put a target on individual consciences and women’s shelters across the commonwealth. Over the past several years, we’ve witnessed the weaponization of similar laws in other states to coerce individuals into speaking messages that violate their deepest convictions and to jeopardize the safety and equal opportunities of women and girls.
Laws and policies like HB 300 have been used to force religious schools and colleges to compromise their long-standing beliefs regarding marriage and sexual ethics. Teachers have been threatened with termination under these policies unless they refer to a student with pronouns that don’t correspond to sex and lie to parents about a child’s struggle with gender confusion. Young women have lost championship medals and had their records crushed by males permitted to compete with them.
And women’s shelters have been charged with violating these “non-discrimination” laws for refusing to take in men identifying as women, despite the emotional, psychological and physical risk this would pose to the vulnerable women staying there. For instance, Anchorage, Alaska, city officials tried to deploy such an ordinance against a faith-based women’s shelter after the shelter referred an inebriated and injured man to a hospital and paid for his taxi ride there instead of allowing him to share sleeping quarters with abused and homeless women.
When confronted with stories like this, lawmakers who support sexual orientation and gender identity laws often downplay these harms, claiming that such violations of their citizens’ constitutionally protected freedoms would never happen in their state.
But not state Rep. Emily Kinkead, D-North Side. She referred to concerns about housing men in women’s shelters as “using women as a shield” — in other words, the concerns of vulnerable women don’t matter in the face of the demands of gender ideology.
Women in shelters because of domestic violence or other sexual trauma are at a higher risk of experiencing mental health conditions. According to the National Center for PTSD, women who have been raped or sexually assaulted are more likely to experience major depression and anxiety, alcohol and drug abuse, and PTSD symptoms like flashbacks and nightmares. In addition, many survivors report feeling scared or nervous around men after experiencing abuse which is why it’s so important for these women to have access to a space where they can feel safe from male aggression or threats.
Women's shelters are a place where women can go to escape their abusers, and allowing men into these spaces takes away this sense of privacy and safety.
There is real harm when our laws ignore the truth about the innate differences between women and men — and women bear the brunt of that harm. That’s why Pennsylvania should reject HB 300 and instead prioritize the needs of vulnerable women, children and families.\
Matt Sharp is senior counsel with Alliance Defending Freedom (@ADFLegal) and director of its Center for Legislative Advocacy.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.