Imagine that you’ve been admitted to a teaching hospital for a scheduled surgery. When you wake up from anesthesia, you feel wetness between your legs. It’s blood — blood, although your surgery had nothing to do with anything “down there.”
You wonder if your period started — although it’s not due for another two weeks. You call the nurse over and learn that, when you were under anesthesia, a medical student practiced a “routine pelvic exam” on you.
This situation continues to haunt you. So you contact the hospital and are reminded that you signed a consent form agreeing to medical students participating in your care. That apparently included a “routine pelvic exam,” though you had naturally thought they were going to help with your surgery, not do anything else.
You’re stunned. Why would you ever think the permission included a pelvic exam?
You can’t shake the sense of violation.
You’re not alone in your disbelief and horror. You’re among the ranks of patients admitted to academic medical centers for surgeries unrelated to their reproductive system who also received so-called “routine pelvic exams” without being specifically informed in advance and without giving explicit consent.
Read More
Some patients never learn that they had such an exam. Others, like you, do.
You, those other patients, and, frankly, anyone who hears about this share a sense of “shock and awe” that this can happen — that this does happen.
Furthermore, as these exams are “routine,” they’re common practice at many academic medical facilities. In fact, physicians and teaching hospitals in more than half of the states aren’t required to obtain explicit consent before performing pelvic exams on anesthetized patients. Thus, unauthorized pelvic exams, or “UPEs,” continue.
So why does this happen?
It’s argued that pelvic exams conducted under anesthesia enable medical trainees to practice on patients whose muscles are completely relaxed. This state of total relaxation coupled with the patient’s lack of consciousness make it easier for novices to learn to examine the female reproductive anatomy without awkwardness.
While that may be true, why must this be done on patients who weren’t given a chance to specifically consent in advance?
Some in the medical establishment fear that patients won’t agree to such exams. So, it becomes a case of don’t ask, don’t tell. This approach, which violates patient autonomy, is “excused” because some believe that these exams pose “no harm” — by which they mean no physical harm, as if there weren’t other kinds of harms.
This blatantly ignores psychological harms that arise from breaches of trust occurring when a patient is in their most vulnerable state. In this case, the unconscious patient has entrusted their body to the care of medical practitioners under the belief that those providers have their best interests in mind. This violation of trust and the resulting distress line up with evidence that unequivocally demonstrates unauthorized pelvic exams have devastating impacts on patients’ mental health.
The very real harms and abuses of patient autonomy inherent in this teaching practice have been known for decades. A 1988 study suggested that teaching hospitals should specifically include the practice in the consent form before allowing students to conduct such “routine” exams on anesthetized patients.
A second 1988 study echoed this recommendation. In 2003, the American Association of Medical Colleges (2003) objected to the practice. Despite these calls for action, the practice prevailed. In the early 2000s, it again became a subject of discussion, with studies investigating the impacts on patients and medical trainees, including undermining respect for patients and undercutting informed consent.
In long-delayed responses, the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology (2020), and the Association of Professors of Gynecology and Obstetrics (2019) spoke out against pelvic exams to which the patients had not given explicit consent. Yet, this hasn’t proven sufficient because these interdictions lack repercussions.
It has fallen to state legislatures to take action. Currently, only 19 states have enacted informed consent requirements prior to the performance of pelvic exams on anesthetized patients. While it’s too early to tell if these laws go far enough, it’s progress.
Pennsylvania remains conspicuously among the states without legislation. Despite a bill introduced in 2021, the proposed legislation has been hung up in the House Committee on Health. It’s time to ban unauthorized pelvic exams everywhere — including in Pennsylvania.
Priya Devanarayan, a graduating senior at Pennsylvania State University, will enter the university’s College of Medicine’s MD program in the fall. Michele Mekel is the associate director of the university’s Bioethics Program and an associate teaching professor of bioethics and humanities.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.