I’ve never been to a drag show. I don’t want to ever go to a drag show. If you want to go to a drag show I’m fine with that as long as I don’t have to go, too.
Still, I couldn’t help but notice that the Republican Party’s production of “Drag Show Madness” has come to my neck of the woods in the form of proposed legislation by Pennsylvania State Rep. Aaron Bernstine. (His district covers parts of Lawrence and Butler counties.)
Bernstine is pushing for a law that would classify drag shows as adult entertainment. He wants to regulate these performances as adult book stores and strip clubs are regulated, banning admission to anyone under age 18 and not allowing them on public property or in areas that can be seen by minors.
The sad part is that a legitimate concern about what types of entertainment children are exposed to is lost in the rhetoric. It’s another casualty in the Republican Party’s ongoing culture war, instigated not out of concern with children and to address a real issue, but with the goal of dividing us to enhance their political chances.
In this case, he is pushing a false premise. He’s claiming that all drag shows are alike and thus should all be treated the same. Sometimes nuance is the enemy of hysteria.
Sarah Warbelow is legal director of the Human Rights Campaign, an LGBTQ advocacy group. She acknowledged that “Drag performances, like all sorts of other performances, run the gamut in terms of who they’re designed for. There are certainly some drag performances that are intended for adult audiences, just like there are R-rated movies. And then there are other performances that are for all ages, like G-rated movies.”
Read More
Bernstine is right when he says young children shouldn’t be exposed to “sexually charged content.” But his overreaching bill is overkill looking for a sound bite. It doesn’t help with the problem he identifies.
He actually gives the real answer himself: “It’s long been considered rational to protect minors from sexually explicit entertainment — it’s why we require warning labels and ratings on music and movies. Parents would be outraged if schools were playing X-rated movies in the classroom.”
There you go. We need a rating system for these shows, classifying which are designed for adults and which are designed for kids, with strong penalties for those that don’t follow the script.
Bernstine also talked about “parental rights.” What about the rights of parents who don’t agree with him on this issue? Those who believe that a child-oriented event — like Drag Queen Story Hour — would be a fun, positive experience for their children. Don’t they have a say? Wouldn’t it make more sense to just allow parents to opt out their children if the content offended them?
Republicans like to talk about local government control, but in this case, Bernstine wants the state to impose its will — his will — upon school districts, which are government entities in and of themselves. If a school district can’t police itself in things like this, then there’s a local remedy: school board elections.
By the way, Drag Queen Story Hours are held in schools with the aim of teaching children general diversity and acceptance through readings and shows.
Acceptance. Now there’s an interesting term. Maybe if we had more of that we wouldn’t have had more than two dozen bills introduced in 14 states by Republican lawmakers in what the Washington Post characterizes as “an abrupt movement that has emerged this year amid a wider conservative backlash to expanded LGBTQ rights.”
Or maybe last year there wouldn’t have been 315 proposals to restrict LGBTQ rights introduced in state legislatures across the country — triple the number of similar bills introduced in 2019 — according to figures from the Human Rights Campaign.
Or maybe a recent survey by The Trevor Project wouldn’t have shown that 45 percent of the 34,000 respondents ages 13 to 24 seriously considered attempting suicide in the prior year.
A man in a dress reading a story to your son or clowning around and dancing on stage isn’t going to inspire him to change his sexual orientation or his preference. If you believe in God, then blame him because, as I understand it, he created all of us as individuals, not robots.
This is still another ploy by an extremist party that has no plans, no policies, and no interest in real governing. For those running around with their pants on fire about this non-issue, here’s a suggestion:
Just wear a dress.
Rick Elia, a former newspaper reporter living in Lawrence County, writes the political blog Musings of a Nobody. His previous article was “America must invest in its children.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.